Rob Horowitz: Supreme Court Keeps Shredding Campaign Finance Laws
Rob Horowitz, GoLocalProv MINDSETTER™
Rob Horowitz: Supreme Court Keeps Shredding Campaign Finance Laws
Frustrated by what he viewed as a fundamentally unjust mid-1970’s Supreme Court decision (Buckley v. Valeo) overturning a provision of a sweeping campaign finance law, limiting how much of their own money candidates could use in a campaign, Bradley called for a constitutional amendment giving Congress the ability to restore those limits.
The latest in a series of bad decisions
In the wake of the current US Supreme Court taking another step last week in its McCutcheon decision to systematically dismantle the campaign finance laws designed to put some sensible limits on the role of money in politics, Bradley’s specific concern about rich candidates buying elections with their own money seems almost quaint.
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLASTUnlike Senator Bradley, a majority on the current Court, as they have demonstrated in bad decision after bad decision, does believe that money and speech are pretty much synonyms. From the perspective of the Court majority, the only justification for limiting the amount of money a person, corporation, labor union or special interest can spend to influence an election are a crabbed and narrow interpretation of the corrupting role of money in politics as limited to a direct quid pro quo.
Commenting on last week’s decision, The Brennan Center for Justice’s David Earley said, “The Court doubled down on its holding that corruption only includes contributions given with the expectation of receiving official action in return — essentially a direct bribe in the guise of a political contribution. The Court also acknowledged that contributions can be used to gain ingratiation with and access to government officials while not reaching the level of outright bribery. But the Court praised this relationship rather than condemning it.”
The future of campaign finance
More specifically, in McCutcheon v. FEC., the Court by a 5-4 margin struck down the federal aggregate contribution limit of $123,000—the total amount one person could give directly to all federal candidates, parties and political committees per election cycle. Now, it will be possible through the use of joint fundraising committees for a single politician to solicit from one individual as much as $3.6 million, according to the Brennan Center.
This ruling comes on top of the 2010 Citizens United decision where the Supreme Court by another 5-4 margin unleashed the floodgates of unlimited corporate and union spending, striking down a long-standing law preventing corporations and unions from using money directly out of their treasuries in federal elections. Now, as long as there is no coordination with a candidate’s campaign, unrestricted spending by these entities is permitted.
In his dissent in the McCutcheon case, Justice Stephen Breyer said, “[This is] a decision that substitutes judges’ understandings of how the political process works for the understanding of Congress; that fails to recognize the difference between influence resting upon public opinion and influence bought by money alone; that overturns key precedent; that creates huge loopholes in the law; and that undermines, perhaps devastates, what remains of campaign finance reform.”
I couldn’t agree more
Rob Horowitz is a strategic and communications consultant who provides general consulting, public relations, direct mail services and polling for national and state issue organizations, various non-profits and elected officials and candidates. He is an Adjunct Professor of Political Science at the University of Rhode Island
Gina Raimondo CGF Campaign Donations
Beshar Family Contribution
Total Contribution: $13,500
Jacqueline G. Beshar, Co-Chairwoman of Capital Good Fund
- 9/27/2011 $1,000
- 10/3/2012 $1,000
- 3/4/2013 $1,000
Robert Beshar, Law Offices of Robert Beshar
- 12/9/2012 $1,000
- 12/15/2013 $1,000
Peter Beshar, Marsh & McLennan
- 9/15/2010 $500
- 8/22/2011 $1,000
- 9/23/2012 $500
Christine Beshar, Cravath Swaine & Moore LLP
- 12/9/2012 $1,000
- 12/15/2013 $1,000
Frederica Beshar
- 10/5/2012 $500
Scot Jones, Groov-Pin Corp. (Husband of Jacqueline G. Beshar)
- 5/9/2010 $250
- 6/4/2010 $750
- 12/05/2011 $1,000
- 10/3/2012 $1,000
- 3/25/2013 $1,000
Hower Family Contribution
Total Contributions: $10,000
Lee Hower, Co-Chairman of Capital Good Fund
- 12/16/2009 $1,000
- 3/11/2010 $1,000
- 7/7/2011 $1,000
- 3/30/2012 $1,000
- 2/16/2013 $1,000
Heather Hower, Brown University
- 12/30/2009 $1,000
- 3/11/2010 $1,000
- 7/9/2011 $1,000
- 3/30/2012 $1,000
- 2/16/2013 $1,000
Tobias Lederberg
Former Vice President of Capital Good Fund
Total Contribution: $5,000
- 12/21/2009 $1,000
- 3/30/2010 $1,000
- 9/23/2011 $1,000
- 3/31/2012 $1,000
- 3/19/2013 $1,000
Daugherty Family Contribution
Total Contribution: $4,125
William Daugherty, ANC Sports
- 6/15/2012 $1,000
- 3/24/2013 $1,000
- 11/27/2013 $1,000
Tracy Daugherty, Homemaker
- 11/29/2012 $125
- 3/24/2013 $1,000
Note: Tracy and Bill Daugherty are individual donors to CGF.
Jessica Ricci
Member of Capital Good Fund's Board of Directors
Total Contribution: $1,550
- 10/14/2010 $50
- 9/30/2011 $1,000
- 10/31/2013 $500
Citizens Bank
Total Contribution: $10,625
Edward O. Handy III
- 3/25/2010 $750
- 9/25/2010 $250
- 3/28/2012 $500
- 7/15/2013 $1,000
Maria Carlino
- 9/27/2012 $1,000
- 11/22/2013 $500
Donna Brady
- 3/17/2010 $150
- 10/5/2010 $250
- 1/20/2012 $100
- 7/15/2013 $200
- 11/7/2013 $100
Barbara C. Garrahy
- 8/24/2010 $100
- 10/5/2010 $250
- 9/12/2011 $250
- 7/9/2013 $500
Stephen P. Higginbotham
- 6/22/2010 $250
- 10/5/2010 $250
- 12/2/2013 $200
Michael Kennally
- 9/6/2010 $150
- 10/5/2010 $250
- 7/15/2013 $250
James M. Hagerty
- 5/3/2010 $250
- 6/29/2010 $150
- 10/6/2010 $250
Kenneth W. Robinson
- 10/5/2010 $250
- 7/15/2010 $500
Joseph Gleason
- 9/12/2013 $200
- 11/20/2013 $250
Kenneth B. Martin
- 7/22/2013 $250
Gregory Kirwan
- 10/4/2010 $250
Terrence W. Allen
- 10/5/2010 $250
Anthony A. Botelho
- 10/5/2010 $250
Gail Ginnetty
- 9/26/2013 $50
- 9/30/2013 $100
Peter R. Bakkala
- 6/22/2010 $125
David Grassini
- 2/6/2010 $100
Patricia E. Wegrzyn
- 8/15/2012 $100
Stephen Craven
12/31/2013 $50
Hassenfeld Family Initiatives
Total Contribution: $4,000
Alan G. Hassenfeld
- 6/23/2010 $1,000
- 8/17/2011 $1,000
- 6/5/2012 $1,000
- 9/5/2013 $1,000
Bank Rhode Island
Total Contribution: $1,375
William C. Tsonos, Bank RI
- 6/17/2010 $125
- 9/13/2011 $250
Linda Simmons, Bank RI
- 6/17/2010 $125
- 9/12/2011 $250
Emanuel E. Barrows, Bank RI
- 9/13/2011 $250
Mary E. Leach, Bank RI
- 6/17/2010 $125
Steven M. Parente, Bank RI
- 6/21/2010 $125
Robert H. Wischnowsky, Bank RI
- 6/21/2011 $125
Sovereign Bank
Total Contribution: $2,225
Kevin J. Sullivan
- 6/24/2010 $1,000
Michael Lee
- 10/27/2012 $100
- 12/31/2013 $25
TD Bank
Total Contribution: $1,575
Robert A. Kolb Jr.
- 6/16/2010 $1,000
John Conte
- 6/22/2010 $250
Rosalin Acosta
- 6/30/2010 $150
Scott H. Sanborn
- 6/22/2010 $125
Amy Beauchamp
- 9/29/2013 $50
Ariel Investments
Total Contribution: $1,000
John W. Rogers Jr.
- 9/15/2010 $1,000
New Roots Providence
Total Contribution: $325
Sabina Matos
- 3/31/2010 $25
- 6/20/2010 $25
- 9/12/2011 $250
- 12/30/2013 $25
Rockland Trust
Total Contribution: $250
William Lavelle
- 6/24/2010 $250
Social Venture Partners Rhode Island
Total Contribution: $250
Kelly Ramirez
- 6/6/2010 $100
- 12/10/2012 $25
- 9/24/2013 $25
- 9/30/2013 $100
Rhode Island Foundation
Total Contribution: $100
Carol Einhorn
- 3/31/2010 $100
