Robert Whitcomb's Digital Diary: Amtrak's Blockage, Fall River's Amazon, & Clintons in Watch Hill

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Robert Whitcomb's Digital Diary: Amtrak's Blockage, Fall River's Amazon, & Clintons in Watch Hill

Robert Whitcomb
American Blockage; Make Providence Fairfield? The Over-the-Top Ocean House;  More Leaves to be Lost

 

You can see an  example of America’s relentless structural challenges in getting important infrastructure stuff done in efforts to block Amtrak’s proposed 30-mile Northeast Corridor bypass in southwest Rhode Island and southeastern Connecticut. The bypass is needed to slice 45 minutes to an hour off the Boston-New York run.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

 

The bypass would be an economic boon for New England by facilitating travel between the economic, technological and cultural powerhouses of Gotham and the Hub. It would also be an environmental boon by taking many people off the roads, reducing the need for road construction (and roads take up far more land than do railroads) and reducing air pollution. It would also move some of the Northeast Corridor line away from the coast – not a bad idea in a time of rising ocean levels.

 

But some locals in southeastern Connecticut and southwestern Rhode Island are determined to block the bypass and consign Amtrak to keeping its current  slow route. President Trump, in one of the relatively few accurate things he said during his campaign, noted: “We’re becoming a Third World country, because of our infrastructure, our airports, our roads.’’ He has also mentioned the crummy state of our railways.

 

America’s transportation infrastructure has long been sliding into Third World status.

 

Amtrak
The greater good is all too often sacrificed on the altar of local opposition, mostly by the affluent; by the absurd density of local, state and federal regulations, some of which contradict each other, and by a civil-law system that rewards a bankrupting litigiousness that delays needed public projects unto death.

 

New England’s best example of this pathology, before the Amtrak blockage, might be how one man – Bill Koch, of the famous right-wing Koch Brothers, managed to kill the Cape Wind project, whose wind turbines in the middle of Nantucket Sound would have provided 75 percent of the electrical needs of Cape Cod, Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard with no carbon emissions.

 

Mr. Koch didn’t want to look at the turbines, which on the area’s rare very clear days he would have seen in the far distance from his mansion in Osterville (on the south shore of the Cape), where he resides a few weeks every summer. The strong majority of Bay Staters wanted the project, but the common good  gets short shrift when an arrogant billionaire thinks he can control everything around him.

 

Philip K. Howard, who runs Common Good (commongood.org), the legal-and-regulatory-reform nonprofit organization, has been working very hard to find ways of streamlining regulations and discouraging relentless litigation in order to allow projects such as the Amtrak bypass to happen. It’s past time for changes that will stop small groups of people from blocking projects that are overwhelmingly positive for the vast majority of the population.

 

Meanwhile, we can’t  expect public-spirited leadership on the Amtrak bypass and many other important projects from state and local politicians. They’ll react in their usual timid and myopic way to the yelps of a small number of  NIMBYs, the wider public be damned.

 

xxx

 

A friend – a very successful businessman -- suggested to me the other day that Rhode Island  in general and Greater Providence in particular should market itself as a much more  culturally and otherwise interesting version of Fairfield County, Conn., and less as a freestanding economic center.  With the economic power of Boston closer to Providence by train than most of Fairfield County is to Manhattan, he’s on to something. But to do this, train service between Providence and Boston needs to be made more frequent and more parking be made available for travelers using the Providence and other Rhode Island train stations.

 

xxx

 

Ocean House - most overrated?
One of the more entertaining recent stories in New England was Richard C. Morais’s denunciation in the Dec. 20 Barron’s of the service at the pretentious Ocean House, in the Watch Hill section of Westerly. Mr. Morais approvingly quotes Penta Travels as calling it “America’s Most Overrated Hotel’’

 

But first it should be noted that the $147 million rebuilding of the 19th Century resort hotel with the money and close direction of Wall Street mogul Charles (“Chuck’’) Royce (of Greenwich, Conn., natch) was done beautifully, albeit with furnishings with the sort of faux aristocratic/WASP imagery promoted by that brander extraordinaire Ralph Lauren (ne Lifshitz and born in the Bronx – a delightfully American life  story). The hotel is heavy on model boats and Chinese vases. It employs some locals (in addition to its cheap labor from abroad) and is a major source of revenue to some local businesses.

 

Anyway,  Mr. Morais and his wife had a generally unpleasant stay in what Travel + Leisure magazine  in 2014 had called  the No. 1 resort in the  continental U.S.!

 

Mr. Morais’s tale of occasionally incompetent and arrogant service sounded pretty accurate to me,  at least based on a  couple of meals we had there (one of them blessedly paid for by somebody else). In any event, the pomposity of service at the hotel is likely to be  best tolerated by the sort of insecure customers who, among other things, want to feign not having to worry about money in a joint pitched to the rich and the wanna-look rich. Some are the same sort of people who stay in the tacky but expensive hotels, and buy the branded made-in-Asia junk, on which the con man Donald Trump puts his name.

 

Mr. Morais wrote:

“That night in the formal dining room, as at the spa {which also involved bad service}, we were handed menus without prices, as if we were faint-hearted Victorian women who couldn’t possibly handle seeing how much things cost. Again I was irritated. Then our obsequious waitress demanded to know our dessert choice before we had even started the meal, somehow under the impression we were on a simple Italian pensione meal plan. Our dinner, when it came—local oysters, halibut—was tasty enough, at $293 with a modest half-bottle of wine.

 

“But each course was introduced by ludicrously long and pretentious descriptions. Worse still, my wife and I tried to have a serious discussion over dinner, but the waiters interrupted us every few minutes, asking if everything was to our satisfaction. After the fifth or sixth such request, my wife whispered that it felt as if we had to reassure them of their job security.’’ Reign of terror at the Ocean House? Staff fearful of being shipped back to Sri Lanka or Mexico or Slovenia?

 

If the rumors about Hillary and Bill Clinton buying a place in Watch Hill turn out to be true,  maybe they can re-establish their frayed populist credentials by championing the rights of low-paid summer-resort workers. The Clintons have apparently stayed in the Ocean House and bought some books in Westerly’s  Savoy Bookshop and Café on their visit after the election. One rumor had it that they were looking at real estate to buy.

 

I’m glad that Mr. Royce has pumped a lot of money into the Westerly area.  And  in his piece Mr. Morais  sometime sounded rather pompously privileged himself.  However, in the same piece, he did have nice words about the Castle Hil Inn, Newport – very expensive,  but not in the stratosphere with the Ocean House.

 

xxx

 

Now that the most corrupt and sociopathic person ever to inhabit the White House is in charge, will  there be a reaction against his gaudy sleaze, as there was in the ‘30s in reaction to the Gatsby-like excesses of the ‘20s?  Will it again become fashionable again, even for the new rich, to show less exhibitionism, more selflessness and more low-key civic-mindedness? Probably not: America’s decline into civic decay, celebrity culture and willful ignorance seems unstoppable, lubricated by cable TV and “social’’ media, which turns out to be pretty anti-social.

 

Another big question, of course, is whether Mr. Trump’s protectionism will lead to the sort of trade war that helped intensify and lengthen the Great Depression after the Smoot-Hawley tariffs of 1930. It will be fun  to watch a Congress run by the Republicans rubber-stamp the protectionism even though the GOP has long prided itself as backing free trade. In the end, the configurations of political power and the associated spoils will trump (or Trump) principle.

 

Some economists have estimated that Smoot-Hawley and retaliatory tariffs by America's trading partners helped reduce U.S. exports and imports by more than half during the Depression, helping to drive American unemployment to 25 percent by March 1933.  History doesn’t repeat itself, but as Mr. Twain said, “there are rhythms’’ in it.

 

xxx

 

Amazon is already employing about 1,800 people in its new and gigantic fulfillment center in Fall River. That’s a big boost to the long  economically ailing ‘’Spindle City’’. But folks should remember that simultaneously Amazon is killing many thousands of jobs at brick-and-mortar stores, many of which are closing. By the way, Fall River’s setting on Mount Hope Bay one of the most beautiful on the East Coast. Yes, romantic Fall River.

 

xxx

 

Scientists say that the gypsy moths will be back in force this spring to continue the devastation of the southern New England woods we saw last year. The  ecological changes wrought by New England’s long drought are blamed.  The Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation reported:

 

“Recent drought conditions have limited the effectiveness of a soil-borne fungus, Entomophaga maimaiga, which has helped keep gypsy moth populations in check since the last large outbreak during the 1980s.”

 

 How many more years of this can the trees take?

 

Of course, we’ve been having a mild winter – so far. I noticed snow drops blooming on a south-facing strip of dirt near our house last weekend. I don’t think I’ve ever seen such early blooming. Seeing the flowers so early was, by turns, heartening and unsettling.

 

xxx

 

Naturally, like any corrupt would-be dictator, Donald Trump denounces “the media’’ (except of course for his mouthpiece Fox News and some other  friendly outlets).  Political leaders, and especially dictators, don’t like news media looking into their affairs, especially when their personal and business affairs have been as sleazy as Trump’s and his Mafia-style-family enterprise. But the Founders knew what they were doing when they made freedom of speech so important. Indeed they put it into the FIRST Amendment:

 

 

“Amendment I. Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.’’

 

It may be that most Americans don’t really believe in free speech  and serious journalism -- it can be unsettling, complicated and can undermine wishful thinking --- and  they don’t respect the hard, generally thankless and sometimes dangerous work of professional journalists as they seek the truth. But the public sure will miss free speech when it’s gone.

 

Now that Mr. Trump has broken yet another promise – this time about releasing his tax returns – all we can do is hope that a patriot will find a way of getting and releasing those tax return to the press so that we can see the extent of his debts to Russian and other unsavory characters at home and abroad and thus the extent of the security risk he poses to us. Such a release will also show that Mr. Trump is not nearly as rich as he has claimed.

 

This is from an interesting column,  by Leonid  Bershidsky, an exile from Russia, in Bloomberg News. The whole piece can be read at: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-01-23/the-numbers-are-in-fake-news-didn-t-work

 

Layoffs hitting journalism
“For us in the media business, it's easy to overestimate how much technology has changed the world. After all, we create the hype around new trends -- why shouldn't we believe it? And yet the underlying mechanics of age-old traditions like electoral democracy do not change as quickly as we might think. That should tell us something important. Instead of panicking about a ‘post-truth’ world, we should raise the bar for our own reporting and make it as persuasive and as fact-rich as we can.’’

 

A fine idea, but the journalism layoffs continue apace. Who will do this work?

 

xxx

 

I’ve written here about the revival of vinyl records and Polaroid type pictures. And now we have another back-to-the-future development. Just as many people want the richness of sound from vinyl records, so many people want the richer colors of images on film compared to those created digitally.

 

Thus  Eastman Kodak is selling a new movie camera that will shoot Super 8 film. At $2,000, it won’t be cheap but I predict that it will be successful. A famous bit of an irony: Kodak invented digital photography but didn’t know how to run with it and  the digital photography adapted by competitors nearly destroyed it.

 

 I was shocked to learn that Fujifilm’s sales of Instax film-based cameras are exceeding those of its digital cameras.

 

Patty Jenkins, a  Hollywood director and screenwriter, put it well:

 

"People like to think that digital mediums can do anything film can do, nowadays, but that simply isn’t true. Digital is great for certain things, but it is still different. There are plenty of looks, feelings and qualities that only film can do, and you simply cannot capture digitally."

 

Next stop: A revival of fountain pens?

 

xxx

 

Wachusett Mountain Ski Area, in Princeton, Mass., has, so far in this puny winter, used more than 95 million of gallons of water to make snow!  I can imagine how much the really big northern New England areas have used. The Wachusett president, Jeff Crowley, says that’s about the amount it usually uses in an entire season, reports the Worcester Business Journal. I wonder what effect putting so much water on a little mountain has on the area’s environment.

 

Not only does snow-making equipment let ski areas get through poor real-snowfall seasons, but man-made snow is said to last longer than the natural stuff. I suppose that having all that slow-melting “snow’’ on the mountain late in the season might stretch out local streams’ spring run. But snow-making also causes erosion, which washes sediment into streams, which among other things hurts trout and other fishing.  And running the machines uses a lot of energy.

 

xxx

 

Hillbilly Elegy, J.D. Vance’s  vivid and often moving memoir of growing up in a  family from eastern Kentucky that moved to what became the rust belt of southwestern Ohio, has some great stuff about a white working class in distress. It shows how a culture too rife with defeatism, tribalism, violence, bigotry and bitterness can discourage people from improving their lot. But I wish Mr. Vance had given us some insight into what public policy can do to make things better.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.