Robert Whitcomb: Yes, R.I. Progress; Conn. Cities Challenge; Train Stories

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Robert Whitcomb: Yes, R.I. Progress; Conn. Cities Challenge; Train Stories

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist
“Rest is not idleness, and to lie sometimes on the grass under trees on a summer's day, listening to the murmur of the water, or watching the clouds float across the sky, is by no means a waste of time.’’

-- John Lubbock (1834-1913), English politician, philanthropist and polymath

 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

I’m skeptical about rankings, whether US News & World Report’s college appraisals or Money magazine’s “Best Places to Retire’’ or others of that ilk.  They all end up comparing apples with oranges in varying degrees.

 

So I don’t think that CNBC’s raising Rhode Island’s “Top States’’ economic ranking to 45 from 50 means that much. And there are many reasons to live or not live in a state besides the criteria used in such rankings.

 

Still, the ranking writers did mention some things about which Rhode Islanders should be pleased.  As Scott Cohn, the study’s lead analyst, wrote:

 

“Let's put this in perspective. Finishing in 45th place would be nothing to crow about were it not for the fact that this is Rhode Island's best finish since we began rating the states in 2007. Just one year ago the Ocean State finished dead last. The improvement is no accident. Every time we rank Rhode Island at or near the bottom, state officials take it to heart. ‘Take a fresh look at Rhode Island,’ Gov. Gina Raimondo urged us last year, pointing to a slate of reforms. Sure enough, Rhode Island's economy notched a solid improvement this year. Other things — like the nation's worst infrastructure — will take more time, but baby steps. Baby steps.”

 

Meanwhile, U.S. News ranks Rhode Island 18th in the nation for economic stability and potential. Not bad at all.

 

RI moved up 5 spots from 50 to 45 in the CNBC Top States for Business
Well, some of the steps that Ms. Raimondo have taken will take some time to work their way through the economy. Perhaps the most important is her “RhodeWorks’’ project to fix the Ocean State’s worst-in-the nation transportation infrastructure. As part of this, she was willing to take on the lobby for truckers, who do 80-90 percent of the damage to the state’s roads and bridges, and set up a tolling system for them. Also very important is the Raimondo administration’s at least partial success in trying to bring spiraling Medicaid costs under control.

 

It’s far  too early to judge the effectiveness of  the governor’s deal-making with big companies to get them to expand or move to the state. A big question: Will they keep their implied promises on job creation, and, for that matter, will they stay in the state? Most companies break their promises.

 

And will the governor, who gained national fame as public-pension reformer, have the courage to veto two horrendous special-interest bills just approved by the General Assembly – one to allow the indefinite extension of municipal labor contracts and the other to let public-safety employees retire with tax-free disability pensions based on developing the sort of common illnesses such as heart disease that anyone can get. Both these measures, pushed through a General Assembly rife with public-employee-union conflicts of interest, would blow big holes in many municipal budgets.

 

Having said that, even cynical Rhode Islanders (i.e., probably most Rhode Islanders) should applaud the progress made in the past few years.

 

xxx

 

Most of us complain that summers go too fast in New England. A big reason is that we try to cram too many social, travel and other experiences into a fairly short season of warm weather and rigidly consider the season to come to a halt with Labor Day.

 

Instead of a time that’s supposed to be more relaxing than the rest of the year we’re going nonstop in a whirr. Perhaps if we (nonstudents and teachers) more seriously considered September a summer month (which most of it is, technically) and moved more summer stuff there, we’d feel less rushed.

 

 

xxx

 

President Trump
It’ll be up to the lawyers, especially Special Counsel Robert Mueller, a Republican and former FBI director, to decide whether to take information about the Trump crowd’s plotting with their pals in the Kremlin to a grand jury and seek perjury, conspiracy and/or treason charges. The legal questions seem murky.

 

What is clear is how thick the Trump people are with the Russians. Trump’s lies about his and his family’s and retainers’ links to Vladimir Putin’s regime are layer by layer being revealed. Of course, President Trump has had ties with government officials and politically connected business people in that nation for two decades. Mr. Trump, a long-time crook himself, has always liked dealing with corrupt regimes – simpler to cut deals with them than with officials answerable to the public in democracies that mandate at least a modicum of transparency.

 

Donald Trump’s public remarks tend to recall the late writer Mary McCarthy’s line about Stalinist American playwright and memoirist Lillian Hellman: “I think every word she writes is false, including ‘and’ and ‘but.'”

 

What might be surprising in all this is how little the media note that these relationships involve collaboration with a deeply corrupt dictatorship that invades neighboring nations, murders political foes and is engaged in cyber war against the United States. After all, Donald Trump Jr., Jared Kushner and the other dubious characters who make up the president’s inner circle have not been collaborating with, say, French, British, Japanese, German representatives, people from nations that share Western values.

 

Mr. Trump, who obviously knew in advance all about Donald Trump Jr.’s now famous meeting at Trump Tower with a Kremlin-connected lawyer, is presiding over a group that thinks it’s fine to have close relations with an enemy of America.

 

Over the years, the Trump tribe has developed considerable familiarity with mobsters in some Trump casino and other projects. Perhaps that’s why they’re comfortable dealing with Putin’s kleptocratic Kremlin crew, who have many Mafia characteristics, including in how they deal with uncooperative people.

 

xxx

 

My background is mostly New England/New York/Midwest Republican. America needs a thoughtful center-right party, and not the expanding special-interest swamp of the current GOP. (Yes, there are plenty of special interests in the Democratic Party, but none so self-enriching and lacking in principle  -- or politically successful! -- as the current Republican ones.)

 

I have been intrigued by the solidity of the support for Trump amongst the overwhelmingly white folks who are the core of his backers.  Incidentally, as it turns out, their income as a group is over, not under, the national median – contrary to the assumption during and after the election campaign.

 

They support him in the face of more than 40 years of his easily researchable frauds, lies, sexual depravity and other offenses that, presumably, most would find intolerable amongst their own family and friends.

 

Why? One reason is that for several decades we’ve been becoming a post-literate world. Many Trump backers get most of their “news and information’’ from cable TV – mostly from that organ of the plutocracy called Fox News, which naturally loves Trump, because the plutocracy is where his loyalties lie. And Trump, like any good demagogue, knows how to use TV – after all, he was a TV star himself. He realizes that presentation (“production values’’), not facts or truth, is all. And Trump, like any good demagogue, knows how to mine resentments, especially in a world where social and economic change are happening at a nerve-racking pace.

 

Finally, there’s the fact that it’s embarrassing to admit that you’ve been conned.

 

 

xxx

 

President Trump, in a rousing July 6 speech in Poland, talked about what he sees as the grave threat to Western Civilization. He called on the West to defend “the great civilized ideas: individual liberty, representative government, and the rule of law under God” and criticized “the shyness of some of us in the West about standing for these ideals.”

 

I agree with the words, except maybe for his reference to God, which implies a religious state. Western Civilization has done more good for humanity than any other civilization. But the speech is best read if you don’t know who delivered it!

 

Russia's Putin
I chuckled at his praise of liberal democracy given his own behavior, which has included an affinity for dictators and his threats against such sometimes inconvenient aspects of Western Civ as freedom of the press and an independent judiciary. And it would have been nice if he’d mentioned three of the glories of   the West – skepticism, free inquiry and a respect for the facts.

 

He also underplayed the growing aggression of the world’s two most powerful dictatorships – Russia and China. – and he over-emphasized a challenge that we’ll always have with us but that can’t defeat us—Islamic terrorism. Trump focused on that rather diffuse threat because it’s much less scary than Russia and China.

 

He also placed too much emphasis on the glories of nationalism and not enough on the unifying qualities of the broader Western culture More than just being an American, I’m happy to be a citizen of the West, which people around the world by the many millions want to move to because of its values and, related to them, its wealth. Mr. Trump is a comically inappropriate ambassador of Western Civilization but I’m glad he said he approved of it and delivered his speech well. Good production values!

 

xxx

 

The Trump administration wants to kill “Net Neutrality’’ which mandates that such Internet Service Providers as Comcast, Verizon and AT&T treat all online content, apps and services equally. This means that ISPs are barred from using their market dominance to block competing content providers or prevent access to other providers by intentionally speeding up or slowing the flow of content. Thus, the current rule keeps the Internet open to a wide range of content creators and transmitters.

 

If the Trumpsters, buoyed by ISP campaign contributions, succeed in killing Net Neutrality then free speech, including journalism, will take a big hit as the big ISPs manipulate the Web to maximize their profit.

 

As Reporters Without Borders declared accurately: “Lack of neutrality would mean restricted access to certain online content, additional charges to visit certain Web pages, censored text and video content, and arbitrarily slowed connections to certain platforms.’’  The public should make its views known on this issue before it’s too late.

 

xxx

 

Financial failures
Derek Thompson, writing in The Atlantic’s online service, has some interesting takes on Connecticut’s current fiscal problems. The state government has a huge deficit,  some cities are effectively bankrupt, taxes are amongst the highest in the nation and some big companies have fled. And yet the state remains the richest on a per-capita basis in America, albeit largely because of New York City-connected rich folks living in Fairfield County. (Massachusetts is  the second-richest; New Jersey the third.)

 

He notes some remarkably little reported reasons for the state’s ills: One is that Connecticut, like America in general, has lost much of its high-valued manufacturing, a sector for which  Connecticut was once famed around the world.  (I lived near Waterbury for four years in the early and mid-‘60s, from when I well remember the busy factories up and down the colorfully polluted Naugatuck River.)

 

Very highly paid people in finance, many of  them commuting to Manhattan but many doing their thing in Stamford and Greenwich, have offset some of this loss. However, finance, which of course follows the ups and downs of Wall Street, is more cyclical than manufacturing. And the latter provided a wider range of well-paying jobs to many more people than does finance.

 

Another important change that Mr. Thompson cited is that the big cities close to Connecticut --- especially New York and Boston – have become much safer and more attractive. Rich people and Millennials have been moving back into them, having grown bored with suburbs, even those as attractively sylvan as some on Connecticut’s strip of the Long Island Sound shoreline.

 

Conservatives who seem obsessed with high taxes above all else should note that some of the big companies pulling their headquarters from Connecticut are not exactly moving to low-tax venues. Consider that Aetna is leaving Hartford for Manhattan and General Electric has left Fairfield for Boston. They want the dynamism of those cities and are happy to pay for it.

 

The Nutmeg State has poor, high-crime and often badly run cities. If the state is to improve its long-term prospects, I and Mr. Thompson would agree, it needs to fix its cities. Hartford, which used to be a vibrant and mostly middle-class city before bad municipal government, ill-considered  “urban renewal’’ and other factors drove it into the ditch, is expected to go into official bankruptcy soon. That should let it start cleaning up its act and make it a place that people, especially young adults who might otherwise go to New York, would want to live and work in. That could help turn around the whole state. After all, Hartford is the state capital.

 

xxx

 

I’ve long been fond of New London, with its dramatic setting where the Thames River meets Long Island Sound, with its ferry service to Orient Point and Block Island, the submarine base across the river in Groton, the Coast Guard Academy, Connecticut College and other institutions. The city still has some glorious old – but badly maintained -- downtown buildings constructed in its ocean-shipping days, which included the whaling boom. But there’s not been the sort of architectural preservation that has saved much of downtown New Bedford, with a somewhat similar history as New London’s, from the wrecking ball.

 

To help protect and repair its gorgeous old downtown buildings, New London, as David Collins, of the local paper, The Day, has suggested, needs a downtown historic district as rigorous as New Bedford’s. It would then benefit more strongly from tourism and other synergies associated with its role as a ferry port through which many thousands of travelers, tourists and students go every year.

 

xxx

 

The proximity of lots of techies and major universities can trump taxes and weather. Thus Amazon is hiring 900 more people and plans to open up a facility in Boston’s Fort Point neighborhood.

 

xxx

 

Amtrak's new proposed route
Amtrak and commuter rail travelers face a summer of hell in and around New York’s Penn station as long overdue repairs are made to rail infrastructure there. There will be many delays. New Englanders traveling to New York might want to consider taking Metro North trains from Connecticut. Those terminate at Grand Central Station, not Penn Station. Hopefully within a decade the hellhole that is Penn Station will be replaced with something more gloriously fitting for the nation’s busiest train station.

 

In other train news, I was sorry to hear that plans for a new high-speed Amtrak route through southwestern Rhode Island and southeastern Connecticut have been held up or perhaps killed by local NIMBYs who assert  that the proposed route would have some bad local environmental effects.  In fact, the environmental effects would be minor. And by thwarting building along the most commonsensical route in the area, the foes would hurt the environment by ensuring that the train trip between Boston, New York and points south wouldn’t be as fast and competitive with driving as it should be.

 

This  would keep more cars on the roads, causing more pollution and perhaps necessitating more and/or wider roads. Highways, of course, are much wider than rail lines. This is yet another example of why America is the toughest place in the Developed World to build and repair infrastructure.

 

Still, there’s happy rail news. Amtrak’s Downeaster, which connects Boston and southern Maine, terminating in Brunswick, reported its second-highest number of passengers – 511,422, in fiscal 2017, which ended June 30. That’s up 9 percent from a year earlier and close to the record of 518,572 set in fiscal 2014.

 

People grow to love their trains – if they’re given the opportunity. Patricia Quinn, who runs the Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority, was quite right to crow: “These results are pretty impressive. Achieving near-record ridership in a year of low fuel prices and construction-related service interruption indicates that the Downeaster has come of age in solidifying a durable and loyal customer base.’’

 

xxx

 

Novelist Bernhard Schlink, a German lawyer and former judge, writes crisp, psychologically acute novels. I just read his The Woman on the Stairs (Pantheon Books), set in Germany and Australia. It involves a beautiful woman, a famous male painter who used her as a model, a rich businessman and a male lawyer, all of whom are brought together by a painting that remains an obsession over decades, as does the woman for the men as they age, even when she becomes old and sick.

 

At the heart of this addictive novel is the struggle to reconcile past and present selves, something that most of us go through. The plot sometimes stretches credulity but the insights are piercing.

 

xxx

 

In last year's campaign, Donald Trump made much of the wonderfulness of coal-mining and of his solidarity with coal miners and  workers in some other old industries. But this quote from a 1990 Time magazine interview with him suggests what he really thinks of these people. And he’s right: These people should do something else, which might include leaving Appalachia. We all have to accept permanent changes in the economy.

“The coal miner gets black-lung disease, his son gets it, then his son. If I had been the son of a coal miner, I would have left the damn mines. But most people don’t have the imagination — or whatever — to leave their mine. They don’t have 'it.'''


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.