Whitcomb: Holiday Horrors; Break Up Facebook, Google, too; New Use for Brayton Point?

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Whitcomb: Holiday Horrors; Break Up Facebook, Google, too; New Use for Brayton Point?

Robert Whitcomb, GoLocal Columnist
“It is hard to hear the north wind again,

And to watch the treetops, as they sway.

They sway, deeply and loudly, in an effort,
So much less than feeling, so much less than speech….’’

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

-- From “The Region November,’’ by Wallace Stevens

 

 

“Power is the ultimate aphrodisiac.’’

-- Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger

 

“I just start kissing them. It’s like a magnet. Just kiss. I don’t even wait. And when you’re a star, they let you do it. You can do anything….

“Grab ’em by the {expletive}. You can do anything.’’

-- President Trump, in his famous 2005 conversation with Billy Bush.

 

And so it goes. There’s little doubt that power, and proximity to it, builds a sense of sexual domination/privilege in many people as well as a sense of submission in their victims. And the longer that famous people hold power, the more their sense of domination grows as our celebrity culture pumps them up.

 

Then comes along some event, such as the outing of Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein as a serial abuser, to cause people to look around and see what’s happening. Then there may be a period of relative restraint before the abuse by the powerful (which usually means rich, too, in our wealth-worshipping country) starts all over again.

 

Former President Bill Clinton
That we’ve had two recent presidents – Bill Clinton and Trump – who are serial abusers may signify that whatever the outraged rhetoric, Americans are remarkably tolerant of such bad behavior.  One of the saddest things about this is related to the fact that the president is not only head of the Executive Branch, but also head of state. As such he (and maybe someday she) is supposed to represent the dignity and gravity of the nation as a whole. And so bad behavior by a president lowers the image and self-respect of the whole nation. That problem has reached industrial strength.

 

New York Sen. Kirstin Gillibrand was right to blurt out the other day that Bill Clinton should have resigned in the Monica Lewinsky scandal. Was Senator Gillibrand being hypocritical, given the great assistance that the Clintons have given her over the years? Probably.  The country would have been better off if Bill Clinton had left the White House in 1998. If he had resigned, an intelligent and dignified man – Al Gore – would have taken over and probably been elected on the basis of having been a competent chief executive for a couple of years before the 2000 election, in which as vice president he got half a million more votes than George W. Bush.  (As usual, the 18th Century Electoral College system gave a big advantage to the GOP.)

 

Public decorum and dignity have been sliding for some time, but Clinton and far worse, Trump, have pushed them off a cliff.

 

As for Charlie Rose: His narcissism and curious insecurity were often visible in his fawning over celebrities on his interviews. Still, those shows were often very good television, in large part because of the ingenuity and energy of the young producers and other off-camera staff who used Rose’s reputation for softball pitches to get good guests with an astonishingly wide range of backgrounds and expertise. Some of those staffers, however, paid a price in being sexually harassed by Charlie Rose the relentless egomaniac. Now they feel safe to complain. Mighty late.

 

Celebrities in these sex scandals, such as Bill Clinton, Trump,  Charlie Rose, Roy Moore, Al Franken, John Conyers, Joe Barton (he’s apparently just an exhibitionist rather than an abuser), etc. , etc.,  all have something in common – the desire to be at the center of everything. They’re all saying “look at me’’ all the time. This extends to the bizarre spectacle of so many of these far-past-the-Adonis-stage men displaying,  without invitation, their nudity (and/or excitable parts of their anatomy) to the women they’re hitting on. They’d do American culture a favor by going away.

 

Mark Halpren
Now the public is caught up in a Niagara of tawdry tales – a voyeur’s delight; the Weinstein case seems to have burst a dam holding back innumerable complaints. But citizens are so caught up in the circus that they might not notice the damage being done to federal functions by the Trump regime, such as gutting environmental protections and making it easier for Wall Street to pull us into another crash and recession. And a crooked tax “reform’’ bill aimed at further enriching the likes of the Trumps and the Koch Brothers moves toward possible passage. Scariest is the growing evidence of the tight collusion of the Trump mafia and the Kremlin, now at least briefly off the front page because of celebs’ sex scandals.

 

xxx

 

So, as the winds strip off the last leaves from the trees (except the oaks, many of whose leathery brown leaves will hang on through much of the winter), we enter the fearsome holiday season, bringing such features as Advent calendars, lots of colored lights, punch with mysterious ingredients and relentless retailing. It will be by turns exhausting, loud, fun and, perhaps toward the end, maudlin or even boring, much of it seasoned with social anxiety. Its best ending would be a cold, clear, calm New Year’s Day morning with its momentary feeling of a new start. 

 

There’s far too much emotion invested in the Christmas season, as any playing of “White Christmas’’ or “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas,’’ both written in the early ‘40s, brings out.  The intensity of the emotions around the holiday shows itself in how popular these melancholy songs remain after so many decades, and after so much rock, hip-hop and rap.

 

Back to the business of America – business. Obviously, online shopping will continue to expand this holiday shopping season, but will that expansion slow as shoppers realize that maybe they want to spend more time with people and other physical things and less on an increasingly unsatisfying (and sometimes dangerous) Internet?

 

The romance of touching a newspaper
David Sax had a Nov. 19 New York Times piece headlined “Our Love Affair With Digital Is Over.’’ He’s the author of The Revenge of Analog: Real Things and Why They Matter.

 

He may be too optimistic. Obviously digital isn’t going away (and this is “Digital Diary’’!) but I sense that many more people these days are learning to regulate their screen lives. There’s increasing evidence that spending many hours a day online, especially in the social-media swamp, causes depression and anxiety.

 

It’s interesting to see the sales of books on paper rising and e-books falling. Likewise, vinyl records have been seeing a big comeback, as have paper notebooks. People want to (need to?) touch, see and smell things.  And who knows? Maybe this desire to get real things will create, for example, a successor small-store chain to succeed the sadly departing Benny’s. Maybe Adler’s Hardware, on Providence’s Wickenden Street, can lead the way around here. Benny’s was always an inviting place to find useful Christmas presents. Perhaps with a different kind of management, such small stores can succeed, at least in a few places with strong and stable neighborhoods.

 

We all must now swim in a digital sea but we will remain fundamentally analog. 

 

(Analog – adjective: “Relating to or using signals or information represented by a continuously variable physical quantity such as spatial position or voltage.’’)

 

To read Mr. Dax’s essay, please hit this link:

 

xxx

 

In other media news: The Justice Department’s Antitrust Division is suing AT&T to stop its $85.4 billion bid for Time Warner. Well, yes, such a combination is too big. At first glance,  I find it nice to see the government apparently acting, at least in this case, to promote a more level playing field for startups and to limit a huge entity’s pricing power. If AT&T gets Time Warner it would steer its customers to its own content, at a high price, and might effectively keep some programs from being used by new online streaming programs, thus hindering innovation.

 

But I’m also suspicious that the Justice Department might be trying to stick it to CNN, which is owned by Time Warner.  President Trump, whose respect for rigorous journalism and, indeed, the First Amendment, are weak, has made his hatred for CNN as clear as his love for his pal  Rupert Murdoch’s Fox “News’’.

 

The Antitrust Division’s  action begs a bigger question: When will the government go after the rapacious near-monopolies of Facebook and Google, both of which also pose a powerful threat to personal privacy and national security, at least as they’re run now by moral, philosophical and political ignoramuses (if techno and business geniuses)? And then there’s America’s monster store --- Amazon. Facebook and Google have accumulated more power than AT&T in Americans’ daily lives. In administrations before 1990, they would have been broken up.

 

 

xxx

 

No fishing regulations, no fish. It’s good to remember that when reading the news that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has ordered around 60 fishermen and 22 vessels, mostly out of New Bedford,  to return to shore as a result of cheating on fishing catches of cod, haddock, flounder and some other groundfish. The owner of many of the boats, Carlos Rafael, aka “The Codfather,’’ has been convicted in federal court of massive fishing violations.

 

The fishermen haven't been keeping accurate counts of their catches: Translation: They’ve been cheating on the quotas meant to protect the viability of valuable species in the waters off New England. The cod population is under particular pressure, with surveys saying that it has fallen to about 6 percent of what’s needed for long-term sustainability.

 

We almost made the American bison (buffalo) extinct by acting for decades as if they were inexhaustible. We sometimes seem to be taking the same attitude toward fish in the sea. Anyway, this is bad news for New Bedford for the next couple of years.

 

xxx

 

Now here’s something that speaks to a sector in which Rhode Island actually has a comparative advantage. This came in from Providence City Hall:

 

“Mayor Jorge Elorza and DESIGNxRI announced the culmination of the Providence Design Catalyst program that provided 17 Providence-based design businesses with funding, mentorship, and professional development to catalyze their small business growth. The Providence Design Catalyst program is the first design business grant program aimed at catalyzing small design business growth in the City of Providence. It is a partnership between DESIGNxRI, Rhode Island School of Design, the City of Providence, and Social Enterprise Greenhouse and funded through federal … funds.

 

“’Providence is deeply rooted in art and design-based industries. The Providence Design Catalyst program builds on that strength by enabling small businesses to get off the ground and grow in the Creative Capital,’ said Mayor Elorza. ‘We look forward to the continued growth of the awardees of this innovative and creative funding opportunity and their contribution to a thriving design sector here in Providence.”’

 

This is the way to go: Leverage Rhode Island’s comparative advantages – most notably in design, ocean-related industries, and superb location  -- to attract and expand businesses. Don’t try to compete in sectors in which the state has no particular advantages. Of course, some firms can be lured by big tax and other public incentives.  But they’re unlikely to stick around for long.

 

xxx

 

As for Virgin Pulse, the Richard Branson-connected wellness-at-work company that’s moving its headquarters to Providence from Framingham: The main reasons, besides the inevitable tax incentives, are that it’s still close to the vast healthcare/techno center of Greater Boston (but cheaper) and Providence is a much more interesting place to work in than Framingham.  That Providence has a medical and nursing school doesn’t hurt either. Who knows where Virgin Pulse will be based in five years but we all hope its employees enjoy their visit, especially Providence’s many fine restaurants.

 

xxx

 

A Missouri-based company, Commercial Development Co., plans to buy the now closed and once heavily polluting fossil-fuel-powered Brayton Point Power Station, in Somerset, Mass. and may turn the 307-acre site into a center for wind power. How fitting.

 “Multiple factors attracted us to this site. Of greatest interest was the potential for renewable energy development,” said Randall Jostes, the company’s  CEO. The Massachusetts Clean Energy Center sees very breezy Brayton Point as a possible site for an industrial wind port.

 

Some of us will feel a pang when the two huge and eerie cooling towers at Brayton Point, looming on the south side of Route 195, are torn down. A lot of people have thought that the facility was nuclear.

 

xxx
 

Last Wednesday, my friend Bruce Newbury asked me on his radio show (WADK-AM -- 1540)  what I was doing on Nov. 22, 1963, when shots were fired in Dallas.

 

I was cutting open a dead white rat soaked in formaldehyde in my high-school bio lab when some kid rushed in to say that “some {John} Bircher shot Kennedy.’’

 

The John Birch Society (still around) is a radical-right wing organization far more famous then than now. (Among other things the society asserted that the fluoridation of public water supplies was a Communist plot and that Dwight Eisenhower was a Commie fellow traveler. The Birchers in the ‘60s were sort of proto-Tea Partiers.)

 

My labmate and I went to find a TV set in a common room. As we got there Walter Cronkite, then the CBS News anchorman,  looking stunned and near tears, took off his glasses for a few seconds, and announced that Kennedy was dead.

 

In fact, of course, it was the Communist Lee Harvey Oswald, a former resident of the Soviet Union, who shot Kennedy. I increasingly think that others were involved in the assassination, too.

 

I was never a huge Kennedy fan, but the horrific way in which his administration, and in 1968 his brother Robert’s presidential campaign, ended have scarred American politics to this day. And we would have done better without the Camelot myth.

 

xxx

 

The idea of the “public intellectual’’ in the U.S. has long faded in a culture that has become more and more frantic, distracted and impatient. But as recently as about 20 years years ago, millions of people avidly listened to the likes of such public intellectuals as William F. Buckley Jr., the economist John Kenneth Galbraith and the writer Gore Vidal.

 

One of this tribe was the historian Arthur M. Schlesinger  Jr. (1917-2009), who used his writing and research talents and  academic and political connections to become a major figure of what Time Inc. co-founder Henry Luce called “The American Century.’’ Once a household name, he is now mostly forgotten. But maybe his career will win new interest with Richard Aldous’s new, gracefully written and rigorously researched biography, Schlesinger: The Imperial Historian (Norton, 486 pp. $29.95 hardcover).

 

It’s the best explanation I’ve read of a man who was both a powerfully effective political image-maker and a serious scholar who helped color how many citizens saw the cycles of American history. He had very broad interests, among which were movies; he wrote film reviews for years.

 

Mr. Schlesinger’s histories of the Jackson and Franklin Roosevelt administrations made him famous – which helped make him a speechwriter and adviser to Adlai Stevenson, and most famously John F. Kennedy, about whom the professor wrote a somewhat hagiographic personal history of the JFK White House called A Thousand Days after JFK’s assassination.

 

The bow-tied Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. represented a kind of confident Eastern Establishment political/academic/economic elite that now seems quaint.

 

Back when I was in high school, I received a history prize one of Mr. Schlesinger’s books. Although the school I attended had very Republican antecedents – it was founded in 1890 by the brother of William H. Taft, who would follow Theodore Roosevelt into the White House – Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. was considered so estimable (and famous) as a historian that despite his liberal Democratic affiliations, the prize givers didn’t fear that a student would be corrupted by reading him.

 

xxx

 

President Donald Trump
Finally, there’s Collusion: Secret Meetings, Dirty Money, and How Russia Helped Donald Trump Win, by Luke Harding, published by Penguin Random House. The book tells the tale of Donald Trump’s long infatuation with Russia and especially its dictator, Vladimir Putin, and the Russians’ brilliant use of Trump.

 

Amazon calls the book:

 

"An explosive exposé that lays out the Trump administration’s ties to Moscow, and Russia’s decades-in-the-making political game to upend American democracy.’’


50 Ways to Give in RI This Holiday Season - 2022

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.