Providence College Professor Slams "Diversity Cult" on Campus, Faces Backlash

GoLocalProv News Team and Kate Nagle

Providence College Professor Slams "Diversity Cult" on Campus, Faces Backlash

Providence College
A Providence College professor has come under fire for questioning the college's focus on diversity as a "political slogan"  -- and has found himself the subject of protest at the Catholic college.

Professor Anthony Esolen, who teaches Renaissance English Literature and the Development of Western Civilization at PC, where he started in 1990, penned the essay on the "watchword" of diversity at PC for Crisis Magazine, and questioned the college being a "committedly and forthrightly Catholic school."

"Is not diversity, as currently promoted, at odds with the foundational diversity built into the nature of the human race, the diversity of male and female, to be resolved most dynamically and creatively in the union of man and woman in marriage?" wrote Esolen for Crisis Magazine. "Is not that same call for diversity, when Catholics are doing the calling, a surrender of the Church to a political movement which is, for all its talk, a push for homogeneity, so that all the world will look not like the many-cultured Church, but rather like the monotone non-culture of western cities that have lost their faith in the transcendent and unifying God?

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Read Esolen's Essay HERE

Following Esolen's publication, he was the center of a protest on campus, a petition from the Black Studies department, and a sharp rebuke from PC's President, Reverend Brian Shanley.

Esolen's Reaction

"One of the points of my article was that I do not know what the faculty politicians mean when they use the phrase 'cultural diversity,' since, in our superb program in the Development of Western Civilization, we study a multitude of cultures, widely diverse from ours and from one another, nor are they all European, either.  Yet that program is vilified all the time for its supposed uniformity, often by people who do not know the material on the syllabi," Esolen told GoLocalProv.com on Sunday. 

When asked if he felt his own free speech was in jeopardy, for articulating his defense of Catholic doctrine, Esolen offered his perspective.

"How could it not? I fear that we may end up with no greater freedom of speech and inquiry than what the professors at any radically secular college enjoy," said Esolen. 

Following the publication of his essays, including one entitled, "What Will You Do When the Persecution Comes?" faculy at PC circulated the following petition:

As PC Faculty, we pledge to break the silence around systemic racism and discrimination on Providence College’s campus. While we vigorously support free expression, recent publications on the part of PC faculty have involved racist, xenophobic, misogynist, homophobic, and religiously chauvinist statements. The use of this type of language by people with power over students runs counter to the Catholic mission of Providence College, which aims “to reflect the rich diversity” of our world, and “extend a loving embrace to all."

PC Professor Anthony Esolen. Photo: YouTube
As a diverse coalition of students have consistently highlighted, such statements are part of a broader pattern of racism, sexism and other forms of hate that are all too common not only on campus, but in the broader public culture. As professors who care deeply about the wellbeing, safety, and growth of our students, we are committed to combating racism and overcoming the hostile learning environment for too many of our students, while creating spaces where all of our students can engage in meaningful ways.

College, Conservative Response

"On Thursday October 20, a group of about 60-70 students marched on campus in protest," said Providence College spokesperson Steve Maurano. "This appeared to be largely a reaction to an article published a few weeks earlier in a non-college publication by one of our faculty members."

"Fr. Shanley met with the protesting students for about 45 minutes and listened to their concerns," Maurano continued. "The following day, he issued the email below to the campus community.​"

Dear Members of the Providence College Community:

Yesterday I met with about 60 of our students who marched through campus and eventually came to Harkins Hall. Their primary source of complaint was the content of a pair of articles recently published by a member of our faculty, how it made them feel, and their frustration that there had been no response from the College or me. After [sic] dialoging with the students, I believe it is imperative for me to respond to their concerns.

Academic freedom is a bedrock principle of higher education. It allows professors the freedom to teach, write, and lecture without any restraint except the truth as they see it. It also gives them the freedom to express their opinions as citizens so long as it is clear that they do not represent the views of the institution with which they are affiliated. This freedom obviously extends to espousing views critical of their own college or university.

So when one of our professors writes an article accusing Providence College of having “Succumbed to the Totalitarian Diversity Cult,” he is protected by academic freedom and freedom of speech. But it must be understood that he speaks only for himself. He certainly does not speak for me, my administration, and for many others at Providence College who understand and value diversity in a very different sense from him.

"I wish he had sent to me the students who were upset; after all, we are an institution of higher learning, and that means that we discuss things, including what cultural diversity' means and for what ends we prize it.  The irony is that the Catholic Church is the most many-cultured institution in the history of the world; but that fact seems lost on many," said Esolen.

When asked if he thinks Providence College is at a crossroads as a Catholic institution, Esolen responded with the following. 

"I don't know. Much remains to be seen. Sometimes things happen without anyone directly intending them," said Esolen. "It is true that most of our recent hires show little interest in the Catholic mission of the college, and some, including some of the most vocal, bristle against it and work to undermine it."

Editor's Note: A previous version indiciated incorrectly that the petition was circulated by the Black Studies Department; it was just shared on the departments Facebook page. 


Rhode Island's Best Communities 2016

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.