Finneran: Income Inequality

Tom Finneran, GoLocalProv MINDSETTER™

Finneran: Income Inequality

Those two words---income inequality---are uttered quite frequently these days. It seems as if every aspirant for public office feels obliged to cite it as a clear and present danger to the Republic.

Yet for the thousands of times I‘ve heard candidates utter those two words, I cannot recall any reporters ever asking a question about the candidate’s “plan” to address and cure the issue.

I can concede that vast disparities in income can create a dual society. I cannot concede that government can fashion a solution without grabbing for itself an appalling power over our lives.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Virtually every modern society suffers some form of economic cleavage, most commonly described as the haves and the have-nots. Perhaps some ancient and isolated tribal societies had minuscule variations in individual wealth or “status”, but once regular contact develops with other societies a hierarchy of the ambitious, the industrious, and the talented begins to emerge. 

America, more than any other country, reflects that hierarchy of the industrious, that dual society which today seems to be the bane of those aspiring pols as they paint false portraits of greed and exploitation. 

Our Constitution sets the tone of America with its ban on titles of nobility. We have no kings here. No princes, no dukes, no earls. Here we have citizens, free men and women, free to strive and free to succeed.

Such freedom and such success has made America the envy of the world. People from all over the globe yearn to come to America, to escape economic and political systems which lock them in place.  They hope to make their own way, based on their effort.

And should their effort gain reward, why is that a bad thing? Profit and wealth are not social negatives. Rather, they are indicative of intelligence, effort, skill, innovation, and insight. They are indicative of the provision of a good or service which others judge as beneficial to their lives. One need not be a genius to build wealth. Every city and town in America has its share of industrious citizens---shopkeepers, merchants, farmers, contractors, mechanics---whose steady efforts can build success. These citizens are not Bill Gates or Steve Jobs. Yet in their own determined way they build a personal and social wealth that should be applauded and encouraged rather than scorned.

We should not castigate and condemn our ambitious and successful neighbor. If by dint of hard work and a particular skill that neighbor enjoys a better life, that’s great. If I choose to spend my evening hours staring blankly at the television while my neighbor is working a double shift or studying for an advanced degree, why should I envy his success? In my hypothetical, I have chosen to forego the road upon which he sweated and succeeded. Any envy on my part is both pathetic and unbecoming a free citizen.

Should my successful neighbors be subject to punitive measures or confiscatory taxation in order to appease my envy? Should candidates for office stir and stoke resentment of the ambitious, the industrious, and the talented citizens in our midst? Let’s hope not. 

Rather let’s hope that public leaders might drop the theatrical rhetoric, the “to the barricades” revolutionary rants, and seriously attend to the greatest equalizer of all time---a free and appropriate public education for all. It is from that foundation that opportunity springs.

It should be about building all folks up not tearing some folks down.

 

CORRECTION: An alert and well-informed reader took me to the woodshed last week, giving me a rebuke that was richly deserved. My identification of Julian Assange as a traitorous American citizen was wrong. Mr. Assange is an Australian, currently residing in the Embassy of Ecuador in London. A correct citation would have identified either Chelsea Manning or Edward Snowden as traitors whose actions endangered American agents. The error was mine. I apologize to my readers. 

Tom Finneran is the former Speaker of the Massachusetts House of Representatives, served as the head the Massachusetts Biotechnology Council, and was a longstanding radio voice in Boston radio.

Rhode Island’s 50 Wealthiest and Most Influential - 2015 Edition

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.