Former Projo Editor Whitcomb: "Providence Came Back in Spite of Buddy"

Kate Nagle, GoLocalProv News Editor

Former Projo Editor Whitcomb: "Providence Came Back in Spite of Buddy"

Former Editor of Editorial Page at the Providence Journal, Robert Whitcomb
GoLocal interviewed former Providence Journal editorial page editor Robert Whitcomb on the legacy of Vincent "Buddy" Cianci.  The following is what Whitcomb had to say:

Buddy Cianci was a grossly misinterpreted figure.  I think he took a lot of credit for stuff he didn't have to do with. The moving of the [Providence] River, for instance, came mostly from John Chafee. Capitol Center was another one. [Cianci] took credit for everything he could, and he was a genius for it.  Even Bruce Sundlun had something more to do with moving the river. 

The public is immature -- a lot of it is they like the entertainment quality. I think Providence came back in spite of, not because of, Buddy. There were companies that were scared away.  He was a carnival barker. The better stuff would have happened anyway, the city would have come back. 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Providence had a bad stretch, but even as a mid-sized city, it was turning around. Providence still had big businesses here back then -- Michael Metcalf [with the Providence Journal], Fleet, Hospital Trust, we had a lot of civic minded people who helped save the city, the Biltmore [Hotel] from being torn down.  Despite its depravity, Providence had a lot of things going for it. 

Vincent "Buddy" Cianci
Cianci got elected because he split the Democratic party the first time around.  I don't know if he even won legally one the second time -- it was only because the Republican candidate took a large pension.  The idea of Buddy being overwhelmingly popular is a myth, and I blame the city for swallowing it. He created a cult of personality around himself, and people looked the other way. Buddy gave away the store to unions. 

I didn't dislike Buddy, I was sometimes irate with the city for falling for his line.  We could have had a competent mayor like [Mayor] La Guardia in New York.  People say [Cianci] may be a crook, but he promoted the city -- but you can have a mayor who gets things done who isn’t corrupt. Mayor Reilly, the [former] Mayor of Charleston, he’s very honest, and a great promoter. You don't have to have exhibitionist, or a narcissist, to be a good mayor.  But I'll miss the wisecracks.
 


Community Leaders and Friends React to Cianci's Death

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.