How Did East Greenwich Become So Divided -- From Fire Contracts to Political Fliers on Sex

Kate Nagle, GoLocal News Editor

How Did East Greenwich Become So Divided -- From Fire Contracts to Political Fliers on Sex

Is East Greenwich the most politically divided community in RI?
The Town of East Greenwich has become an increasingly divided political hotbed in recent months, and last weekend it reached a fevered pitch with a back-and-forth over a political mailer (and its origins) between Republican State Representative Anthony Giarrusso and progressive opponent Justine Caldwell.

When did the bedroom harbor community, known for its quaint main street and top-notch schools, become ground zero for political unrest in Rhode Island?

"East Greenwich has caught the 'national disease' i.e. the chronic lack of civility. Folks no longer seek the kernel of truth in those with opposing views in order to build a consensus," said former Rhode Island Attorney General Arlene Violet. "Taking its cue from D.C., far too many have a winner takes all mentality. It is particularly disconcerting to see a fine community like East Greenwich with so many smart people become another hub of discontent. Please cure the 'illness' by taking a deep breath and listen to one another."

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

While the origins of the political mailer that Giarrusso said he received last weekend are uncertain -- with Giarrusso calling for civility in the campaign and Caldwell claiming he blamed her -- the Progressives are blaming him. 

"In my opinion, this is more of Representative Giarrusso creating a stir rather than a splintered town. He...is feeling the heat today because of his poor record.  Representative Giarrusso is an extreme right wing politician who’s a dangerous threat to his constituents and he’s doing whatever he can to keep his seat," said Nate Carpenter with the Progressive Democrats of Rhode Island. "Dividing and conquering is unfortunately what some Republicans do, but I hope that East Greenwich is smarter than to fall for such a histrionic impersonation of Dr. Caldwell."

Latest in East Greenwich

The mailer marks just the latest controversy for East Greenwich, with saw union opposition and more turnout for the rehiring of Town Manager Gayle Corrigan in November 2017, to the town "Paying out $1.7 million in "Fire District Fee Scheme" in June, and more.

Former gubernatorial candidate Ken Block, who has reported on what he has called the "inflated" overtime of the fire department based on his analysis, decried what he says are opposition tactics -- not just in East Greenwich, but across the state.

"Some Progressives have adopted a scorched earth form of campaigning, which brings about the appearance of political unrest when in actuality it is simply dirty politics," said Block. "I watched in Barrington as some Progressives sent out campaign flyers which consisted almost entirely of blatant lies. Since the flyers were not directly from the campaign but rather from outside groups trying to influence the election, there was no direct accountability to the candidate who the flyer was supposed to help."

Battles between the town and public service unions are ongoing

"I personally believe (and hope) that these sorts of flyers actually harm the candidates they were intended to help. If the harm is great enough, the flyers will disappear – as they should. Unfortunately, there is nothing in place to prevent the kind of outrageous lies we see come from some outside groups trying to influence our elections," said Block. "It doesn’t matter if the lies come from Russia or the head of some obscure organization in Providence – these sorts of communications are harmful to our democracy, and they should be stopped."

Elected Officials -- and Candidates -- on Record

Democratic Town Council member Mark Schwager decried the direction of the Town Council -- but Town Council President Sue Cienki defended what she said was the need to find "new efficiencies to give residents more value for their tax dollar."

"I've been on a number of different councils, and they've been more collegial and consensus building in the past," said Schwager. "It's a different experience for me. There's a lot of concern in the town right now. It's not the way the Town Council has traditionally operated. One of our strengths had been our town government stayed in the background, provided good services, and good schools. That was our focus."

"This 'my-way-or-the-highway' unilateral approach now, we saw it with the budget process. We had 2 hours to review the final budget -- no input from department heads or public input -- and we took a million out of the reserve fund," said Schwager. "My impression is that the town wants to turn down the temperature.  The town is not interested in a cultural or political conflict. People want open government, good relationships between the Town Council and schools, municipal employees, and we should be inviting the community in to the process."

Republican Town Council President Cienki defended the body's actions. 

"It's certainly something that's taken a lot of us by surprise over these last two years. I think it's the confluence of a lot of things happening in a short period of time. First, I think the current political climate on the national level has activated a number of individuals who haven't been actively involved in politics to this point. There have been many who are looking to take a more active role in their legislative process which I applaud," said Cienki. "Simply, there are more people contributing to the overall town discussion in person and on social media."

"The next issue was the transfer of our Town Managers. The Town Manager that we had to let go was incredibly popular in town (myself included) and we replaced him with Gail Corrigan who received a reaction we certainly did not expect," said Cienki. "I think the subsequent reaction was due to  the optics of appointing her in executive session. Getting back to your original point of our residents not being 'overly political', we really didn't see any issue going off of the precedent of appointing our last Town Manager, which was also done in executive session. But the perception was this was some sort of 'House of Cards' maneuver, which I can of course say it was not."

"The last factor which is tied to the Town Manager issue has been the Fire Department. One of the main reasons we hired Gail was her extensive experience negotiating labor contracts. In 2019 East Greenwich has 5 upcoming labor contract negotiations with its employees and representatives. Gail, with her experience turning around the Central Coventry District, has certainly had her share of experience dealing with the firefighter unions. These organizations are very skilled  and experienced waging public relations wars and funding opposing political campaign," said Cienki. "This has played a pivotal role in driving the narrative that Gail is unfit to manage the town and that her appointment was somehow not legitimate. All of this has created a very uncomfortable atmosphere for everyone in town."

Sean O'Leary, who is running as an independent for Town Council, said that he believes residents want another option. 

"I'm running as an independent. This is the first time I've run for political office, while I've had a deep interest in politics for a while," said O'Leary. "The way I see it, I can best serve the citizens of East Greenwich. I'm not obliged to carry forth any agenda -- just what I hear as the collective will of the citizenry."

"I think people appreciate the fact I'm new to politics -- and why I'm running is [against] what has perturbed people the last few years at the national and local level. So they find that refreshing," said O'Leary.  "Disdain might be strong word, but there's some impatience with the bomb throwing."

"Clearly, there's bad blood on both sides -- which is why there's a need for new blood. Let's stop pointing fingers, reboot, and remember we live in a town of 30,000 people in 16 square miles. We're all neighbors."

Editor's Note: Carpenter's original statement alleged Giarrusso "won by a narrow margin in 2016;" it has been taken out as Giarrusso ran unopposed in 2016.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.