VIDEO: Common Cause RI Criticizes Senate Chair for Blocking Non-Profit Testimony at Hearing

Kate Nagle, GoLocal News Editor

VIDEO: Common Cause RI Criticizes Senate Chair for Blocking Non-Profit Testimony at Hearing

Senator Josh Miller, refused to allow testimony
After Rhode Island Senate Health and Human Services Chair Josh Miller said he was "dismissing" testimony from a non-profit during a hearing on eye care legislation, Common Cause Rhode Island Executive Director John Marion said that "no Rhode Islander should be precluded from providing testimony" on a bill.

On Thursday, Mike Stenhouse, CEO Rhode Island Center for Freedom and Prosperity began remarks during the Senate Committee hearing -- during which Miller interrupted his remarks to claim Stenhouse's 501(c)3 status invalidated his testimony. Miller referenced a prior letter, sent by Stenhouse, which Miller read out loud. "So it says, 'I'd like to provide some background...as a 501(c)3 our center is not allowed to advise you how to vote'," said Miller of Stenhouse's letter.

"I'm not telling you how to vote, I'm telling you the underlying issues," said Stenhouse, who began his remarks by saying, "I represent the free market and consumers, I'm not paid by anyone to be here, we just want to see what's best for the state." "I didn't advise you how to vote. It's a thin line, but it's what 501(c)3 across the state do," said Stenhouse. "You can go forward but we're dismissing your comments," Miller shot back.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Common Cause's John Marion
Common Cause Weighs In "Mike Stenhouse and the Center for Freedom and Prosperity are wrong [to] say 501(c)3s are not allowed to advise lawmakers to support or oppose legislation," said Marion.

"The IRS makes it clear that such organizations can lobby, but 'too much lobbying activity risks loss of tax-exempt status.' That's straight from the IRS website."

"Many Rhode Island 501(c)3 organizations are involved in the legislative process in a way that does not cross that line," added Marion.

"Lobbying should never be a substantial part of what a 501(c)3 does. That's for 501(c)4 organizations like Common Cause. The trade-off is the tax exemption that donors enjoy when they give to a 501(c)3."

"Mike Stenhouse is correct that you can express an opinion about an issue without actually lobbying on specific legislation. Once someone starts advocating for or against legislative action on specific legislation they are lobbying. It's a distinction that is sometimes hard to see, and one that Senator Miller seems to struggle to understand in this instance," said Marion.

Finally, Marion had the following to say. "No Rhode Islander is, or should be, precluded from providing testimony on a bill," said Marion. "If they meet the definition of a lobbyist under the law, because they seek to influence specific legislation, they should also register with the Secretary of State. Mike Stenhouse clearly believes that some of what he does on behalf of the Center for Freedom and Prosperity is lobbying because he is registered on their behalf."

Stenhouse Reaction

Stenhouse said about Miller's highly unusual decision, "As you can see from the video, I was incredulous that the Chairman could not grasp this obvious distinction [between an opinion and instruction], even after I repeatedly tried to explain this simple concept it to him," said Stenhouse.

"I don't believe the Senator is intellectually incapable of understanding the issue, rather, I believe he chose to look for any possible pretense to shut down my views, even if it made himself look foolish. This is a common tactic of intolerant progressive elitists, like Senator Miller, who think they know what's best for the rest of us," added Stenhouse. 

Editor's Note: A previous version identified the legislation as the hair braiding bill; it was for eye care oversight.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.