Whitcomb: Beltway’s Young Nobility; Bring in Mr. Gilbert; Adding to the Floods; & Intense Newport

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist

Whitcomb: Beltway’s Young Nobility; Bring in Mr. Gilbert; Adding to the Floods; & Intense Newport

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist
“When we pause in the middle of a long walk home and

Suddenly feel something invisible and weightless

Touching our shoulders, sweeping down from the air:

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

It is the autumn wind pressing against our bodies;

It is the changing light of fall falling on us.’’

 

-- From “Fall,’’ by Edward Hirsch

 

Explosive Infrastructure

The recent explosions and fires north of Boston were reminders of how dangerous natural gas can be, especially if pipes carrying it are old and corroded and gas is being sent at excessive pressures, in this disaster. We can hope that as battery storage improves, electricity from non-volatile energy from regional solar, wind and other nonpolluting sources will replace fossil fuel (all of which comes from outside the region) for virtually  all residential and commercial uses, also making us less vulnerable to giant utilities for whom profit and stock price might trump public safety.

 

For now, we can only hope that the gas-line part of America’s crumbling infrastructure gets some fast upgrades.

 

Nike Ban
Petty ‘Patriotism’

The 3-2 vote, apparently now to be redone, by the North Smithfield Town Council for a resolution asking town officials not to buy Nike products because former NFL player and now Nike promoter Colin Kaepernick “took a knee” (God, I hate that expression!)  during the playing of the National Anthem to protest police brutality against black people was wrong. Indeed, what Kaepernick did was an expression of patriotism in that he was defending the human rights enshrined in the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights.

 

The council could have run into legal problems by seeming to violate the First Amendment.

 

And, no, the low-key Kaepernick was not showing what Town Council President John Beauregard alleged was his “disdain’’ for the police in general. As a black man, he was demonstrating solidarity with victims of racism, racism that has been expressed by a minority of, but more than a few, white police officers in some infamous cases.

 

He may have considerable support from the public: Reuters reports that Nike “has sold 61 percent more merchandise since the controversial ad campaign featuring former NFL player Colin Kaepernick appeared earlier this month, according to data on the company’s online sales from Thomson Reuters Proprietary Research.’’

 

“{False} patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.’’


-- Samuel Johnson

 

 

The council’s vote recalled the hot air from Trump, who has wrapped himself in the flag even as he has undermined American principles and whose rise to the presidency was assisted by his organization’s collaboration with a murderous dictatorship and adversary – Russia. What a fraud!

 

 

WPRI debate
Some Moderate Ideas

 

WPRI gubernatorial debate organizers should let Moderate Party of Rhode Island candidate William Gilbert participate in the Sept. 27 debate with Gov. Gina Raimondo, the Democratic candidate, and Cranston Mayor Allan Fung, her Republican foe. Since its founding by the brilliant systems analyst Ken Block in 2009, the Moderate Party, the third-biggest party in the state, has presented thoughtful and specific proposals for improving state government, and has garnered much public support. And consider that its 2014 gubernatorial candidate, Robert Healy, won a hefty 22 percent of the vote.

 

Mr. Gilbert’s participation in the debate would tend to force Ms. Raimondo and Mr. Fung to be more specific about what they’d do in the next four years if they win, and less able to hide in generalities.

 

Supreme Court nominee faces allegations of sexual assault
The Kavanaugh-Ford Case

I’m leery of guessing about what may or may not have happened between Republican operative and Appeals Court Judge and Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford, who says that Judge Kavanaugh sexually assaulted her when she was 15 and he was 17, back in the early ‘80s.  Teenagers tend to do crazy and/or irresponsible things, especially when they’re drunk, which they apparently often were in the preppy world inhabited by the future judge and his accuser. Most of us remember at least some cringe-worthy behavior in our youth.

 

In any event, Ms. Ford certainly deserves a thorough hearing but the ruthless national GOP wants to railroad Kavanaugh’s confirmation to indirectly help forestall the conviction of the mobster in the Oval Office in a Senate impeachment trial and to ensure that the interests of the Koch Brothers, et al., are protected.

 

 I say the “national GOP” to differentiate it from the many honorable, old-fashioned moderate conservatives at the local level. And my complaint about Trump’s unprincipled and staggeringly hypocritical and cowardly enablers in Congress is far more animated by how they tolerate Trump’s attacks on the rule of law,  our government institutions and democratic principles than on their shifting policy positions. A truly cynical crowd.

 

Who will help create a responsible new center-right party, which every democracy needs, to replace a national party now rife with greedy donors like the Koch Brothers, grifters, racists, “Evangelical’’ con men, and even a few traitors at the top. In a few states, old-fashioned, civic-minded Republicans still hold sway, but some of their brethren in Washington have become a threat to the Republic.

 

What most impressed me in reading about the Kavanaugh controversy was how it publicized the sense of privilege of the spoiled kids born on third base and insulated by their rich Beltway Bandit parents from the economic and social pressures that most Americans must deal with. They’ve been safely ensconced in a self-perpetuating upper class that uses widening income and political inequality to further armor their wealth and power.

 

As Judge Kavanaugh joked at a private function a couple of years ago, “What happens at Georgetown Prep (his elite private high school) stays at Georgetown Prep.’’ God will protect the Ruling Class? Certainly, a Justice Kavanaugh will do his best to do so. Note, by the way, that right-wing Supreme Court Justice Neal Gorsuch, whom the Republicans put on the high court last year, is also a Georgetown Prep graduate.

 

For a look at life in the world of beloved old Georgetown Prep, read the memoir by Kavanaugh’s classmate Mark Judge entitled Wasted: Tales of a Gen X Drunk. Ms. Ford, you may recall, says that Mr. Judge was in the room during the alleged aforementioned assault.

 

In any event, the affable, indeed charming Mr. Kavanaugh will be a faithful protector of socio-economic privilege, comforting the comfortable whenever possible.

 

 

Sending Water Into Rivers Faster

With more than 30 inches of rain in some places, the flooding in North Carolina would have been awful even if so much land hadn’t been paved over for parking lots in our car-dependent culture. But, as we have discovered in New England in big rainstorms, it certainly makes things worse as stormwater isn’t permitted to be absorbed into the soil but instead rushes off into streams, often carrying oil and other pollutants from impervious surfaces.

 

Catastrophic rain events seem to be increasing with global warming. Public- and private-sector planners need to make more of an effort to replace, wherever possible, asphalt and concrete parking surfaces with porous ones, such as paving stones set in sand.

 

Meanwhile, the Trump regime will make things worse as it takes steps to make it easier for developers to fill in more water-absorbing wetlands. (See comments on deregulation below.) And of course, it’s promoting a massive increase in the drilling and mining for fossil fuel, whose global-warming effects include more intense fresh and saltwater flooding.

 

Meanwhile, readers might want to hear this dramatic Rhode Island Public Radio piece about the 1938 hurricane that ravaged New England and on how vulnerable we still are around here. To hear it, please hit this link:

 

 

Bacon is good
Bacon Is Good for You

“They’’ tell you that drinking alcohol, in moderation, is good for you. Then “they’’ tell you it isn’t. “They’’ tell you to take a baby aspirin once a day. Then, no. The scientific testing and conclusions and contradictions roll on, recalling the Woody Allen 1973 movie Sleeper, set 200 years in the future, in which an expert touts the health-giving attributes of deep-fried foods. Maybe the best you can do is to follow Oscar Wilde’s advice, “Moderation in all things, including moderation.’’ But then, he didn’t end up in a very happy place

 

Pulling Down Fences

The Trump administration has been hard at work trying to kill various regulations involving business and the environment. There’s no doubt that many regs need to be updated, or killed, from time to time and regulatory streamlining can be a very good thing.  “Sunset’’ statutes mandating the end of outdated and/or excess laws can work well.


Certainly, eliminating and/or weakening regulations can make life easier and more profitable for business. That’s in part because it makes it tougher for public and private actors to sue companies for their dubious actions.

 

But those business regulations were originally put there for good reason, especially to prevent fraud. When regulation gets weak, you’ll have more corruption and what Alan Greenspan called “irrational exuberance’’ that will blow up and do more damage to businesses than the regulations ever did.  Consider how Clinton-G.W. Bush era deregulation helped lead to the Panic of 2008 and the Great Recession.


As for the gutting of some environmental laws and rules, that can lead not only to long-term or even irreversible ecological damage and, particularly in cases of air and water pollution, human deaths. I like Robert Frost’s line:

 

“Don’t ever take a fence down until you know why it was put up.’’

 

Anderson writes about Projo's demise
Leaving the Paper

My former Providence Journal colleague M.J. Andersen has an evocative and important piece, titled “Leaving the Paper,’’ in the newish Web site Politics/Letters (which wants to eventually be in print, too!) about newspapers as they shrink and disappear these days. She comes from an Upper Midwest newspaper family, about which she writes fondly but without blinkers. Among her remarks about The Journal:

 

“Perhaps the mission to which we had dutifully given lip service over the years — the mission of uncovering the truth — was no abstraction but a project as vital to democracy as our civics books had always insisted. …’’

“Now, thanks to an explosion in new media outlets, our patient if not always perfect cultivation of the facts was being uprooted by a cyclone of disordered information, rumor, and outright falsehoods. In the meantime, a peculiar quiet spread across the state {of Rhode Island}. Everywhere, we sensed, corners were being cut; deals were being struck, at public expense.’’

 

“In the course of 185 years, The Providence Journal had made itself into an institution as important to Rhode Island as paved roads, public schools and sanitation systems. …For all its faults, The Journal was and still is a communal space, permitting Rhode Islanders to know each other. And knowing is the basis of trust.’’

 

To read her article, please hit this link:

 

The United States of Obesity

If you want to know one reason that U.S.  per-capita health-care costs are so much higher than other nations’,  look no farther than the astonishing obesity of victims of Hurricane Florence as seen on TV – U.S. obesity is worst in the South -- or even of people waiting in the lobby of Rhode Island Hospital. It would be interesting to find out how much of this can be explained by gluttony (perhaps to relieve anxiety) and how much by a refusal to exercise. No wonder visiting foreigners are staggered by the spectacle of so many morbidly fat people in America.

 

Gloria Vanderbilt
Newport’s Social Circus

I’ve been chatting with Newporters a bit more than usual lately. It’s an exciting and complicated, sometimes bizarre place, with great natural and manmade beauty. But the routes to get there are problematical. The Route 114 commercial strip in Middletown to the Newport city line is one of the ugliest I’ve seen – where were the town planners and zoners? -- and there often seems to be an accident or other problem on the Pell Bridge, a toll span. If only there was much more ferry service between Providence and Newport to reduce some of the congestion.

 

And society, especially “high society,’’ while often entertaining, can be quite vehement. Battles, such as the Preservation Society of Newport’s successful multi-year war to build a “welcome center,’’ with restaurant, on the grounds of The Breakers, the Vanderbilts’ former over-the-top mansion on Ochre Point Avenue, rather than across the street, which some powerful Newporters preferred, created an upscale civil war with neighbors; some of the protagonists still don’t speak to each other.

 

Some Newporters fear that the Preservation Society might try to put restaurants in some of its other properties, too, in effect turning into a restaurant chain, which would displease some neighbors (street-parking paranoia) as well as for-profit eateries in town that might be hard-pressed to compete with the powerful nonprofit.

 

Anyway, the city could use a Truman Capote, Edith Wharton, Gore Vidal or Tom Wolfe to do an updated zoological study of the Bellevue Drive/Ocean Drive swells, which include such nouveau riches as Larry Ellison, Jay Leno and Judge Judy as well as “old money,’’ some of which can be traced back to crooks in the 19th Century Gilded Age.

 

(The old response, attributed to various recipients of charitable donations over the years, about “tainted money’’ was that the only problem was that  ‘’taint enough of it’’.)
 

There’s something about the mix of deep history, commercial and recreational port, aesthetics, social drama and intrigue, a rich stew of ethnicities, Navy, ex-spies and other government types and location at the southern end of an island that keeps new people coming to rejuvenate the place.

 

 

Dr. Bronhard’s Irritating Investments

There have been numerous angry complaints for many months about property maintenance and other issues involving the property of Fall River-based real-estate mogul and chiropractor Walter Bronhard, who has been buying up many millions of dollars in property to rent out on Providence’s East Side, especially near Brown University.  What do city officials propose to do about him?

 

South Coast Out of Seclusion

Going by the Sotheby’s signs, it appears that New York money has discovered – big-time -- Little Compton, R.I., and Westport and South Dartmouth, Mass., with their beautiful countryside (including vineyards) on Buzzards Bay. Will they be Hamptonized, as has Block Island?

 

 

One of RI's proposal to Amazon for HQ2
Give the Money to the Residents, not Amazon?

Lev Kushner, in the usually very interesting citylab.com, suggests that cities should stop chasing the likes of Amazon, which has been demanding huge incentives from cities in return for the increasingly arrogant Amazon moving its “Second Headquarters’’ there. Instead, he argues, cities should focus on spending economic-development money to attract the freelancers/small businesspeople who lack “fringe benefits‘’ and comprise a growing percentage of the workforce. Consider that about half of the people doing work for Google aren’t on salaries.

 

From the ranks of such people come creators of new businesses and inventions.

 

Employee loyalty continues to fall almost as fast as companies’ loyalty to their employees. City planners need to take this into account.

 

So, Kushner suggests, why not spend some of the vast sums offered to big companies in the form of tax breaks, etc., on, instead, subsidizing health care and child care and boosting unemployment insurance to make the cities better places to start and nurture businesses?

 

This, he argues, “mitigates the risk of becoming a one-company town that loses its {one big} company’’ in a time when corporations express less and less commitment to the communities they’re in.

 

“Why chase one company when you can make them all come to you by supplying cheaper {because the city, not companies, would pay for much of the benefits} subsidized talent? Sure, Amazon brings its elite {headquarters} workforce with it, but why pay the middleman?’’ Consider that about half of the people doing work for Google aren’t on salaries.

 

Worth considering. To read all of Kushner’s argument, which would discomfit many state and local economic-development officials, most of whom relentlessly seek to land a big corporate fish, please hit this link:
 

 

Teaching Lesson

Fifty years ago, in 1968, I spent the fall teaching public high school in North Andover, Mass.,  in a program called A Better Chance, in which poor kids, minority and white, from the South and elsewhere lived in a kind of group home, presided over by a teacher and spouse, in towns with good public and/or private schools. I learned a lot that fall, which I remember as notably windy and wet. One lesson was that a firm, er, loud, voice in a class with 30 kids can to some degree offset the vulnerability of someone, like me, of small stature teaching restless and sometimes rowdy teens many of whom were bigger than me.  And that you need eyes behind your head. Performance art.

 

Red-Brick Bonanza

It seems that pretty much all big new buildings in Providence -- no matter how high -- are being clad in red brick, giving the effect of walking amongst gigantic 1920’s era public school buildings.

 

 

New Bedford Confidential

Down at the Docks (Pantheon), by Rory Nugent, is an unvarnished look at, by turns,  gritty and beautiful New Bedford and particularly the hard and often disorderly lives of fishermen there. Drug smuggling and other crime, organized and otherwise, the history of the industry that made the city famous – whaling – the city’s resilient romantic aspects amidst its decay as its textile industry imploded – it’s all in the book.

 

As Nugent notes, New Bedford is no longer exactly what Herman Melville, author of Moby Dick, called “the dearest place to live in, in all New England,’’ but it ain’t boring. Read the book and then go check out the Whaling Museum, the port and some great 19th Century mansions.

 

Abroad at Home

For information on the Providence Committee on Foreign Relations’ exciting fall lineup of dinner speakers, as well as membership information, please hit this link


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.