Parents in North Smithfield Fight for Examination of Cancer Concerns

Kate Nagle, GoLocal News Editor

Parents in North Smithfield Fight for Examination of Cancer Concerns

Instances of pediatric cancer in North Smithfield have some residents asking for more information about what the town uses for chemicals and where.
North Smithfield residents are asking the town to look into the chemicals used at schools and public spaces after a fifth case of pediatric cancer in five years was recently diagnosed, to rule out any environmental factors -- and sides are sparring about how to go about doing so. 

A North Smithfield School Committee meeting on Wednesday ended with accusations of “recklessness” — and a subsequent backlash — after Chair Merredythe Nadeau admonished board member James Lombardi for putting forth an agenda proposal to discuss a “report on the grounds for contaminates and listing of chemicals used on school properties."

Nadeau and Lombardi got into a heated exchange on camera with Lombardi taking issue with Nadeau changing the wording of his agenda request — and the Chair’s reluctance to have updated environmental reports be a standing agenda item. 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

See Video BELOW

“At 3:20 of this video you will see one Merredythe Nadeau of the North Smithfield School Board, call out Jim Lombardi for trying to put a motion to look into pesticides used in this town and keep it on the agenda to review monthly. Some quick background on this subject matter is the fact that recently there has been a uptick in kids diagnosed with cancer in North Smithfield,” wrote parent Michelle Galano on Facebook following the meeting. “Apparently she feels this is not an issue of importance. As a parent who has had a child with cancer in this town I find it of the utmost importance and am truly perturbed by this woman's actions and attitude towards this subject. Hopefully at the next meeting there will be much more of a presence in order for our voices to be heard.”

Nadeau did not respond to request for comment on Thursday. 

One Parent’s Story - and Reaction

“I got involved because there's been what seems like a high incidence of cancer in town,” Galano told GoLocalProv.com. “My daughter was diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in 2013  - she was four at the time. It’s most commonly linked to environmental factors. She just finished chemo, it’s a two and a half year treatment. She's just getting back into the swing of things, she had to miss all of kindergarten.”

The North Smith field School Committee discussing agenda issues following the meeting.
“When we learned of another case of cancer last week, after another child was diagnosed in December, this has increasingly concerned a lot of parents,” said Galano. “We don't think the schools have anything to do with it, they're not all the same types of cancer -- but we want to make sure that the [schools] aren't responsible, and we want to show what's being used is not the cause. We just want to know the products are safe, both now and anything they use in the future. It's not a one and done thing.”

Galano told GoLocal that in addition to her daughter, the recent cases of pediatric cancer in North Smithfield -- which has a population of just over 12,000 --  include an 11-year-old boy in 2012 with DIPG (incurable brain tumor), a ten-year-old girl in 2014 with Osteosarcoma, an eight-year-old boy in 2015 with Leukemia, and an eight-year-old girl in 2016 with Osteosarcoma. 

Latest School Committee Meeting

Following the school committee meeting on August 16, where North Smithfield schools facilities manager Martin Shaw presented what products were currently being used, and what still need to be tested, Lombardi called for all of the information to be made public on the town’s website — but not before he admonished Nadeau for changing his agenda request to a more innocuous “Green Schools — List of Chemicals Used on School Grounds” line item. 

VIDEO: Watch Full School Committee Meeting HERE (Discussion regarding chemicals starts at 18:20)

“You didn't put the proper agenda item down. That's not what I put on the agenda,” said Lombardi. “It was not the agenda item I asked for. It was changed.”

When another board member questioned what it was Lombardi asked for, Nadeau interjected. 

“You're right I changed it. I thought it was rather reckless on short notice to put something on the agenda that might cause parents to be frightened about sending their children to school,” said Nadeau. “I had lengthy conversations with the school committee attorney and superintendent, it was our collective decision to word it on the agenda they way it was worded.”

Galano reacted to seeing the video of the post-meeting discussion. 

“I just want to know our schools our safe, and I think this information can only serve to calm people - trust me, people are already concerned, putting it on the agenda wasn’t going to do anything,” said Galano. “These are our children at our schools.  If we have to beat the issue to death, we will. I don’t know why it’s such a big deal.”


Rhode Island's Best Communities 2016

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.