The Rise and Fall of Agawam Hunt Club

GoLocalProv News Team and Kate Nagle

The Rise and Fall of Agawam Hunt Club

The Agawam Hunt country club was where Rhode Island’s wealthiest did deals on the golf course, played tennis on the grass courts, and dined on Friday night. For those who lived on Providence’s Grotto Ave and Blackstone Boulevard or Barrington’s Rumstick Point, membership at Agawam was a must. 

For Italians and Jews – they had their own clubs. Agawam was an exclusive place, like the Hope Club or the Dunes Club. Membership had its privileges.

Now, it is bankrupt.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

“The death of [Agawam] sure is a sociological historical marker,” said Bob Whitcomb, former Providence Journal Editorial Page Editor - and now GoLocal columnist. 

GoLocal was first to report Agawam’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing on Wednesday, which delineated a list of creditors that includes club members who represent the “who’s who” of Rhode Island’s patrician elite. 

And while the bankruptcy filings show Agawam's assets and liabilities ranging between $1 million and $10 million, a club member who spoke on the condition of anonymity said the amount of Agawam's debt is “around $4 million.”

Club attorney Peter Furness did not respond to request for comment on Wednesday, and Agawam President Ed Thomsen referred all inquiries to Furness.  

GoLocal, however, obtained copies of emails sent by Thomsen (see below), which paint a picture of a club in dire straits.  Despite having the upper-most echelon of Rhode Island as members, the "captains of industry" have seen the club plunged into debt. 

Agawam Then - and Now

Founded in 1897, Agawam Hunt’s first executive committee included a President, Secretary, Treasurer — and a MFH (Master of Fox Hounds), according to club history

In 1921, the club voted to “allow members to use the stable for saddle horses on the condition that they hire a man, who would become a Club servant, to do their work, for a cost of $1.00/week per horse for those members.” In 1966, a new grill room was built, “and ladies were allowed to use that entrance, but still forbidden to dine there.” In 1987, “the first woman, Mary Worrell, was named to serve on the Board — and run the pool activities.” 

The club continued to acknowledge the changing times, noting in 1988, “due to lack of interest…paddle tennis courts began to deteriorate, and were town down.” 

“Through the [1990s], it was still very WASPy, but affordable,” one club member told GoLocal. “But when Carnegie Abbey came into vogue, [Agawam] decided that in order to compete, they had to spruce up the place, make it more elite and harder to get into. All of a sudden, you had to have 12 letters of recommendation to get in. If you wanted to propose someone you had to throw a cocktail party for all the members and pay for it. The initiation fees increased from $5,000 to $15,000. It was lunacy.”

“There was a fire in the pool building office, and when they reconstructed that, they decided they wanted more outside weddings. They took out loans from Bank RI. Meanwhile Merrill Sherman, who was a club member, was head of Bank RI,” the member said. “It’s almost a microcosm of Rhode Island. [Agawam] kept kicking the can down the road, and people started realizing it in the last six or seven years.”

“The club’s lost maybe 100 members since the summer,” said the member. “I’d say we’re probably at around 330 now.”

Who’s Who of Members

Past and present members who were listed as creditors with unsecured claims in the bankruptcy filings include some of Rhode Island’s wealthiest and influential (as reported by GoLocal).  

“[Agawam] owes about $870,000 to members,” said the member. 

They include:

* Charles Townsend, III: Aloha Partners exec who sold wireless spectrums to AT&T for a reported $2.5 billion. One of GoLocal’s wealthiest and most influential in 2015.

* Glenn Creamer: As GoLocal reported, “If Jonathan Nelson is worth $2 billion as Forbes claims, then Creamer is estimated to be in the $1 billion range. Creamer grew up in Pawtucket and went to Brown University.”

* Almon Hall: Served as senior Vice President and CFO at Nortek, where he worked closely with Rick Bready. A philanthropist, has a “Family Fund” along with wife Suzanne at the Rhode Island Foundation. 

* Winn Major: The East Side resident was a Director at the now-defunct Old Stone Bank, and counsel for Edwards and Angell.

* Gregory Benik: The Providence lawyer has served as a club Vice President for the Rhode Island Golf Association, whose 26 person operating committee and executive board counts one woman in its ranks.

* Louise Mauran: Listing an address of Boca Grande in Florida, she was the wife of the late Duncan Mauran, who had been President of the Providence Steamboat Company. Both were listed on two funds at the Rhode Island Foundation. 

In addition, bankruptcy filings show Agawam owes millions to the City of East Providence (for water, sewer, and real estate taxes) and vendors large and small, including local food and beverage businesses (such as Calise & Sons Bakery, LaSalle Bakery), pest control (Griggs and Brown), and waste services. Agawam also owes golf pro Norman Albergio nearly $30,000. 

Appeal to Members

In an effort to save the club from financial demise, Thomsen sent numerous emails to membership, desperately making pleas for help. 

On January 3, Thomsen wrote the following to “fellow Agawam members,” just prior to the bankruptcy. 

“For those of you who read my last email you are aware that Agawam will be filing for court protection under chapter 11. Before that happens I want to call one last meeting where a miracle will take place (come on we have all seen 'It's a Wonderful Life'). I am hoping for that miracle but in addition it is important to have this meeting so that all questions can be addressed and all ideas can be evaluated. We would also use this opportunity to update you on what options we have that are still viable. We truly are at the bitter end and I, as well as your Board, will entertain any idea that can solve our financial issues.” 

Following the bankruptcy, on Tuesday, January 17, Thomsen then sent this message:

“This past Friday, the 13th of January, we officially filed in Federal Court for protection against creditors under Chapter 11 of the Federal bankruptcy code. Surely not a happy day in Agawam's 119 year history but it is a step in the direction of a permanent solution. The goal is to create a plan which will allow us to emerge from bankruptcy debt free and become a stronger Club than ever before. I am scheduling a meeting on February 8 at 6:00 pm to reveal that plan and get support from the membership to make it work. Please save that date and more details will follow.”

The Agawam Hunt bankruptcy filing in federal court may prove to be a milestone in the transformation of Rhode Island's class and economic power structure. 

Photos: Providence Public Library


Rhode Island’s 50 Wealthiest and Most Influential - 2015 Edition

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.