Robert Whitcomb: Revolutionary Pawtucket? Higher Taxes to Pay for Being a Sanctuary City?

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Robert Whitcomb: Revolutionary Pawtucket? Higher Taxes to Pay for Being a Sanctuary City?

Robert Whitcomb
Pulled North and South; Revolutionary Pawtucket? Higher Taxes to Pay for Being a Sanctuary City? Fascist in France; Understanding Science

 

So South County Hospital and Yale New Haven Health System are discussing linking up, presumably along the lines of what the Connecticut institution has already done with Westerly Hospital. It’s  another reminder of how Rhode Island is being more and more absorbed into multi-state markets. From, say, East Greenwich north, the Ocean State is more and more part of Greater Boston. From East Greenwich to the southwest, it’s drawn into the coastal Connecticut/metro New York orbit.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

 

Rhode Island can be a less expensive, more convenient and physically attractive alternative to those more congested and expensive places. While the state’s hospitals might not be able to offer the full range of services available at some famous Boston or New York hospitals or  at Yale New Haven, they can provide most of the services that patients need. Meanwhile, Rhode Island could become a national model for primary care, helped by the Alpert Medical School at Brown’s nationally known primary-care training.

 

And there’s no reason that an out-of-state organization, such as Yale New Haven, for one, would close down certain highly profitable specialty services in Rhode Island, such as South County Hospital’s joint-replacement program.

 

There are many social and economic advantages to being between two of the richest and most important cities in America. And the more the Ocean State gets absorbed into the big metro areas to its north and south, the less provincial and tribal it will be.

 

xxx

 

Mayor Jorge Elorza
It still isn’t entirely clear what Providence Mayor Jorge Elorza means when he says Providence is indeed a “sanctuary city’’ for illegal aliens. It seems to mean that his administration’s police are told to refuse to hold undocumented immigrants for extended periods while Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials get arrest warrants and not to ask residents about their immigration status.

 

In any event, the mayor should cooperate fully with federal officials, who have near-100 percent authority on immigration matters. The cities and states cannot be allowed to make their own foreign policy.

 

If he doesn’t  fully cooperate, the city could up losing a lot of federal dollars for local law enforcement. The mayor would have a hard sell asking for higher taxes to make up for the lost revenue. The Trump administration has been clumsy in its immigration enforcement and God knows that the immigration laws should have been reformed decades ago. But let’s not encourage law-breaking. Push to change the law, don’t break it.

 

xxx

A group of us were talking the other day about the Pawtucket Red Sox’s plan for a multi-recreational-use downtown “Park of Pawtucket’’ at and around a successor stadium of McCoy Stadium. The PawSox organization says it would provide “recreation, entertainment and other amenities year-round,’’ including “concerts, hockey and certain family attractions.’’ Sounds  nice, but it’s still hard to see how well this would work without a covered stadium, considering that annual cold snap called “winter’’. The “Park of Pawtucket’’ concept is obviously part of the pitch to get state money to help pay for a McCoy replacement.
Meanwhile, the CEO of GoLocal, Josh Fenton, suggested (in jest?) that the New England Revolution move its base to this new stadium from Gillette Stadium, in Foxboro. Unlike at Gillette, it might often have a chance of filling the stands at a new facility to be shared with the PawSox. Rhode Island, in  part because of its large Hispanic and Asian community, loves soccer. And such a move would pull  deep-pocketed Robert Kraft, the owner of the Revolution and the New England Patriots, into Rhode Island.

 

xxx

 

 

The new “Partnership for Rhode Island’’ is long overdue. In the old days, before so many big companies moved their headquarters and even their entire operations out of the state, groups of Ocean State executives would get together and do such civic-minded things as saving the Biltmore Hotel from demolition. That civic-mindedness has faded in the past few decades.

 

But as I have written before, there’s been a revival in local business patriotism. The most dramatic example – the creation of the nonprofit “Partnership for Rhode Island,’’ which has 10 corporate members: Amica, Bank of America, Brown University, Citizens Financial Group, CVS Health, General Dynamics’s Electric Boat Division, Hasbro, IGT (formerly GTECH), Providence Equity Partners and the Rhode Island Foundation.

 

Their aim is broad – to improve the quality of life in the state, mostly through such economic initiatives as improving K-12 public education; promoting lifelong learning/retraining programs; luring business to the state, and improving infrastructure, first at T.F. Green Airport, which is poised for a major expansion with a longer runway that will facilitate transcontinental and transatlantic flights. (I hope that they do something about the state’s local roads, many of which remain at Third World levels.)

 

As a sign of seriousness about their mission, the group has hired Tom Giordano to be its executive director and is raising $1 million to get started. Mr. Giordano had been working for New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo in financial capacities.

 

 

xxx

 

President Donald Trump
Donald Trump’s promotion of a formidable wall between  Mexico and the United States, and his apparent plans to jettison large parts of NAFTA, ignore the possibility of huge unintended consequences.

 

One is that Trump’s anti-Mexico program could result in more poverty and unrest South of the Border, resulting in more Mexicans trying to flee to the United States.  (More Mexicans have been leaving the U.S. in the past few years than have entered.) And many of them will find a way, Trump wall or not.

 

Another is that anti-Mexican rhetoric and policies could steer Mexico into the arms of China, which has been trying to romance that nation for a while, with the hope of doing massive business deals and undermining the United States. While Mexico is not a U.S. foe, China definitely is.

 

Mr. Trump wants to reduce globalization’s effects on U.S. employment.

 

by enacting high tariffs against some nations. This might, at least for a time, protect a few jobs and raise some wages a little by making it uneconomic for some U.S. companies to import goods from low-wage nations and/or make the stuff abroad at U.S.  subsidiaries there. But the main effect would be to accelerate U.S. companies’ automation, thus killing more American jobs. The more you fight globalization via protectionism the more pressure to automate.

 

As Bloomberg News reported the other day: “About 38 percent of U.S. jobs could be at high risk of automation by the early 2030s, according to a study by PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. The ‘most-exposed’ industries include retail and wholesale trade, transportation and storage, and manufacturing, with less-educated workers facing the biggest challenges.’’

 

 

xxx

 

I came across this quote from Hannah Arendt, which seems appropriate in these days of fake news and expanding dictatorships around the world:

 

“A people that no longer can believe anything cannot make up its mind. It is deprived not only of its capacity to act but also of its capacity to think and to judge.’’

 

With a deeply corrupt and pathological liar president in the White House, this can only get worse.

 

Much has been made of the power of bad actors, such as Vladimir Putin, enabled by such allies as Wikileaks’ Julian Assange, to distribute negative and often fake news to undermine their foes. But too little attention has been paid to the role of  such gigantic, quasi-monopolistic Internet companies as Facebook and Google as enablers. They profit mightily from the advertising-associated clicks in their huge digital infrastructures. The more extreme and irresponsible the postings, the better they do.

 

We’d be better off if the Federal Trade Commission and the U.S. Justice Department took their duties to curb extreme corporate concentration as seriously as they did decades ago.

 

xxx

 

President Trump wants to cut the corporate tax rate to 15 percent  from the current 35 percent (which few companies pay because of various deductions and other breaks). Better to phase out the corporate tax entirely and admit that in the end individuals pay all taxes. Having a corporate tax encourages corrupt lobbying and skews some companies’ activities away from productive (for the general economy) activities and toward maneuvers purely aimed at avoiding taxes.

 

At least the Trump tax reform ought to include a major simplification of the tax code – including getting rid of most itemized deductions. But it’s too bad that the Republicans won’t go after the mortgage-interest deduction, which unfairly favors homeowners over renters.

 

The amount of time taken to process taxes is a huge drain on the economy. If the president can address the need for massive simplification, he’d get a lot of bipartisan support, although accountants and tax lawyers won’t be happy.

 

But whatever the rhetoric, the one thing that will be utterly clear in the Trump tax program is that it will be aimed at furthering enriching Donald Trump and the rest of his corrupt family as they lead the United States into becoming a banana republic.

 

xxx

 

It’s good to read that the State Department has taken off its Web site the ad for Mr. Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach. There’s already been far too much profiteering by the Trump family from their leader’s presidency. Truly brazen.

 

 

xxx

 

The outcome of the first round of the French election was no surprise, with young newcomer Emmanuel Macron and far-rightist Marine Le Pen coming out first and second. In the May 7 runoff (the French wisely hold their elections on Sundays to encourage maximum turnouts) Mr. Macron should win, perhaps by as much as 20 points. But it could be closer: Ms. LePen is a very dynamic campaigner with great appeal to downwardly mobile people in the smaller formerly industrial cities that the economy has left behind and many of whose residents resent the influx of immigrants who don’t share French traditions.

 

 

She’s also a fascist, an anti-Semite and a frequent liar, like her father, Jean-Marie Le Pen, who was in the presidential runoff in 2002.

 

If she were to surprise most observers and win, it would probably be the end of the European Union and a huge blow to the power of the West to promote democracy and challenge such dictators as her pal Vladimir Putin. And her election would not improve the French economy any more than Donald Trump’s strident but incoherent nationalism will help America’s.

 

No nation can escape globalization, though it can and should be slowed in some nations to reduce the harm to some groups. The world will stay networked, whether we like it or not.

 

xxx

 

With the ruling Republican  Party rife with people who are, in effect, anti-science (especially if respecting science means lower profits for some individuals and old industries),  and the proliferation of fake news, readers would do well to read Cornelia Dean’s latest book, Making Sense of Science: Separating Substance from Spin (Harvard University Press).

 

 

Ms. Dean, a long-time science writer and former science editor of The New York Times, has in this very accessible and often entertaining book sought, as the promotion says, “to equip nonscientists with a set of critical tools to evaluate the scientific claims and controversies that shape our lives.’’ She eloquently addresses the “public indifference to the way science is done and communicated.’’

 

It would be an understatement to say that this is a timely book.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.