Pam Gencarella: Will Spring Bring Renewed Hope to RI?
Pam Gencarella, GoLocalProv MINDSETTER™
Pam Gencarella: Will Spring Bring Renewed Hope to RI?
But that hope was quickly dashed for those residents of Coventry who wanted significant change and the opportunity to take control of their dire public safety problem - the Central Coventry Fire District. For those not following the story, the Central Coventry Fire District is bankrupt, even after taxing their residents to death. Those residents voted numerous times against the latest proposed budget and finally, the Judge ordered the district to liquidate (although much delayed in the process which began October 2012 and resulted in the liquidation order February 2014). Many residents came together, invested their personal time and energy to create a plan for a new district and legislation was introduced to allow for a new structure, a structure that aimed to significantly lower the operating budget.
Unfortunately, separate legislation was also introduced to maintain the status quo by allowing a fiscal overseer for fire districts, theoretically maintaining the current structure, but with some budget modifications. That legislation went to both Chambers for floor votes (that typically means it is meant to pass into law). Since the original premise of voter disapproval was the unreasonably high fire district tax, a seemingly reasonable amendment was proposed on the House floor to require that any taxes levied would be subject to the 4% tax cap, like the rest of the state’s municipalities. Tax Cap amendment? Squashed. Then, given that the existing collective bargaining agreements were the source of the high taxes, an amendment was proposed allowing the overseer to modify these agreements. Amendment to modify the cost drivers in the contracts? Squashed!
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLASTThe result? The separate status quo bills have sailed through both the House and the Senate (although it has not become law yet). If Woonsocket is any indication of what happens with a fiscal overseer, Coventry may want to prepare for a supplemental tax, which gets built into the next year’s tax rate, which increases the maximum allowed by law, another 4%. In Woonsocket, that equated to a 23% increase for the average homeowner for 2014. And that didn’t include the 19% supplemental tax on vehicles. OUCH! But wait. Woonsocket was “fortunate”. They were bound by the tax cap.
You may be reading this thinking that because you’re not a Coventry resident, this issue doesn’t affect you. Think again. This was one of the first bills to pass under the new (spring) House leadership. Public unions 1, Taxpayers 0. What does that portend for RI taxpayers? Jobs and the economy, possibly, up to a point, but not if it interferes with the status quo.
A real sign of whether or not new leadership will be a breath of fresh air for the state will be the opportunity to give the average voter hope by way of passing the good government bill that repeals the outdated, disenfranchising, ineffectual Master Lever (aka straight party voting).
There have been numerous articles, editorials and letters to the editor written in the recent past on not just the bill, but the process. Interestingly, the House itself has written a letter to the editor defending the claims of placing this on the ‘back burner’. All of this discourse supports the abolition of this vestige of another era. It appears that virtually no one from the public testifies against this bill, only a few of the elected representatives do. While this bill seems to be a no-brainer, for years it has been sent to Never Never land where little bills stay little bills forever. This year may be different. On Tuesday, House Judiciary voted to recommend passage of the bill. It is scheduled for a vote by the full House today. While there is cause to be optimistic, this is a first step. The bill remains in committee on the Senate side. Remember, in 2010, the Ethics bill passed the House but the Senate never voted on it. The House and the Senate need to work together on this legislation if it is to become law.
The session is more than half way over.
Presumably, the General Assembly leadership’s focus will be on the budget. But before they are mired in finding ways to address the billion dollar budget deficits that are projected each year in the 5 year budget, before they tackle the bubble of Medicaid expansion and the cost to maintain the health insurance exchange, before they attempt to reign in the cost of government and overregulation to help beleaguered small businesses, before they deal with how to pay for our crumbling infrastructure and how to support education reform efforts, perhaps Speaker Mattiello and Senate President Paiva Weed could even the score for voters and bring renewed hope for the average Rhode Islander by repealing the Master Lever. We could all use a ray of sunshine, a glimmer of hope. After all, spring is in the air.
Pam Gencarella is a member of OSTPA, a taxpayer advocacy organization in Rhode Island.
RI Communities with the Highest Tax Rates #39 - #1
#39 New Shoreham
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $5.21
Commercial: $5.21
Personal Property: $5.21
Motor Vehicle: $9.75
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $1,000.32
For 2008 Honda Accord: $147.71
Total Taxes as % Median Income: $1.29%
Note: Real property is assessed at 80 percent of value. This is reflected in the community's ranking.
#38 Little Compton
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $5.38
Commercial: $5.38
Personal Property: $10.76
Motor Vehicle: $13.90
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $1,291.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $210.59
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 1.56%
#37 Jamestown
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $8.75
Commercial: $8.75
Personal Property: $8.75
Motor Vehicle: $14.42
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $2,100.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $218.46
Total Taxes as % Median Income: $2.84%
#36 Charlestown
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $9.46
Commercial: $9.46
Personal Property: $9.46
Motor Vehicle: $13.08
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $2,270.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $198.16
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 3.56%
#35 Narragansett
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $9.80
Commercial: $14.68
Personal Property: $14.68
Motor Vehicle: $16.46
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $2,352.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $249.37
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 4.06%
#34 Bristol
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $12.80
Commercial: $12.80
Personal Property: $12.80
Motor Vehicle: $17.35
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,072.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $262.85
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.18%
#33 Portsmouth
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $14.53
Commercial: $14.53
Personal Property: $14.53
Motor Vehicle: $22.50
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,487.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $238.61
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 4.87%
Note: Motor vehicles are assessed at 70 percent of value. This is reflected in the community's ranking.
#32 Westerly
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $10.53
Commercial: $10.53
Personal Property: $10.53
Motor Vehicle: $29.67
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $2,527.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $449.50
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 4.93%
#31 South Kingstown
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $15.47
Commercial: $15.47
Personal Property: $15.47
Motor Vehicle: $18.71
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,712.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $283.46
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.39%
#30 Newport
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $11.71
Commercial: $16.23
Personal Property: $16.23
Motor Vehicle: $23.45
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $2,810.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $355.27
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.45%
#29 Middletown
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $15.71
Commercial: $20.87
Personal Property: $15.71
Motor Vehicle: $16.05
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,770.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $243.16
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.58%
#28 Exeter
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $14.72
Commercial: $14.72
Personal Property: $14.72
Motor Vehicle: $32.59
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,532.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $493.74
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 3.93%
#27 Tiverton
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $19.37
Commercial: $19.37
Personal Property: $19.37
Motor Vehicle: $19.14
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,648.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $289.97
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.75%
#26 Richmond
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $19.76
Commercial: $19.76
Personal Property: $19.76
Motor Vehicle: $22.64
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,742.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $274.40
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 6.33%
Note: Motor vehicles are assessed at 80 percent of value. This is reflected in the community's ranking.
#25 North Kingstown
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $18.80
Commercial: $18.80
Personal Property: $18.80
Motor Vehicle: $22.04
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,512.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $333.91
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 6.18%
#24 Coventry
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $18.66
Commercial: $22.49
Personal Property: $18.66
Motor Vehicle: $18.75
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,478.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $284.06
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.11%
#23 Cumberland
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $15.78
Commercial: $15.78
Personal Property: $28.86
Motor Vehicle: $19.87
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,787.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $301.03
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.62%
#22 Hopkinton
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $19.77
Commercial: $19.77
Personal Property: $19.77
Motor Vehicle: $21.18
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,744.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $320.88
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.80%
#21 Warren
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $18.67
Commercial: $18.67
Personal Property: $18.67
Motor Vehicle: $26.00
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,480.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $393.90
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 9.15%
#20 East Greenwich
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $22.90
Commercial: $22.90
Personal Property: $22.90
Motor Vehicle: $22.88
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,496.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $346.63
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 6.05%
#19 Burrillville
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $18.58
Commercial: $18.58
Personal Property: $18.58
Motor Vehicle: $40.00
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,459.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $606.00
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.35%
#18 Barrington
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $18.20
Commercial: $18.20
Personal Property: $18.20
Motor Vehicle: $42.00
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,368.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $636.30
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.07%
#17 West Greenwich
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $22.55
Commercial: $22.55
Personal Property: $33.85
Motor Vehicle: $19.02
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,600.20
For 2008 Honda Accord: $288.15
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.81%
Note: Does not include rate for vacant land which is $16.07. Has homestead exemption.
#16 Foster
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $20.40
Commercial: $20.40
Personal Property: $28.03
Motor Vehicle: $36.95
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,896.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $559.79
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.00%
#15 Scituate
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $33.37
Commercial: $43.20
Personal Property: $39.75
Motor Vehicle: $30.20
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,484.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $434.65
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 6.01%
Note: Real property is assessed at only 50 percent of value and motor vehicles are assessed at 95 percent of value. This is reflected in the community's ranking.
#14 Glocester
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $21.24
Commercial: $24.14
Personal Property: $42.29
Motor Vehicle: $24.37
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,097.60
For 2008 Honda Accord: $369.21
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 7.10%
#13 North Smithfield
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $15.86
Commercial: $17.57
Personal Property: $42.75
Motor Vehicle: $37.62
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,806.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $569.94
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.54%
#12 Lincoln
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $23.49
Commercial: $26.85
Personal Property: $36.89
Motor Vehicle: $30.66
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $3,664.44
For 2008 Honda Accord: $464.50
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 5.57%
Note: Has homestead exemption.
#11 Warwick
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $19.79
Commercial: $29.68
Personal Property: $39.58
Motor Vehicle: $34.60
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,749.60
For 2008 Honda Accord: $524.19
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 8.79%
#10 West Warwick
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential Rates:
- For apartments with 6+ units: $35.26
- For two to five family buildings: $35.26
- For single family homes: $24.67
Commercial: $29.98
Personal Property: $39.00
Motor Vehicle: $28.47
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,920.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $431.32
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 12.70%
Note: For ranking purposes, the average of the three residential rates was used.
#9 Cranston
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $22.84
Commercial: $34.26
Personal Property: $34.26
Motor Vehicle: $42.44
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,481.60
For 2008 Honda Accord: $642.97
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 10.48%
#8 Smithfield
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $17.52
Commercial: $17.52
Personal Property: $61.06
Motor Vehicle: $39.00
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,204.80
For 2008 Honda Accord: $590.85
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 6.54%
#7 East Providence
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $22.78
Commercial: $25.21
Personal Property: $56.25
Motor Vehicle: $37.10
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,647.12
For 2008 Honda Accord: $562.07
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 10.54%
Note: Rates are for FY 2013. Has homestead exemption.
#6 Johnston
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $28.75
Commercial: $28.75
Personal Property: $59.22
Motor Vehicle: $41.46
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,520.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $628.12
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 11.20%
Note: Has homestead exemption.
#5 Pawtucket
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $23.06
Commercial: $30.88
Personal Property: $52.09
Motor Vehicle: $53.30
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $5,534.40
For 2008 Honda Accord: $807.50
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 16.00%
#4 North Providence
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $24.29
Commercial: $31.03
Personal Property: $69.41
Motor Vehicle: $41.95
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,663.68
For 2008 Honda Accord: $635.54
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 10.55%
Note: Has homestead exemption.
#3 Woonsocket
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $34.56
Commercial: $39.81
Personal Property: $46.58
Motor Vehicle: $46.58
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,976.64
For 2008 Honda Accord: $705.69
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 14.45%
Note: Has homestead exemption.
#2 Providence
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential Rates:
- For owner-occupied residential property: $19.25
- For non-owner-occupied residential property: $33.75
Commercial: $36.75
Personal Property: $55.80
Motor Vehicle: $60.00
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,620.00
For 2008 Honda Accord: $909.00
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 14.21%
Note: For ranking purposes, the average of the two residential rates was used.
#1 Central Falls
FY 2014 Tax Rates Per $1,000 in Value
Residential: $25.72
Commercial: $37.06
Personal Property: $73.11
Motor Vehicle: $48.65
Tax Cost for Residents
For a single family home valued at $240,000: $4,728.36
For 2008 Honda Accord: $737.05
Total Taxes as % Median Income: 14.43%
Note: Has homestead exemption.
