Robert Whitcomb: Raimondo’s Correct Veto; NFL Kneeling Distraction; Losing NE's Forrest

GoLocalProv

Robert Whitcomb: Raimondo’s Correct Veto; NFL Kneeling Distraction; Losing NE's Forrest

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist
“Sunny days with drifting clouds

Football matches spilling crowds
Cold grey mornings, grassy dew
Chilly winds that blew and blew
Blowing leaves off all the trees
Final song of wasps and bees
Spiders looking for a mate
Found in baths await their fate.’’

-- From “October,’’ by David Wood

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

 

“Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.’’

--- Samuel Johnson

 

(The famous 18th Century English writer was not talking about real patriotism but exaggerated rhetorical patriotism aimed at gaining popularity.)

 

xxx

 

Many New Englanders know that much of New England used to be open farmland, a lot of it pasturage, but with lots of crops grown in the valleys, especially the Connecticut River’s. But as the region’s farming declined,  and manufacturing and then modern services became dominant, the woodlands returned, eventually making New England one of the most densely populated but thickly wooded areas in the world.

 

I once had one of those panoramic photos, taken about 1905 of the hills of Norwich, Vt., as seen from Hanover, N.H., which showed open fields with sheep grazing on them. New England used to have a big woolen-textiles industry. I looked at the same hills the other week and they seemed completely covered with trees. When the leaves fall off in the autumn you can see houses owned by the affluent people who have moved to town, at least from May to October.

 

The small town-becoming–a-Boston suburb I lived in as a boy had several farms; one was across the street from us. I’m told that one is now part of the estate of a Fidelity Investments executive. We loved going over there and irritating a bull.

 

Now a new Harvard Forest report says that reforestation had halted. The region was losing 24,000 acres of woodland a year to development from 1990 to 2010, most of it to residential building.  Such deforestation is thought to be continuing although more recent data are lacking. The researchers also found that funding for land conservation in the region has fallen 50 percent since the financial crash of 2008 and that the acreage of woodland being conserved annually has dropped from 333,000 to 50,000 a year since 2010.

 

Jonathan Thompson, a senior scientist at Harvard Forest and one of the study’s authors, told Harvard Gazette: “Peak forest cover is over in New England. For more than 150 years, forests expanded and regrew. That history is how we gained the status of as among the most populated and most forested regions in the world.’’

 

At the current rate of deforestation, Mr. Thompson said, the region will lose woodlands equivalent to twice the size of Rhode Island by 2060. (Poor Little Rhody – the yardstick for everything.) This would mean the destruction of some eco-systems, and thus possibly the extinction of some regional flora and fauna. It will also undermine attempts to slow global warming: Woodlands lock up carbon dioxide.

 

Let’s hope that state and local policymakers take stronger measures to protect New England’s woodlands, which, with our plentiful water, may be our greatest environmental comparative advantage.

 

To read more, please hit this link: 

 

xxx

 

Governor Gina Raimondo
Kudos to Rhode Island Gov. Gina Raimondo for vetoing an outrageous bill that would let firefighters retire early with big tax-free disability pensions (worth two-thirds of their salaries)  based on their assertions that their cardiovascular disease was caused by their work.  But all kinds of people can get this most common of serious chronic diseases. (I had a triple bypass myself). You can get it if you sit at a desk all day, or drive a truck. This bill is yet another attempted theft of public money aimed at pleasing a special-interest group.

 

Will the state General Assembly sustain this excellent veto? Let us hope that the voters, who would have to pay the higher property taxes to support what would be a new wave of cushy very early retirements, hold them accountable.

 

xxx

 

Whatever else Trump and his remaining GOP allies on  Capitol Hill do with “tax reform,’’ you can be sure that they’ll  fight particularly hard to eliminate the federal estate tax. They’re devoted to ensuring that those children wise enough to pick rich parents will be born on home plate. As will their children and their children and ….Gotta protect the Western World’s most extreme income inequality!

 

xxx

 

While watching The Vietnam War series on PBS, I remembered my late father and me watching CBS News in the summer of ’65 as the war was heating up. My dad, a combat veteran of World War II  (North Africa, Europe and the Pacific) who retired from the Navy as a lieutenant commander, looked at me, and very quietly said: “I don’t think you’d look good in uniform.’’ Like many conservatives, he thought that the war was a fool’s errand – an extreme overreaching into a swamp, literal and otherwise.

 

xxx

 

NFL's kneeling controversy
The inane controversy over many NFL players kneeling during the National Anthem as a sign of solidarity against racism predictably brought out the fraud that is Donald Trump.

 

The con-man-in-chief tried to wrap himself in the flag but only succeeded in showing yet again what a clown he is as he demanded that NFL owners fire their millionaire kneeling employees.

 

Trump is not a patriot. He is a pathologically narcissistic crook, who has installed a family-based kleptocracy in the White House, after being assisted into office by a foreign dictatorship. We’re on our way to banana republic status.

 

Meanwhile, the national Republican Party, which he hijacked, in part with assistance from the Kremlin, has been taken over by plutocrats, con men  (many, such as Pat Robertson, making millions selling bogus versions of Christianity) and knownothings who have no respect for science. (Some believe, or want to believe, that the world was created less than 10,000 years ago.)

 

Nobody’s perfect!

 

Things can only get crazier, with the likely election to the Senate of Alabaman right-wing crank, religious fanatic and policy ignoramus Roy Moore after he defeated establishment figure and Trump suck-up Luther Strange in last Tuesday’s primary. Characteristically,  after Moore’s victory, our leader deleted a bunch of tweets he’d sent out backing Strange and pledged his troth to the paleolithic Moore, who at least served bravely in Vietnam.

 

 In “the Kneeling Crisis,’’ Trump was simply trying to divert attention from his corruption and incompetence. (But shouldn’t a president spend at least a little time administrating the Executive Branch? Too boring?)

 

As a TV star, the president has been good at such diversions, especially among those who get all their “information’’ from the likes of Fox News, but his efforts are wearing thin, even among some of his wishful-thinking fans who have happily swallowed his snake oil. The latest chaotic attempt to kill the Affordable Care Act and the sluggish response in relief for hurricane-devastated Puerto Rico (hey, not many Republicans there!) is another reminder to them of their leader’s problematic qualities as a leader, not that many of his most fervent followers care much about Puerto Rico one way or another.

 

Trump’s fanatical fans comprise perhaps a third of the electorate, and around two-thirds of the population don’t like him. So you’d think he was doomed. But the two-thirds are still too disorganized to take him down.

 

Anyway, the NFL players have every right to express their views by kneeling, or standing on their heads, for that matter. Of course, the very rich NFL team owners also have every right to punish them for their display of the

First Amendment, one of the laws that the flag represents. (Believe it or not, “Deplorables,’’ there are other amendments besides the Second.)

 

But these athletes have no constitutional right to be employed by this corner of the entertainment business. In any event, as long as they continue to play well, they’ll be employed. This is all about the money.

 

Still, I forecast the NFL shows won’t go on forever. The piles of medical evidence showing that playing professional football can be lethal for many players continue to get higher. Eventually, perhaps when a retired Tom Brady starts to exhibit signs of dementia in a decade, these gladiatorial contests will stop. Millions will miss the pleasure of seeing a 300-pound player crash into a 250-pound one, but popular culture will continue to provide many other violent alternatives. In the meantime, the NFL owners will do anything they can to keep the money pouring in.

 

xxx

 

I was intrigued by the agreement that  Vermont’s private Thetford Academy (founded in 1819), in the Upper Connecticut Valley town of the same name,  has with several public schools in the area, including the Lyme, N.H., public schools, that lets students attend Thetford Academy.  (Lyme has no high school.)

 

In this very unusual two-state arrangement, about 25 percent of Lyme’s high-school students go to Thetford Academy. Another 25 percent go to the also private St. Johnsbury Academy, way up the river in the town of the same name. About half go to Hanover (N.H.) High School, a regular public high school, and a small number to other schools in the region.  

 

Adding to the Upper Valley’s very usual (for the U.S.) relationships is that, as I’ve  recently written, Hanover is part of the two-state Dresden School District- -- the only one in America. Rather complex cross tuition/voucher arrangements pay for this.

 

The principal of the Lyme School District, Jeff Valence, told the Valley News: “The relationship we’ve built over the years…has brought something really special to the educational landscape here. The fact that families can choose to send their kids to an independent academy, while still upholding the tenets of public education, is very important to us.’’

 

Such arrangements may provide models for schools elsewhere, especially in tight, densely populated southern New England. Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Massachusetts school officials should study the northern examples, which might be applicable to them, especially for communities along state lines and with a good mix of private and public schools. To read more, please hit this link:

 

 

xxx

 

Amazon
Worcester is putting in its own bid to get Amazon’s “second headquarters’’ in addition to being part of the  Massachusetts application to the Seattle-based monster. Not a bad idea – two lottery tickets instead of just one.  But it is hard to see Worcester having the infrastructure, techno personnel, and tax-break resources to lure Amazon and what the company asserts will be 50,000 new employees. Maybe, like Providence, they could get a couple of small slices of the pie if Amazon picks Boston. (I still bet on Austin.)

 

 

xxx

 

I ask again: Why does Massachusetts, a rich state, refuse to help pay to build sports stadiums for private companies while much poorer Rhode Island is looking to cough up such money for the PawSox?

 

xxx

 

Michelle Goldberg’s debut column in The New York Times raised troubling questions about the continued legitimacy, or perceived legitimacy, of our republic. The question is whether the ongoing rule by an increasingly ruthless minority will undermine faith in our government system.

 

It’s not only that the Republican George W. Bush won the White House in 2000 despite having received more than half a million fewer popular votes than Democrat Al Gore or that Trump won in 2016 despite having gotten almost 3 million fewer votes than Hillary Clinton.

 

The Electoral College system greatly favors small, rural states that tend to support the GOP. We do have a federal system. Deal with it!

 

More dubious is that congressional-district gerrymandering by the GOP (which is almost always far more, er, clever and rigorous than the Democrats’) has made it increasingly difficult for Republicans to lose control of the U.S. House.  Consider that a Brookings Institution study found that in last year’s House elections Republicans won 55.2 percent of the seats but under 50 percent of the votes. Similar things have been going on in state legislative battles. And remember, whichever party controls a state’s legislature designs the congressional districts after the U.S. Census every 10 years.

 

If Democrats voted with the same frequency as Republicans, they’d probably win most elections. So they must blame their own sloth as well as a system that has long structurally favored the GOP. Still, it must be said that if this goes on, and an increasing percentage of Americans feel disenfranchised as a result, the nation may face a legitimacy crisis and social disorder. It could, in the end, even lead to a breakup of the country; no nation lasts forever…..

 

xxx

 

Tom Price resigned
Tom Price, M.D., a rich former orthopedic surgeon and now a former (just fired!) U.S. health & human services secretary, is a fairly good representative of the Trump regime – greedy, corrupt, arrogant, privileged, materialistic and hypocritical.

 

As a congressman, he drafted bills that favored medically related companies he’s invested in. After complaining about wasteful federal spending, he flew around as HHS boss on private jets on “business trips’’ that included a lot of very personal luxury “business’’ and sent the taxpayers a total bill of at least $400,000 for the fun.  (Late last week, caught in that scandal, he said he’d pay back some of the money.)

 

But wait! There’s more! He also cost the taxpayers $500,000 for multinational trips he took with his wife on military planes. He claims he paid for his wife.

 

In his HHS role, he worked to sabotage long-overdue programs to move from our astronomically expensive fee-for-service health “system’’ toward a value-and-outcomes-based one because it might slightly reduce the compensation of the world’s most highly paid physicians.

 

And he has worked hard to avoid taking hard questions from the news media or indeed the general public.

 

He is, in short, a pompous crook, making him fit right in with many of the other deluxe luminaries in the upper echelons of the Trump regime. But at least he didn’t request that the government fly him and his glitterati/fashion-obsessed wife at taxpayer expense to Paris for a honeymoon, as did mega-rich Wall Street operator and now Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin.

 

xxx

 

This time of year reminds me of fishing for smelt, which would run from fall into winter. I grew up in a house up a hill from a harbor on Massachusetts Bay. When it started to get cool in late September and early October, we’d take bamboo rods with several hooks attached to something that looked a little like a coat hanger down to a dock and try to catch as many of these small fish to take home and fry in butter. They were delicious. We’d do this several times a week until November, when it was usually too cold and windy to enjoy such fishing.

It was a quiet seasonal joy.

 

 

xxx

 

About 80 percent of Holyoke, Mass., public school students are of Puerto Rican descent. Now district officials are preparing for a flood of new students as a result of the ravages of hurricanes Irma and, especially, Maria, in that U.S. commonwealth. Other urban school districts in southern New England, especially in Massachusetts and Connecticut, that have lots of Puerto Ricans, are making similar arrangements.

What will immediately help the ravaged island is suspension of the Jones Act, which requires goods shipped between American ports to only be carried on ships built primarily in the United States and with U.S. citizens as their owners and crews. Happily, President Trump, last week suspended the law. But it may be time to get rid of it for good.

The idea behind this 1920 law was to protect the American shipping business.

But the Jones Act dramatically raises the prices of goods brought into the island. Puerto Ricans must absorb extra shipping costs of items that could be shipped directly and much more cheaply from a nearby island, such as Hispaniola or Jamaica. The Jones Act forces shippers to route through an American port, in Puerto Rico’s case most likely from Jacksonville and Miami.

 

Puerto Rico desperately needs supplies to start to recover from these terrible storms.

 

For the longer term, Daniel W. Drezner, of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts wrote:

 

“This is not just about recovering from Hurricane Maria. It is also about Puerto Rico’s long-term future. If the Jones Act were suspended, consumer prices would drop by 15 percent to 20 percent and energy costs would plummet. A post-Jones Puerto Rico could modernize its infrastructure and develop its own island-based shipping industry. Indeed, the island could become a shipping hub between South America, the Caribbean and the rest of the world. This industry would generate thousands of jobs and opportunities for skilled laborers and small businesses. On an island with official unemployment over 10 percent (but actually closer to 25 percent), this would energize their entire workforce.’’

 

Meanwhile, it continues to be perverse that residents of Puerto Rico and the nearby U.S. Virgin Islands, while American citizens who can serve in our armed forces, can’t vote in U.S. elections. But that, of course, goes back to the fact that Puerto Rico is not a state. Out of fairness and for national-security concerns, the island, perhaps combining with the U.S. Virgin Islands, should become one.

 

If it had been a state, it probably wouldn’t have suffered the lethal delays in receiving aid after the hurricanes.  Statehood would mean that Puerto Ricans would have to pay federal taxes but that the respect and assistance that they’d get as full parts of the United States would make that well worth it.

 

xxx

 

MA Governor Charlie Baker
Joshua Miller, of The Boston Globe, had a nice summary of the success (so far) of Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker:

 

“His wonky, straightforward style stands in stark contrast to that of his party’s bombastic leader, President Trump.

“What’s more, Massachusetts’ economy is strong, and unemployment is low; there’s a sense among voters that the state is generally headed in the right direction, while the nation is on the wrong track; Baker has crafted a likable media persona; he’s presented himself as a fiscal check on the Democratic Legislature; and there’s been an apparent dearth of crises in state government.

“’He’s not an ideologue, and voters here, at least in their governor’s office, prefer managers and problem solvers,’ said political science professor Peter Ubertaccio, dean of the School of Arts and Sciences at Stonehill College. ‘He’s like the uncle who is always glad to see you and give you good advice, even if you’re not going to take it. He strikes folks as a decent guy and a good manager, and that just fits the moment.’”

Most GOP governors (which means now most governors) govern with far more practicality and cooler rhetoric than members of Congress. They have to, in order to get anything important done. Actually governing/administering, and coming up with the compromises and solutions to do so, is a hell of a lot tougher than bloviating on Capitol Hill, where people are rarely held responsible for much of anything, as long as they’re good on TV.

Federal legislators spend remarkably little time actually legislating, as opposed to raising money and giving speeches. In recent decades they ‘ve spent less and less time working according to their constitutional job description and much less time working across the aisle to craft bipartisan bills.

 

xxx

 

History has proven time and again that appeasement of dictators always makes the world less, not more, secure. Thus it has been with payoffs and “negotiations’’ with brutal regimes of Iran and especially North Korea by administrations going back to Bill Clinton’s.  Sabotage and even direct but limited military strikes when these regimes were weaker would have left us much safer. It’s much tougher now to “manage’’ their threats. We’ve allowed North Korea to become nuclear-armed and Iran will probably soon be too,  with help from North Korea!

 

President Trump has described these malevolent regimes accurately. His recent denunciation of Iran, North Korea and Venezuela at the U.N.  was refreshing after predecessors’ evasions, euphemisms and wishful-thinking. But given his history of incoherent bluster and BS, he doesn’t seem to scare them. And given his disdain of international cooperation, lack of interest in human rights and, indeed, admiration for some dictators, he wasn’t exactly the best spokesman for denouncing the likes of North Korea.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.