Robert Whitcomb: GOP’s Healthcare Hell & State Police’s laughable 38 Studios ‘Investigation'

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Robert Whitcomb: GOP’s Healthcare Hell & State Police’s laughable 38 Studios ‘Investigation'

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist
Now for the GOP’s Healthcare Hell; State Police’s laughable 38 Studios ‘Investigation’; Distributive Power; Trump Wall vs. Wildlife

 

“You expected to be sad in the fall. Part of you died each year when the leaves fell from the trees and their branches were bare against the wind and the cold, wintery light. But you knew there would always be the spring, as you knew the river would flow again after it was frozen. When the cold rains kept on and killed the spring, it was as though a young person died for no reason.” 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST


― Ernest Hemingway, from A Moveable Feast

 

Crazy New England winter this year, with the coldest days near the end of it, testing our stoicism.

 

xxx

 

It has been amusing to read about the Republican contortions on healthcare.  After seven years of complaining about “Obamacare,’’ they have come up with a hypocritical mess.

 

For example, the legislation pushed by House Speaker Paul Ryan would allegedly get rid of the widely disliked (if  relatively small) penalties  for not signing up for insurance under the hated ‘’mandate’’. Not quite!

 

Rather, it would impose a surcharge (to be paid to the insurers) for people who go without insurance for 63 days (where did that number come from?) and then buy insurance. And the surcharge would be heftier than penalties under the current version of the ACA – “a flat 30 percent late enrollment surcharge on top of their (patients’) base premium for the next year,’’  the legislation says.

 

As Republican Sen. Rand Paul noted: “{The Republican program} keeps {the individual mandate but makes you pay the insurance companies instead of the government.’’

 

Still, this would be a one-time fee; that means that plenty of people would go without insurance for a while and then, when they start to get sick, sign up. This undermines the basis of any effective health-insurance plan – that people who are healthier subsidize those who are sick.  Obviously, when you make it so easy for people to avoid paying premiums until they’re older and sicker, the role of prevention in our healthcare system fades, making it harder for providers to keep people healthy, which of course tremendously raises overall medical costs.

 

In another dodge, the GOP plan would put off big cuts in Medicaid until after the 2018 elections.  Medicaid expansion under the ACA has been very popular in the states that took it, including Republican-run ones.

 

Despite the constant denunciations of the Affordable Care Act,  the fact is that a lot of it is very popular, such as barring discrimination against people with pre-existing conditions and letting young people up to age 26 stay on their parents’ policies,  both of which apparently would be kept in any bill that makes it to President Trump’s desk to sign. But in any event, the GOP bill writers have created a fiscally absurd arrangement that would also hurt far more patients (generally the poorer ones) than it helps (the affluent).

 

Many folks who say they hate “Obamacare’’ say they like the Affordable Care Act, which is exactly the same thing. The growing ignorance and civic sloth of large sections of the citizenry are, well, not comforting for a democracy. Consider our new president’s recent remark: “Nobody knew that healthcare could be so complicated.”  Eh? Nobody?

 

The triumph of H.L. Mencken’s Boobus Americanus

 

 

xxx

 

Many Rhode Islanders were mystified and then angered by the ridiculously superficial “investigation’’ by the Rhode Island State Police into the 38 Studios disaster, which still reverberates across the body politic.

 

They didn't question  then-House Speaker Gordon Fox (now residing in federal prison on an unrelated matter).  The State Police says: "Fox was not contacted at the request of his attorney, William Murphy.’’ Eh!? Couldn’t the State Police have gone ahead and interviewed him?

 

Former Speaker of the House Bill Murphy
Mr. Murphy, a former House speaker who remains a big-foot lobbyist at the State House, reportedly wanted to become lobbyist for 38 Studios and yet he wasn’t questioned either. The reason, the police said: "William Murphy did not want to answer questions due to his representation of Fox.’’ Nor did they interview Providence lawyer/fixer Michael Corso and some other key legislative and nonlegislative figures in the scandal.

 

The State Police “investigation’’ thus verges on being a joke. Rhode Islanders would like to know why it was so thin and unprofessional. It would have been much better if a highly respected lawyer, perhaps a retired federal judge, has been brought  in -- from out of state! --  to run a thorough, rigorous probe of who did what in the 38 Studios case and how to prevent something like this from happening again. Given the huge holes in the State Police report, it would still be worth bringing in such a person.

 

xxx

 

Much of the future of electricity will involve “distributive power,’’ in which instead of getting our electricity from big power plants, we’ll get a lot of it via small-scale renewable energy, often generated right where we live or work.  This reduces the political problems and endless delays of  siting big power plants and gives far more control to consumers. With recent huge efficiency improvements in renewables the “distributive-power’’ revolution can only speed up. (There are electricity-grid issues posed by this decentralization.)

 

A new example of the possibilities is “smartflower,’’ (smartflower.com) an Austrian solar-energy system that tracks the sun for maximum efficiency.  Looking like giant flowers, smartflower systems fold out every morning and then fold in at dusk. The manufacturer says it gets up to 40 percent more yield from sunlight  than does a roof-mounted system.

 

 You can put these things in your yard or on  flat roofs;  they take only an hour or two to be installed. And this fall, storage batteries will be available. Smartflower systems cost about $25,000 to buy and install; clean-energy tax credits would let you recoup some of this expense. And you can take these things with you when you move.

 

A smartflower unit will be on display at the entrance to the Rhode Island Home Show March 30-April 2 at the Rhode Island Convention Center. Take a look!

 

xxx

 

The great Trump wall on the U.S.-Mexico border will have major environmental effects. It will block normal movement of many mammals and reptiles, some of them endangered, preventing many of them from finding food and water, and perhaps causing the extinction of some of these species. As it is, and particularly in Developed Nations, highways, walls and urbanization are rapidly fragmenting and reducing habitat,  presenting dire threats to many animals.

 

Thus human over-population destroys at an accelerating rate the natural world.

 

xxx

 

Former Rhode Island Congressman Patrick Kennedy is quite right to say that legalizing  recreational marijuana throws “gasoline’’ on America’s addiction problems. (And you can bet that  lot of “medical marijuana’’ is being used entirely recreationally.) Pot is yet another gateway drug to worse ones and mental illness.

But now that there’s so much cash and potential  big tax revenue in the marijuana industry, don’t look for policymakers to follow Mr. Kennedy’s advice and crack down on this drug, whose use will soon be pervasive everywhere, including among drivers – if it isn't already.

 

xxx

 

President Donald Trump
Perhaps it will be a Republican senator who helps bring down the crook who is our president. One honorable and brave young Republican senator who can be expected to keep pushing back against this thug: Sen. Ben Sasse, of Nebraska. Better known GOP Trump skeptics (if that’s the word) include Senators John McCain and Lindsay Graham.

 

Back in 1954, Sen. Ralph Flanders {R.-Vt.) introduced a successful motion to censure fellow Republican Sen. Joseph McCarthy for his outrageous and lie-laden  attacks on individuals that came to be known as “McCarthyism’’. Mr. Flanders felt that McCarthy was distracting America from addressing real and serious threats and were creating division and confusion in the United States to the comfort of our enemies abroad. (Sound familiar?)

 

Senator Flanders pointed to McCarthy’s "misdirection of our efforts at fighting communism” and his role in “the loss of respect for us in the world at large.’’

 

And William Kristol, editor of the conservative Weekly Standard,  wrote the other day:

 

“And then 36 hours later, Saturday morning {on March 4}, we had Donald Trump's latest tweetstorm {alleging that then-President Obama had ordered wiretapping at Trump Tower}. Previous ones had been distasteful and vulgar and unseemly. But this one was different in the depth of its recklessness and irresponsibility. It threatens to unleash real damage on our institutional and constitutional order. Trump's accusing his predecessor of illegally wiretapping him, without presenting any evidence, will make partisan bitterness even more acrid, inflame relations between key institutions of the government, and generally threatens to undermine basic confidence in the rule of law. If Trump's suspicions are true, there are proper ways for him to see to it that they are thoroughly investigated. If the allegations are false, he shouldn't make them. But the whole issue of the Trump campaign, Russia, and the Obama administration now threatens our basic political health in a way we've rarely seen.’’

 

(Given Donald Trump’s close links with the Putin regime, I wouldn’t be surprised if the FBI (not President Obama) got a judge to authorize spying on Russia-related activities at Trump Tower.)

 

 

xxx

 

The shouting down  by students of a talk at Middlebury College, in Vermont, by conservative scholar and Bell Curve author Charles Murray and then the physical attack on Middlebury Prof. Allison Stanger (who walking with Mr. Murray) by people whose identities have not been established (Were they students or “outside agitators’’? They wore masks.) raises the big question of what the college is going to do about this assault on free speech and free inquiry at a place where both should be revered.

 

Will Middlebury take a powder on this and order a meaningless blue-ribbon committee to investigate and then do nothing? Probably. That’s what Brown University President Christine Paxson did when demonstrators stopped then New York Police Commissioner Ray Kelly from speaking in defense of his department’s “stop-and-frisk’’ policy. No students were punished although there was plenty of incriminating video, as there is of the Middlebury mess.

 

 

xxx

 

In perhaps happier Vermont news, voters in Sharon, Royalton, Strafford and Tunbridge have denounced a plan by a Utah engineer and Mormon activist to build a planned community for thousands of people known as “NewVistas”

 

Residents of Royalton, Sharon, Strafford and Tunbridge overwhelmingly approved resolutions opposing the “NewVistas’’ development.

 

David Hall, of Provo, has been buying up land on which to build a self-sustaining community of 20,000 on a 5,000-acre grid near the birthplace of Joseph Smith, the founder of the Mormon Church. (I have visited the Mormon museum in Royalton; quite interesting. A guide tried to get my then 10-year-old younger daughter to become a Mormon; she demurred.)

 

 “We have used these hills for hunting, fishing, a little bit of everything, and if David Hall comes in and does what he thinks he wants to do, I’m sure we’re not going to have a Tunbridge, or Sharon or Strafford or South Royalton anymore,” Ted Hoyt, an eighth-generation farmer, told Tunbridge Town Meeting.

 

Having spent a lot of time in the area at issue, I’m very sympathetic to Mr. Hall’s foes, who want to preserve this verdant pocket of old-time villages in a pastoral landscape. But if by some remote chance Mr. Hall gets this project done, you can bet  that it will be among the healthiest, cleanest and best-run places in America, given Mormon rules and habits.

 

xxx

Controlling Big Brother? Some Massachusetts state legislators want to restrict how the state can use data collected by the state’s new electronic tolling system.

 

Bills would prohibit the state Department of Transportation, which collects and stores the data, from using the data for virtually anything except collecting tolls and would prohibit sharing of the data without a court order.

 

Somewhat creepily, the system tracks and stores such data as speed and takes photos and videos as vehicles pass under the gantries.

 

Okay, we need some curbs on what is increasingly a surveillance society. But bear in mind  that companies, most notably Google, are following your moves with at least as much intensity as is  government.

 

xxx

The travel guide publisher DK Eyewitness Travel calls Worcester the 11th most overlooked -- or, (aka, underrated) -- destination city in the United States.

 

DK writes: "Once firmly in Boston's shadow, Massachusetts' second-largest city is fast developing as a creative hub in its own right. The phenomenal collection at the Worcester Art Museum, as well as contemporary galleries and arts programs such as ARTSWorcester, Worcester Windows, and the Worcester PopUp, contrast with historic attractions such as the elegant Salisbury Mansion, built in 1772."

 

"Foodies won't be disappointed either; the city pioneered the classic dining car, with Miss Worcester Diner open since 1948, and the current craft-beer scene championed by Wormtown Brewery.’’

 

So there!


 


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.