No Action by Providence Police on Beating Video, Two Months Later

GoLocalProv News Team and Kate Nagle

No Action by Providence Police on Beating Video, Two Months Later

A photo of the video in question.
More than two months after a video surfaced of a Providence police officer punching a woman during an arrest, the Providence Police Department has not made a ruling as to whether the force was excessive

The revelation comes as community groups are pushing for the passage of the Community Safety Act (CSA), which has a hearing before the City Council on September 14 -- and would include reinstating the Providence External Review Authority.

"This would definitely be an instance of PERA oversight. That is clearly police harassment and brutality, that amount of force is never justified," said Vanessa Flores-Maldonado, the Campaign Coordinator for the STEP Up coalition supporting the CSA, of the incident recorded in the video. 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

On Wednesday, Providence Chief of Police Colonel Hugh Clements said the internal investigation of the physical altercation, which had taken place on May 23, is still ongoing. 

"We're still awaiting final disposition," said Clements. "As an assurance, we had many take a look at it -- we discussed it [Wednesday morning] at our advisory board, in fact. Everything's been up front and there's been a thorough investigation. There's been no final report yet, but there will be one forthcoming."

Call for Review Authority, Additional Oversights

The coalition of groups pushing once again for the passage of the CSA are calling for twelve action items pertaining to establishing rules against racial profiling; searchings, recordings, and surveillance, in addition to the PERA community oversight.

In their description of next week's hearing on Wednesday, the group wrote:

The Providence Community Safety Act is a city-wide proposed ordinance that aims to hold police accountable and make our communities safer. Developed by community members and organizations who are frustrated with police harassment and lack of accountability, the CSA has 12 key points that outline how police officers should interact with community members. These points range from video recording to traffic stops to the gang database. A summary of the key points as well as the full act of the ordinance can be found on our website.

"In terms of the public safety division, we'd need to hear from them on this," said City Councilman John Igliozzi on Wednesday. "I support body cameras. I haven't gotten feedback on this from the Commissioner, as to what they like and don't like -- and if there's a financial note."

"We all want a safe city," continued Igliozzi. "One of the council's initiatives was that we put money in for two police academies. We are at a seriously low level of police on the force. We were once 496 - we're close to 400 now -- that's not good for the city of Providence. We need more community police, more presence, and we need more boots on ground."

"So anything that would make the city safety that seems reasonable, I'm not sure who would be against. But if something comes with a big price tag, maybe there's an alternative," said Igliozzi. "The auditor [already] preditcts the fire department will spend $7 million over [the year's budget] alone. Public safety finances are not in sync with what [the department] comes to us with."

Group organizer Flores-Maldonado spoke to meeting with the city -- and the group's insistence on all twelve of the items they are requesting be met.

"Last summer we met with [police] several times and in May when we thought we were meeting with Mayor Elorza, it ultimately ended up being a meeting with the police," said Flores-Maldonado. "We are no longer open to compromise. We want the full bill to be passed."

CSA Prospects

City Councilman David Salvatore weighed in on what he thought were the CSA's current prospects on Wednesday. 

"I know that some changes have been embraced, and there are things that remain," said Salvatore of the current CSA. "It's my understanding that the city solicitor has some issues with what the city can, or can't do, legally, for starters."

"I think there's been increased -- and better -- communications between police and community groups. I know Councilman Yurdin passed a resolution about creating a task force to bring all these folks to the table," continued Salvatore. "Anything that will improve relations between community and police department is a good thing. But I think a lot of improvements have already been made."

On Wednesday, Clements spoke to both the CSA proposal -- and recent legislative changes that have already been made addressing some of the issues. 

"We continue to have talks relative to what we can agree to, and to come to a better understanding," said Clements of discussions with the groups pushing for the CSA. "We passed [the Comprehensive Community-Police Relationship Act] at the state level, landmark legislation that's looked at regionally as a very good state bill -- and lot of the initial components of the CSA were satisfied in that."


Rhode Island’s 50 Wealthiest and Most Influential - 2015 Edition

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.