Finneran: When "Less Asian" Is Less American

Tom Finneran, GoLocalProv MINDSETTER™

Finneran: When "Less Asian" Is Less American

First it was the Jews…well no, not really, because even before the Jews started their rapid and well-earned ascent in American life, there were the blacks who were blocked off from just about every  avenue of economic and educational opportunity. Now I guess it’s the Asians…

A Boston Globe story tells the tale of aspiring Asian students seeking admission to America’s elite colleges being told to act “less Asian” in their studies, in their extracurricular activities, and in their declarations of intended course majors. Can you think of anything less American? Young American students are essentially being told to don a mask and to pretend to be something that they are not. Why would any nation, let alone the United States of all places, want to camouflage achievement? A nation whose legend is one of spectacular success in multiple fields of endeavor by people from all corners of the world no matter what the circumstances of their birth or their religious beliefs, now seems confused by such success and determined to put us all in ugly and limiting racial and ethnic categories. We have become so silly about this stuff that it’s probably a federal crime to check off the wrong racial box, or to say “simply American”, or better yet to say “drop dead” to the bean counters who deem this stuff important. Call the gendarmes. Today’s feds won’t tolerate such classic American impudence. 

An anonymous Harvard professor has been quoted as saying that “if we admitted students on the merits of their applications, our student body would be 85% Asian”. That quote was reported to have been made more than twenty years ago! 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Now I can understand that Harvard doesn’t want its campus and its classrooms to be a reflection of a bustling street in Beijing. And I accept the fact that as a private university they can admit whomever they design to choose, including the half-wit sons of wealthy alumni. The balancing acts performed at top-notch colleges and universities admissions offices are daunting, in part because of the overwhelming number of highly-qualified applicants and also because of the school’s yearly need to build a true community of talents—academic, musical, athletic, dramatic, literary  experiential, etc.

Yet it still strikes me as wrong that there is this “bamboo ceiling”, an anti-Asian bias that’s as distasteful in its implications as the historical  bias against Jews, blacks, the Irish ,the Italians and of course the Catholics. When oh when oh Lord will we become a truly color-blind merit-based and merit-driven society?

Young people of course must be reminded and consoled that a happy and successful life is rarely determined by where one went to school. Many are the pompous fools who have an Ivy League degree. And many are the resourceful and fascinating high-achievers whose schools don’t appear in the U.S. News’ elite college rankings. I used to joke around with my very well-educated and talented staff that behind every foolish idea or decision they would find a “Harvard man”. My personal preferences were for the service academies and for Holy Cross graduates, a personal bias to be sure.

Equally galling these days is the notion of “white privilege”, brought to you by chronically unhappy and virtually unemployable academics. Why Eric Holder’s kids should get any edge over some poor kid from Brockton or Worcester is beyond me. “Privilege” in America has historically been earned and if Mr. Holder’s kids are the beneficiaries of his earned achievements then I have no gripe. That his income and position and prestige might open doors for them is a fact of life which I accept. But don’t tell me that the son or daughter of a white janitor from Worcester gets a limo ride through life via white privilege. That’s pure nonsense.

Back to the poor Asians who apparently must now act out of character to their natural competitive impulse. The Globe quotes from some of the advice given to Asian-American applicants regarding their college essays: “ Don’t write about your immigrant family. Don’t talk about your family coming from Vietnam with $2 in a rickety boat and swimming away from sharks”.

Gee, silly old me, but I’d prefer that my sons and daughters sit right next to someone like that who came here not knowing a word of English and who became class valedictorian. But what do I know. I’m just a dumb beneficiary of white privilege.

And as for acting “less Asian”, put me down as a contrarian. We should all act more Asian, more often.

Tom Finneran is the former Speaker of the Massachusetts House of Representatives, served as the head the Massachusetts Biotechnology Council, and was a longstanding radio voice in Boston radio.


New England College Super Rankings 2014

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.