“This Is Anyone’s Race,” Say Experts on Battle for 1st Congressional Seat

GoLocalProv News Team and Kate Nagle

“This Is Anyone’s Race,” Say Experts on Battle for 1st Congressional Seat

Congressman David Cicilline resigns in May. PHOTO: GoLocal
Two top political scientists tell GoLocal that the race for the soon-to-be vacant first congressional seat is wide open.

Congressman David Cicilline announced that he is stepping down from his seat in Congress to take over the position as the head of the Rhode Island Foundation and collect a salary of $650,000 for the group dedicated to supporting those in need.

The announcement over the past few days that Speaker of the House Joe Shekarchi and former CVS executive Helena Foulkes are not running has opened this race up for any number of candidates to win this race.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

“Foulkes’ decision not to run for the seat means that there’s no obvious frontrunner," said the Chair of the Political Science Department at the University of Virginia, Jennifer Lawless.

"Foulkes has statewide name recognition and deep pockets, two of the most important predictors of electoral success, especially in a relatively short campaign," said Lawless. "That’s not to say she would have won – many different dynamics would have been in play and low turnout could help an underdog – but her presence as a candidate would likely have deterred others from throwing their hats into the ring. Now, there’s no such deterrent,”

 

SEE WHO IS IN, NOT ANNOUNCED, AND OUT BELOW

To date, only two candidates have announced they are running — Lt. Governor Sabina Matos and State Senator Sandra Cano.

 

RIC Professor Val Endress PHOTO: GoLocal
Professor Val Endress of the School of Communication at Rhode Island College said, “When both House Speaker K. Joseph Shekarchi and former CVS top executive Helena Foulkes announced that they won't be running for the seat vacated by David Cicilline, it changed the dynamics of the race.  The size of Shekarchi's campaign war chest and Foulkes' ability to self-finance may have deterred other potential candidates or, perhaps, limited other candidates' goals to merely gaining more name recognition for a future run for statewide office.”

 

Cheap Race, Low Turnout

“Given that this is now anyone’s race, it’s hard to predict how expensive it’ll be. On the one hand, it’s possible to imagine a crop of candidates who are local politicians without substantial donor bases or personal funds. These women and men could treat the race similarly to how they’ve treated those they’ve already won – relatively inexpensive operations that are contingent on turning out their voters. In a crowded field, 5,000 votes might be all it takes to win, and that doesn’t require hundreds of thousands of dollars,” said Lawless.

UVA Professor Jennifer Lawless PHOTO: File
“On the other hand, a key way to differentiate yourself from your opponents is to demonstrate an ability to raise tons of money and make national connections. So, there could be pressure on all the candidates to outraise and outspend the rest of the field. That’s a way to build name recognition beyond your current constituency, generate media coverage, and position yourself for the next federal race in 2024. My bet is that at least one candidate will go big. Again, though, it’s a crowded field, so spending big might not predict winning big,” added Lawless

 

Lt. Governor Sabina Matos was first to announce for the seat.
Serving in the Minority in Congress

Endress said, “Foulkes recognizes what Gina Raimondo also views as a fundamental disadvantage in this particular congressional race:  The executive functions performed by a governor don't necessarily compare to the skill set needed for a new member of Congress—and especially when one is entering as a member of the minority party.  By virtue of his well-honed debate and media skills, David Cicilline was a standout.  He never backed away from a fight and this characteristic served him well.”  

“Those who are running for this seat will need to have that same drive and be willing to work their way through the labyrinth of congressional committees in order to showcase their skills. It's a much longer slog to get the same sort of recognition.  In many ways the gubernatorial race can be more grueling, but it does offer you the spotlight from the moment of your inauguration and can be a more attractive to candidates who have extensive corporate leadership experience,” added Endress


Potential First Congressional District Candidates - June 13, 2023

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.