Whitcomb: Sharing Pension Blame; 'Ladies Lingerie'; Money for the Mob; In Defense of Buses

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Whitcomb: Sharing Pension Blame; 'Ladies Lingerie'; Money for the Mob; In Defense of Buses

Robert Whitcomb, columnist
“You fall out of your mother’s womb, you crawl across open country under fire, and drop into your grave.”

-- Quentin Crisp

 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

“News is what somebody somewhere wants to suppress; all the rest is advertising.’’

-- The early 20th Century British newspaper publisher Lord Northcliffe
 

“{O}ne turns to the spring world again, knowing that it is not forever, and that all one can do is drink deeply and store it up, and use it, a memory at a time, against the press of other moments and other moods. If ever one moment could justify all of life, it would be such an evening in May.’’

-- In the chapter “May Evening,’’ from in Praise of Seasons, by the late Alan H. Olmstead, a Connecticut editor and essayist.

 

I vote for May as the best month. It’s the freshest,  the most fragrant and the most, well, most luscious. It’s also the greenest, and I think that green is the most soothing color, though some neurologists insist that blue is.

 

If you’re a student, final exams and papers darken the month,  but for most of us, May is a joy. Early and mid-October may give it a run for its money in beauty, but October has the great drawback of our knowing that it’s followed by dark, chilly, windswept November.

 

 

xxx

 

Vincent "Buddy" Cianci
In my last column, in a comment about the Providence Water Supply Board, I called the late Providence Mayor Vincent Cianci the prime culprit in the city’s ongoing underfunded-pension problem. Well, he signed off on the extreme giveaways, the worst part of which was huge cost-of-living payments,  and set the long-term pattern for underfunding the pensions.

 

However, I should have noted that the original sin in all this was committed by the Retirement Board,  which municipal unions controlled for years. The board showed little concern for the fiscal health of the city. Then there was a  1989 decision by then-Mayor Joseph Paolino to offer 5 percent compounded COLAs in a collective-bargaining agreement; city councilors unwilling to push back strongly to stop the raids on the city’s treasury,  and widespread disability-pension fraud.

 

xxx

 

Some Rhode Island Democrats have proposed big tax increases to pay for expanded or new public programs. But the tiny state has no alternative but to make its taxes competitive with Massachusetts’s. Economic reality bites.

 

xxx
 

 

I’m sympathetic to Rhode Island Superior Court Judge Netti Vogel for having imposed a ban on citizens, including journalists, from contacting jurors in the high-profile trial of  Jorge DePina, who was found guilty of second-degree murder in the death of his 10-year-old daughter. After all, who wants to be approached by strangers wanting to discuss such a ghastly story after you’ve done your painful civic duty in a case like this?

Facing a Providence Journal lawsuit alleging that her do-not-contact order violated the First Amendment, Judge Vogel lifted her ban.

While levels of sequestration are appropriate for jurors while they serve so that they can make as disinterested a decision as possible based on sworn testimony and other evidence, after a jury decides, the public has a right to ask about what went into its judgment. With trial after trial, such information over time can be used to improve our courts.

Of course, the jurors have every right to refuse to speak to the news media or anyone else. And we thank them for their service.

 

xxx
 

 

Why would Newport’s Salve Regina University want to build two large dormitories to house hundreds of students? Well, one attraction would be that the university could try to rent them out to the public during the City by the Sea’s busy summer tourist season.


This might be particularly attractive during a time when, nationally, the number of customers applying to enter many such small private colleges has been declining, forcing some to close.

 

 

xxx

 

 

The death, back on Feb. 3, of Paul Nicholson, 99, was a melancholic reminder of Providence’s glory days as a renowned industrial center.

 

Mr. Nicholson was the long-time CEO of the family enterprise,  the long-gone and Providence-based Nicholson File Co.,  which was the world’s largest maker of files and rasps, with a big manufacturing complex in Providence. He was on innumerable boards, business and charitable, and was known as a kindly and paternalistic executive in the days of noblesse oblige. Lost world indeed!

 

 

xxx
 

President Donald Trump
Given how relentlessly Donald Trump has denounced the Iran nuclear deal (but has he to this day even read it?) to his base, it was unlikely that he would do anything else but dramatically take us out of it. Indeed, he has tried to destroy all the major initiatives of the Obama administration, while promising such exciting new things as a “great, beautiful wall’’ along the Mexican border. It’s all about his adoring base, the most flamboyant members of which you see at his frequent rallies. A narcissist/demagogue can never get enough cheering. (Trump very rarely ventures into large non-base settings.)

 

Yes, as with all such agreements, the Iran nuclear deal has flaws that need fixing. But most U.S. experts on Iran have thought it has been pretty effective. And our clear-eyed, not naïve, allies Britain, France and Germany have strongly supported it for substantially slowing Iran’s march to becoming a nuclear power. Now more confusion will reign in the Mideast, and with more confusion usually comes more danger.

 

We await the president’s Plan B.

 

 

xxx

 

The Works Progress Administration and the Civilian Conservation Corps did some great public projects in the Depression – the former building roads, bridges, walls, public buildings and other  infrastructure (some of which is still with us), the latter reforesting wide areas, improving parks, addressing erosion on farms and building roads into remote areas. They were both job programs meant to address the immediate unemployment crisis but their work made lasting improvements.

 

Now, although the jobless rate is very low, some leading Democrats want to create a federal “jobs guarantee’’ to prevent mass unemployment in future recessions/depressions. The basic idea is to hire any American who wants a job and pay him/her $15 an hour and provide health insurance.

 

Civilian Conservation Corps
Of course, this would be hugely expensive, maybe over $500 billion a year, but backers say raising taxes on the rich, and savings in unemployment-benefit programs, Medicaid and other social services, would make it fiscally plausible. I doubt it:  The costs would probably quickly spiral out of control, and it would be an administrative nightmare.

 

Could the Feds really put all of the millions of people who would sign up into productive work?  Of course, they’d be some jobs requiring little skill, such as ditch digging, picking up litter, some kinds of exterior painting and planting trees, but WPA-type projects now require a lot of people trained in operating complex machinery and even computers. The private sector wants people with those skills and generally pays more than $15 an hour for them.

 

As the usually very interesting conservative writer Megan McArdle noted in The Washington Post, the massive program envisioned by some Democrats would involve a lot of “make-work.’’ Hit link here.

 

But we would benefit greatly from targeted federal jobs programs that put people to work rebuilding our crumbling infrastructure and in such sectors as public health and education.

 

Oh, by the way, whatever happened to the huge infrastructure program promised by Trump?

 

xxx

 

Some Trumpists complain that it’s unfair for Special Counsel Robert Mueller to be mucking around so much in the president’s past and present business affairs when the main point of the investigation is supposed to be Russian collusion with the Trump campaign.

 

They miss the point. Trump’s many business links with Russia, most suspiciously the vast quantities of money that his sleazy empire has received from people there, suggest his extreme vulnerability to Russian pressure, including blackmail and having loans called. Trump has always been a crook, with Italian Mafia and other criminal connections.

 

Robert Mueller
Look for the phrase “money laundering’’ to pop up more and more as the Mueller investigation continues.  Among many signs of corruption: Big cash expenditures by the Trump Organization. Where did the cash come from? No wonder Trump has refused to release his tax returns. But Robert Mueller has access to at least some of them.

 

Trump has always presented himself as a brilliant dealmaker. It can be easy to present yourself as a deal “artist’’ and “genius’’ if you’re not hemmed in by basic ethics and morality. Read the observations of Tony Schwartz, who ghost wrote Trump’s book Art of the Deal after shadowing Trump for 18 months in the ’80s (and still feels very guilty about it) by hitting this link here:

 

The electoral college has installed a mobster in the Oval Office.

 

Meanwhile, we learn that a  shell company that Trump fixer/lawyer/assistant crook Michael Cohen used to pay money to  porn star Stormy Daniels to shut her up about a sexual encounter with Trump got big payments from a U.S. company linked to a Russian oligarch as well as  from several corporations, including AT&T, with current or expected business before the Trump administration.

 

Among the transactions was about $500,000 from Columbus Nova, a New York investment firm whose biggest client is a company controlled by Viktor Vekselberg, the oligarch; he’s close to dictator Vladimir Putin.

 

Other transactions described in the financial records include $4.4 million Mr. Cohen got from big companies with current or potential business before the Trump administration. Dubious but probably legal.

 

xxx

 

No wonder so many Americans, Trumpists and otherwise, feel antipathy to higher education:

 

Consider the case of Ned LeBow, 76, a Dartmouth College emeritus professor of government. Riding in an elevator at a recent International Studies Association (ISA) meeting, he joked as the doors opened at a floor, “ladies lingerie”.  Those of a certain age will remember when big department stores had elevator operators with natty uniforms who would announce, in a dignified voice, the specialty of each floor – e.g., “sporting goods,’’ “housewares,’’ “men’s clothing’’ and, yes, “ladies lingerie.’’

 

This enraged fellow passenger Simona Sharoni, 56, a professor of  “women’s and gender studies’’ at Merrimack College. So she filed a complaint with the ISA, which demanded that Professor LeBow “unequivocally’’ apologize for his whimsical remark. To his credit, he has refused to do so or to enter the ISA’s Stalinist re-education camp. Is Sharoni so weak and so angry that she can’t take a mild joke?

 

xxx

 

Guild-like protectionism has always been very powerful in American health care, which partly explains why our health costs are the world’s highest.  I was reminded of this in reading the May 7  Providence Journal op-ed column “Protectionism only hurts Rhode Island,’’ by Saya Nagori, M.D., an ophthalmologist and medical director of an online app called Simple Contacts. It’s a telehealth technology for glasses and contact-lens users.

 

She asserts in her obviously very economically self-interested piece, that “79 percent of the time that a contact-lens user visits an optometrist to renew a prescription, they are reissued the  exact same prescription….{But} mobile app platforms like Simple Contacts use technology to administer a basic vision test….{which} is recorded and reviewed by a Rhode Island  licensed ophthalmologist who can renew the patient’s existing contact-lens prescription’’ at far less cost that visiting an optometrist.

 

Of course, the Rhode Island Optometric Association sees this as a serious threat to members’ revenue stream and has filed legislation to ban use of this technology. It reminds me of the strenuous attempts by some physicians to keep CVS’s Minute Clinics out of Rhode Island (where CVS is based).  Minute Clinics are staffed by nurses, nurse practitioners and physician assistants rather than by considerably more expensive physicians.

 

But the protectionists will fail in the end. American health care is just too damn expensive and so more and more patients demand new options.

 

xxx

 

Meanwhile, every night on TV network news you can see a force for high healthcare costs – relentless and glitzy advertising of expensive, in-patent drugs that may or may not be more effective than much cheaper generic ones. The ads are especially targeted at the aging demographic who watch those shows. Of course, the older you are, the more likely you are to need medicine.

 

Viewers see these ads and then troop to their physicians to ask for prescriptions for the latest wonder drugs, the cost of which leads to ever more expensive public and private insurance and higher out-of-pocket health-care costs.

 

xxx

 

Buses aren’t sexy, but we need more and better buses and bus routes, especially in dense urban areas, using new technology. As Laura Bliss, the author of a piece in the very useful citylab.com writes:

 

“{T}oo many cities are ignoring what is arguably the cheapest and most flexible general-purpose option, which happens to be available already: the bus. Buses can carry large numbers of people in a compact amount of road space. They don’t require special rights-of-way (though that’s sometimes ideal). They can be deployed and rerouted as needed. Across modes, they’re the most affordable to cities in terms of capital costs, and often in terms of operations….

 

RIPTA
“It’s not hard to see how the trend of deprioritizing buses will harden in the age of on-demand door-to-door rides. The problem is, your streets can’t fit them. If you care about how well your city moves, how your local economy is faring, and how the planet’s future fares, then you care about your city bus. And you care about making the bus better.’’

 

“{W}e plan to look at what’s working on bus systems in the U.S., with the belief that there is no inherent reason that buses cannot be great. Which cities are winning the battles to prioritize road space? Where is the gold standard for frequent, fast, and reliable transit being set by buses?’’

 

“After all, it’s telling that, even while transit agencies are being told to be more like Uber and Lyft, Uber and Lyft are increasingly mimicking buses. Both companies now have ‘shuttle’ or ‘line’ services that operate along preset routes with preset stops during peak commuter hours, just like a bus. It’s existential to the future of these start-ups that they stop subsidizing high-end solo rides and instead cram in the maximum number of riders per vehicle—in order words, that they reproduce a bus. ‘’

 

I hope that Scott Avedisian, the outgoing Warwick mayor, who will soon become the CEO of the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, reads Ms. Bliss’s article. See:

 

xxx

 

As a citylab.com fan, I also can’t resist touting an article headlined “Blue Light Special: The Chicago-area High School in an Old Kmart’’. It tells the story of how a design firm turned an abandoned department store in Waukegan, Ill., into a spiffy, bright school.  There are many old and decayed school buildings in Rhode Island – indeed, Gov. Gina Raimondo has proposed a $1 billion plan to fix them over the next five years; best estimates suggest that $3 billion is needed.

But with so many large store buildings around here empty because of Amazon, etc., why not see if some could be converted into school buildings at a lower cost and with better design than we’d get by renovating existing school buildings. Consider that the average Rhode Island school is more than 50 years old! Most big-box stores, vacant and otherwise, are younger.

See here:

 

xxx

 

The Travelers, by Chris Pavone, is an intense, first-class international spy (among other occupations) thriller with psychological acuity, brilliantly drawn characters, and sense of place (or, rather, of many places, exotic and otherwise). It’s also often very funny, usually in macabre ways. The protagonist is a travel writer.

 

If you like short stories, pick up a copy of the late Peter Taylor’s Complete Stories: 1960-1992. While Mr. Taylor, a native Tennessean, usually set his stories in the urban  Upper South, with middle or upper-class characters, he did what good fiction writers do: Show universal issues that arise from particular situations. it’s hard to see the universal if it’s not grounded in the emotional and physical details of the particular.

 

Mr. Taylor’s characters strive to find their roles in a rapidly changing society. Doesn’t everyone. 

 

xxx
 

“Lilacs,

False blue,

White,

Purple,

Color of lilac,

Your great puffs of flowers

Are everywhere in this my New England.

Among your heart-shaped leaves

Orange orioles hop like music-box birds and sing

Their little weak soft songs;

In the crooks of your branches

The bright eyes of song sparrows sitting on spotted eggs

Peer restlessly through the light and shadow

Of all Springs.

Lilacs in dooryards

Holding quiet conversations with an early moon;

Lilacs watching a deserted house

Settling sideways into the grass of an old road;

Lilacs, wind-beaten, staggering under a lopsided shock of bloom

Above a cellar dug into a hill.

You are everywhere.

You were everywhere.

You tapped the window when the preacher preached his sermon,

And ran along the road beside the boy going to school.

You stood by the pasture-bars to give the cows good milking,

You persuaded the housewife that her dishpan was of silver.

And her husband an image of pure gold.

You flaunted the fragrance of your blossoms

Through the wide doors of Custom Houses—

You, and sandal-wood, and tea,

Charging the noses of quill-driving clerks

When a ship was in from China.

You called to them: ‘Goose-quill men, goose-quill men,

May is a month for flitting.’

Until they writhed on their high stools

And wrote poetry on their letter-sheets behind the propped-up ledgers.

Paradoxical New England clerks,

Writing inventories in ledgers, reading the ‘Song of Solomon’ at night,

So many verses before bed-time,

Because it was the Bible.

The dead fed you

Amid the slant stones of graveyards.

Pale ghosts who planted you

Came in the nighttime

And let their thin hair blow through your clustered stems.

You are of the green sea,

And of the stone hills which reach a long distance.

You are of elm-shaded streets with little shops where they sell kites and marbles,

You are of great parks where every one walks and nobody is at home.

You cover the blind sides of greenhouses

And lean over the top to say a hurry-word through the glass

To your friends, the grapes, inside.

 

Lilacs,

False blue,

White,

Purple,

Color of lilac,

You have forgotten your Eastern origin,

The veiled women with eyes like panthers,

The swollen, aggressive turbans of jeweled pashas.

Now you are a very decent flower,

A reticent flower,

A curiously clear-cut, candid flower,

Standing beside clean doorways,

Friendly to a house-cat and a pair of spectacles,

Making poetry out of a bit of moonlight

And a hundred or two sharp blossoms.

Maine knows you,

Has for years and years;

New Hampshire knows you,

And Massachusetts

And Vermont.

Cape Cod starts you along the beaches to Rhode Island;

Connecticut takes you from a river to the sea.

You are brighter than apples,

Sweeter than tulips,

You are the great flood of our souls

Bursting above the leaf-shapes of our hearts,

You are the smell of all Summers,

The love of wives and children,

The recollection of gardens of little children,

You are State Houses and Charters

And the familiar treading of the foot to and fro on a road it knows.

May is lilac here in New England,

May is a thrush singing “Sun up!” on a tip-top ash tree,

May is white clouds behind pine-trees

Puffed out and marching upon a blue sky.

May is a green as no other,

May is much sun through small leaves,

May is soft earth,

And apple-blossoms,

And windows open to a South Wind.

May is full light wind of lilac

From Canada to Narragansett Bay.

 

Lilacs,

False blue,

White,

Purple,

Color of lilac.

Heart-leaves of lilac all over New England,

Roots of lilac under all the soil of New England,

Lilac in me because I am New England,

Because my roots are in it,

Because my leaves are of it,

Because my flowers are for it,

Because it is my country

And I speak to it of itself

And sing of it with my own voice

Since certainly it is mine.’’

 

-- “Lilacs,’’ by Amy Lowell


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.