Whitcomb: Teacher Revolts; Sinclair Speech; A Gondola Over the Traffic? Bring Back Blue Laws?

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Whitcomb: Teacher Revolts; Sinclair Speech; A Gondola Over the Traffic? Bring Back Blue Laws?

Robert Whitcomb, columnist

“The sun was warm but the wind was chill.
You know how it is with an April day
When the sun is out and the wind is still,
You're one month on in the middle of May.
But if you so much as dare to speak,
A cloud comes over the sunlit arch,
A wind comes off a frozen peak,
And you're two months back in the middle of March.’’

 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

-- From Robert Frost’s “Two Tramps in Mud Time’’

 

“{T}he current appeal of machismo as political style, the wall-building and xenophobia, the mythology and race theory, the fantastical promises of national restoration – these are not cures, but symptoms of what is slowly revealing itself to all: nation states everywhere are in an advanced state of political and moral decay from which they cannot individually extricate themselves.

“Why is this happening? In brief, 20th-century political structures are drowning in a 21st-century ocean of deregulated finance, autonomous technology, religious militancy and great-power rivalry….”

 

-- Rana Dasgupta, a British-Indian novelist and essayist writing in The Guardian. Hit this link to read his entire essay:

 

 

“It’s not America to me that you just get something in the mail.’’

 

-- Rhode Island state Rep. Antonio Giarusso complaining about tickets mailed to people nailed for speeding by those controversial speed cameras in Providence meant to protect students near schools (while raising revenue).

 

Gee, I get bills in the mail from governments all the time.

 

 

It’s hard to integrate the bright sun of April and the flowers pushing up (life will out!) with the wintry wind. Confusing and depressing. Reminds me of those weird school “spring vacations’’ in April, with the earth struggling to turn green in the cold rain, and summer vacation, though it was to start in just a few weeks, seeming so far away. It was the bland season.

 

xxx

 

Teachers protesting in Providence
The states that have recently been experiencing the worst unrest among public-school teachers – West Virginia, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Kansas, and Arizona -- are Red States whose political and economic leaders – call them oligarchs – have been obsessed with tax cuts, especially those favoring companies and rich individuals. They’re also right-to-work states, which means in practice weak labor rights and low wages.

 

The result has been the impoverishment of many teachers, overcrowded classrooms,  crumbling school physical plants and antiquated supplies, such as 50-year-old schoolbooks.

 

But now,  despite the traditionally weak teacher unions in Red States, things have gotten so bad in public education there that many thousands of teachers are striking back, so to speak, making heavy use of social media, among other tools. Some are staging wildcat strikes, led by desperate grassroots organizers operating outside official unions.

 

The deterioration of education (and other public services) in most tax-cut-obsessed Red States is a major reason why their economies tend to lag behind relatively high-tax Blue States. The best-paying jobs require good educations. Red States also tend to have the highest percentages of such problems as drug abuse and childbirth outside of marriage. Again, that can be partly correlated with low taxes and thus poor public services.

 

But many voters in Red States, inspired by the president’s nativist calls and the siren calls of tax cuts,  will probably continue to vote against their own socio-economic interests. The best book on this phenomenon of what’s been called “anti-elitist conservatism’’ (which benefits the very rich elite, such as the Koch Brothers, the most) is Tom Frank’s What’s the Matter With Kansas.

 

xxx

 

There’s nothing all that new per se about right-wing Sinclair Broadcast Group forcing its stations to run pro-Trump propaganda on its 193 TV stations.  Some newspaper chains have long dictated the wording of certain editorials (including candidate endorsements) to be run by their local properties. I wrote a few myself at the order of the owners, sometimes not happily.

 

But television is a more powerful and visceral medium than print.

 

Sinclair Broadcasting
There are other things about Sinclair that are more worrisome than the editorials, which of course Sinclair has every right to order. One is that the Trump-controlled Federal Communications Commission has been throwing out long-established rules meant to encourage local control of broadcast stations. These included the “main studio rule,’’ in which radio and TV stations had to have physical studios in the areas where they were licensed to operate. Then there’s the Trump FCC’s repeal of another old rule that barred TV stations in a market from merging if it would result in leaving fewer than eight independently owned stations in a market.

 

Perhaps most ominously, the FCC’s chairman, Ajit Pai, also wants to end a rule that bars a single broadcast company from reaching more than 39 percent of U.S. households. Ending that rule would be delightful for Sinclair:  It’s seeking approval to buy Tribune Media, the acquisition of whose stations would give Trump’s favorite TV chain access to about 75 percent of households!

 

Meanwhile, it should be noted, Sinclair is noted as an enthusiastic cost-cutter of its stations’ local news coverage.

 

This sort of national consolidation and automation of media, especially by a company so closely tied to a single political party and its demagogic leader, is not good for democratic civil society. But about the only thing you can do about it is to tell pollsters that you won’t watch Sinclair stations (which include WJAR, Channel 10, in Providence, which before Sinclair bought it was a  very respectable station) and discourage local advertisers from buying time on them. And push your senators and representatives to pressure the FCC to nix Sinclair’s purchase of Tribune Media. If you love Trump, however, you can express your gratitude to Sinclair’s servants for telling you what you want to hear. Maybe they’ll put you on air.

 

xxx

 

A lot of people in rural Exeter, R.I., apparently don’t want big wind- or solar-powered electricity generation in their town, which includes small if woodsy landholdings as well as some big estates of rich people. It would be nice if all big solar- and wind-energy facilities could be put on such places as vacant parking lots at closed malls, at Superfund sites and the roofs of closed factories but we’ll need more space than that to move very deeply into a post-fossil-fuel world.

 

John Scuncio, former police chief on nearby and also rural Hopkinton, touted solar panels and wind turbines because “when you tie up a piece of property with solar or wind’’ you remove land that could otherwise be developed for housing. But I’d guess that most people in Exeter don’t want more houses or large green energy projects, although they do want electricity, to be generated somewhere.

 

Exeter is an example of why housing costs are so high in New England:  Legal (“snob zoning”) and informal restrictions on expanding the supply of housing units make existing housing that much more expensive.

 

xxx

 

U.S. Postal Service
I think that the U.S. Postal Service does a super job considering the heavy burdens that the government imposes on it. The first, of course, is that it’s required to provide service in all sorts of loss-making places. It can’t pick and choose where it will deliver mail, unlike UPS and FedEx.

 

Few Americans are aware of another heavy – and unfair – burden: Congress has mandated that the USPS must prefund its estimated long-term pension and health-care liabilities, which are hundreds of billions of dollars. (Of course, the estimates can change over the life of the liability.) No other delivery company has to do this.

 

As the  Postal Service’s Inspector General in 2015 wrote:

 

“What if your credit card company told you: ‘You will charge a million dollars on your credit card during your life; please enclose the million dollars in your next bill payment. It’s the responsible thing to do.’ Doesn’t seem quite right, does it?’’

 

The result has been that the Postal Service doesn’t have enough money left over to adequately modernize itself and is understaffed in many places.

 

I mention this, of course, after reading of Trump’s attacks on Amazon for allegedly underpaying the Postal Service. Shipping Amazon packages has been a boon for the USPS, offsetting part of the huge loss at the service from consumers moving to email from snail mail. That isn’t to say that the Postal Service couldn’t negotiate a better deal. (And maybe in the fullness of time the Antitrust Division will do the right thing and break up the retail behemoth, as it also should break up Google and Facebook.  More competition usually means cut prices.)

 

In any event, thank you, postal workers, for your great work. And particular thanks to those working at Providence’s big post office, one of the most efficient in the country.

 

xxx

 

Boston,MA
Boston’s prosperity has led to ever longer commutes on highways that are gridlocked daily. Some commuters are in their cars as much as four hours a day as they struggle to move back and forth between exurban and suburban homes and dense downtown Boston. It’s so bad that Millennium Partners, a big developer, proposes that a gondola be installed to take workers from South Station over the increasingly clogged (and sometimes flooded) streets to the Seaport District! Millennium would contribute $100 million to the project, in which 15,000 people a day, mostly workers, would be transported.

 

That the commuting nightmare continues to worsen in and around Boston surprises me a bit because so much work can be done on computers at home these days and Boston, as a high-tech center, is particularly computer-bound. Further, Boston has more mass transit than most big American cities. But it’s clearly far from enough to serve the booming metropolis.

 

Providence and other Boston satellite cities should redouble their efforts to snare commuting-weary businesses from “The Hub.’’

 

xxx


 

Rhode Island’s state government has launched a new program to buy farms at their current full appraised developable value and then sell them to new farmers for, say, 20 percent of that price -- at their appraised agricultural value (their value solely as farms, not at, for instance, their potential value as a subdivision of McMansions). The idea, of course, is to protect local farmland, encourage the local production of food and boost local food-sector entrepreneurs. The money will come from $3 million from the most recent state environmental bond issue. Apparently, the Ocean State is the only state that has decided to buy farmland to then sell at a price way under its full market value. Many states do offer tax credits and loans to farmers.

Some nonagricultural entrepreneurs must be asking why they can’t get the state to buy other kinds of enterprises at their full market value and then sell it to the entrepreneurs for a price that’s 20 percent of its value….

To read Jennifer McDermott’s Associated Press article on this unusual program, please hit this link:

 

xxx

 

The internal promotion of URI’s associate head basketball coach, David Cox, to succeed the departing Dan Hurley as head coach instead of an out-of-state celebrity such as, for example, ousted University of Louisville coach Rick Pitino, was refreshingly proper and, well, old-fashioned.

 

xxx
 

Poland is bringing back what we used to call the “Blue Laws’’ in New England, which mandated that most stores be closed on Sundays. Exceptions will include drugstores, cafes and gas stations. Sounds about how the Blue Laws worked here in the ‘50s.

 

The new law starts with banning retail trade two Sundays a month but then moves it to three and then four a month.

 

The idea is to give retail workers a rest and to encourage more family-and-friends time in our frantically materialistic times. I think it’s basically a good idea. I do, however, worry that some stores would push their employees to work longer hours on Fridays and Saturdays because there would be more customers compressed into those days. And of course it would further boost online shopping – more bad news for physical stores and the energy and sense of community they give to communities.

 

Still, I think that most Americans would come to like the quiet of a Blue Laws Sunday, once they kicked the seven-day-a-week shopping addiction. There might even be a revival of Sunday dinners, starring a roast something.

 

xxx
 

Marble House, Newport
The Newport Planning Board has cleared a plan for prepackaged sandwiches, salads, soft drinks, coffee and tea to be sold in the spectacular Chinese Tea House at Marble House, one of the famous great mansions on Bellevue Avenue.

 

Happily, there hasn’t been the vast controversy of the sort that has attended the construction of the welcome center (café and restrooms, instead of Port-a-Johns, of all things!) at the Breakers –a multi-year battle that drew bemused national attention. Many thought it was a silly if entertaining example of a quintessentially Newport dispute.  Proposals for physical changes often elicit incendiary responses in the City by the Sea. Witness the current pushback against Salve Regina University’s plan to build new dorms on its campus in the mansion district.

 

xxx

 

The New York Post ran a useful, or exasperating, article last month headlined “How (Mitch) McConnell and {Elaine} Chao used political power to make their family rich.’’

 

McConnell, of course, is the Senate majority leader and Chao the current U.S. transportation secretary (and former commerce secretary, under George W. Bush ).

 

They and some other politicos of both parties leverage their influence over government policy to make their families (and therefore themselves) rich or richer.

 

U.S. Senator Mitch McConnell
Chao’s family fortune is based on the Foremost Group, a big shipping company founded in New York and still chaired by Elaine’s father, James, a native of China and classmate of former Chinese President Jiang Zemin. Foremost is heavily involved with Chinese government enterprises.

 

So McConnell has taken remarkably pro-Chinese stances since marrying Elaine Chao, in 1993. A couple of examples are his opposition to punishing China for undervaluing its currency and disinclination to criticize China for its terrible human-rights record.

 

While neither McConnell nor his wife can be formally accused of taking bribes, it bears noting that their fortune, much of it connected with Foremost, rose to as much as $36.5 million in 2014 from about $3.1 million in 2004, according to the best scholar of the legal corruption/conflict of interest that permeates Washington – Peter Schweizer, author of Secret Empires: How the American Political Class Hides Corruption and Enriches Family and Friends. (His previous books were Clinton Cash and Throw Them All Out.)

 

Mr. Schweizer writes in his book: “Were McConnell to critique Beijing aggressively or support policies damaging to Chinese interests, Beijing could severely damage the family’s economic fortunes.’’ Sounds like Trump and Russia….

 

Other conflict-of-interest perps include Penny Pritzker,  President Obama’s second-term commerce secretary, whose big family real estate business has benefited from big government contracts, and the lobbyist sons of Senators Orrin Hatch and former Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott. Then there are Hunter Biden and Chris Heinz,  respectively son and stepson of former Vice President Joe Biden and former Secretary of State John Kerry. They created an international private-equity fund that did deals with foreign governments while the then vice president and secretary of state were negotiating with them.

 

Schweitzer wrote: “Foreign governments and oligarchs like this form of {family} corruption because it gives them private and unfettered gateways to the corridors of Washington power. Foreign entities cannot legally make campaign contributions so using this approach creates an alternative way to curry favor and influence America’s political leaders.’’

 

To read the New York Post story, please hit this link:


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.