Whitcomb: A Tear in Fall River’s Fabric; Wind Money; Affirmative Action for Rich Kids

GoLocalProv

Whitcomb: A Tear in Fall River’s Fabric; Wind Money; Affirmative Action for Rich Kids

Robert Whitcomb, Columnist
“May something go always unharvested!

May much stay out of our stated plan,

Apples or something forgotten and left,

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

So smelling their sweetness would be no theft.’’

-- From “Unharvested,’’ by Robert Frost

 

“Nobody minds having what is too good for them.’’

-- Jane Austen

 

“I don’t know where their personal philosophy ends and their business goals begin. They’re not the Koch Brothers, but they reflect a deep-seated conservatism and generations of libertarian philosophy that also happen to help their business.’’

-- Andrew Schwartzman, who lectures on telecommunications law at Georgetown Law School, on Sinclair Broadcast Group, which orders its many TV stations, including Providence’s Channel 10, to broadcast pro-Trump propaganda. He was quoted in an Oct. 22 New Yorker magazine article headlined “Breaking the News’’.

 

Fall River Mayor Correia
The planned Nov. 25 closing of spectacular St. Anne’s Church, dedicated in 1906  and probably Fall River’s best known building (besides its much-disliked Brutalist city hall, which hangs over Route 195), is a reminder of the decline of churches and other institutions that were in varying degrees ethnically as well as well religiously based. These congregations, in their heydays, did much more than carry out their official religious missions. They also became social-welfare institutions, providing not only spiritual and psychological sustenance but also food and even shelter in tough times.
 

St. Anne’s was a French-Canadian parish, serving the many thousands of Quebecois who moved to Fall River and other New England textile- and shoe-making towns starting in the 19th Century – a migration that hit its peak in the World War I  boom years. French-Canadian architect Napoléon Bourassa designed the church, with its dramatic bell towers.

Now many of the devout have died and many parishioners have long since dispersed to the suburbs or elsewhere.  The priest-abuse scandals and the long decline in affiliation with organized religion in the Northeast also help explain the woes of St. Anne’s.
 

The church has serious physical problems, and would require millions of dollars in repairs, which apparently can’t be raised; the parish is no longer populous and committed enough to fund the work.  Bishop Edgar da Cunha, who runs the Diocese of Fall River, announced that parishioners are invited to join a new “Catholic Community of Central Fall River,’’ which sounds pretty vague and diffuse.

 

It’s been another bad stretch for the Spindle City.  Its mayor, Jasiel F. Correia II, 26, has been indicted by a federal grand jury on fraud and tax charges. This hard-charging and glitzy materialist was elected when he was 23. That means that he was far too inexperienced to run a town or city, let alone one as big as Fall River, which has a population of about 87,000. They should raise the minimum age for mayors to 30.

 

Over four years, beginning in 2013, U.S. Atty. Andrew E. Lelling said, Correia persuaded seven people to invest $363,690 in a startup called SnoOwl, yet another phone app.

 

The Feds allege that the mayor, who proclaims his innocence, illegally diverted more than $230,000 of that money. He is said to have spent the money on his mayoral campaign, travel, adult entertainment, designer clothes, jewelry, credit-card and student-loan payments, casinos and a 2011 Mercedes-Benz C300 all-wheel-drive sport sedan. This makes it sound as if he had serious lifestyle ambitions of the sort modeled by the Emperor of the Oval Office.

 

Fall River and New Bedford are often lumped together. After all, they ’re both old textile-mill towns a mere 14 miles apart. But at least in the past few decades, New Bedford, with about 95,000 people,  has generally had much abler and more visionary mayors than Fall River,  most notably the current chief executive, John Mitchell, and former Mayor John Bullard.

 

The Whaling City has rebuilt its downtown around a cobblestoned National Historical Park and the University of Massachusetts at Dartmouth’s College of Visual and Performing Arts. Meanwhile, its big scallop fleet has prospered, bulk shipping has increased, and it has become a center for the wind-power industry. Of course, New Bedford was always much more of a port than Fall River. And a good number of urban pioneers (aka gentrifiers) have moved to New Bedford in the past few years, many drawn to its beautiful old houses, loft spaces and “romantic’’ (if gritty) waterfront.

 

While Fall River has lured an Amazon fulfillment center, a new Justice Center and SouthCoast Marketplace, it is way behind New Bedford as a happening place. That seems unlikely to change anytime soon.

 

Deepwater Wind
Money in the Wind

The Danish energy company Orsted’s purchase of Providence-based Deepwater Wind from D.E. Shaw & Co., an investment company, for $510 million certainly testifies to the growing value of wind power, especially in the reliably wind-rich area off southern New England. Congratulations to the Deepwater Wind folks for their visionary and complicated risk-taking -- economically, technologically, politically and regulatorily.

 

I noted that the companies said that, Deepwater, now a subsidiary, would be based in Providence and in Boston; the latter city is where Orsted’s North American operations are based. But I predict that soon the Providence office will be closed and everything will be run from Boston (and Denmark). As a PR move in acquisitions, companies often assert that much important stuff will remain in the hometown of the acquired entity. But the savings and efficiencies from consolidation almost always trump such sweet ideas sooner rather than later.

 

If anything, Newport, not Providence, might be the best town for a second headquarters: It’s closer to planned big wind farms south of New England. And Aquidneck Island, like Greater Providence, has lots of engineers.

 

By the way, wind turbines, though far, far better than burning fossil fuel, can raise air temperatures in wind-farm areas by half a degree or more by interrupting wind flows, say recent studies. All energy production has downsides. Consider, for example, that solar arrays require a lot of space, which leads to clearing woodlands in some places. Abandoned big-box store parking lots and landfills are among the best sites, besides rooftops, of course.

 

Affirmative Action Indeed
 

“Americans are the only people in the world known to me whose status anxiety prompts them to advertise their college and university affiliations on the rear window of their automobiles.’’

 

-- The late Paul Fussell

 

Harvard University
The federal government is suing Harvard as part of the Trump administration’s drive against affirmative action in college admissions (and elsewhere). Its angle is to assert that Asian-Americans, many of whom have very strong high-school records, should be admitted in higher percentages. What is left unspoken is that the Trump plan is also meant to help white applicants, who, at least in part because they tend to come from more privileged backgrounds than African-Americans and Hispanics, also tend to have better high-school records.

 

I think that the Feds should bug out of the college-admissions controversy. All elite colleges, including all eight Ivy League schools, use a wide variety of criteria to try to make sure that their undergraduate student bodies have at least a vague resemblance to the population of the nation that these schools have served very well. Indeed, the schools are jewels of American culture, having helped to produce much cultural, technological and financial wealth. Consider the scientific breakthroughs in the institutions’ labs.
 

Anyway, despite the schools’ efforts at affirmative action,  students from affluent backgrounds (overwhelmingly white) dominate these schools because of the economic, educational and social advantages (including better public and private schools) they’ve grown up with.  Students must be careful to pick the right parents! If the administration wins, the colleges will be even more skewed to the rich. Such skewing is what helped Jared Kushner get into Harvard despite a mediocre high-school record. Daddy wrote a check to America’s oldest college for $2.5 million. And Donald Trump’s transfer to the University of Pennsylvania from Fordham was lubricated by his father’s wealth.

 

As this Bloomberg story reported:

“A Harvard dean was thrilled. The undergraduate college had just admitted the offspring of some wealthy donors, and now the money was expected to pour into the university.

"’I am simply thrilled about all the folks you were able to admit,’ David Ellwood, then the dean of {Harvard’s} John F. Kennedy School of Government, wrote to {Harvard College} Dean William Fitzsimmons on June 11, 2014. ‘All big wins. [Name redacted] has already committed to building and building. [Name redacted] and [name redacted] committed major money for fellowships -- before the decisions (from you) and are all likely to be prominent in the future. Most importantly, I think these will be superb additions to the class."

There will always be affirmative action for the rich, even at Harvard, with a $39 billion endowment.

 

Oh, well: Not all the big donors’ gifts go to putting up grandiose buildings with their names plastered on them and endowed professors’ chairs, also with donors’ names plastered on them. Some goes to fellowships and scholarships.

To read more, please hit this link:

 

Bird Scooter - father and daughter and no helmets
Maybe S.F. Will be a Model for Scooter, Bike Regulation

 

As electric bikes and scooters become more common in Providence and other cities, municipal officials should follow what’s happening in San Francisco, where the city’s Municipal Transportation Agency has designated two scooter companies – Skip and Scoot -- to start a pilot regulated scooter system in the very hilly and congested city.

 

One big issue: Keeping parked scooters off sidewalks by trying to ensure that they’re attached to existing bike-locking gear. People get cranky when they see abandoned electric scooters and bikes just lying around, sometimes blocking sidewalks and even streets. Cities and personal-transportation companies such as Skip and Scoot need hotlines that people can call to report abandoned bikes and scooters.

 

Other questions for cities and states: What should be the extent of dedicated personal-vehicle- lane networks? Who should regulate these vehicles? The state or communities? Should helmets be mandatory?

 

The arrival of these small electric vehicles is good news for cities seeking to limit car congestion and the pollution that cars cause. But much needs to be done to systemize their use to maximize their efficiency and safety.

 

To read more about what they’re doing in San Francisco, please hit this link:
 

 

National Sailing Hall of Fame votes to move to Newport
Even More of a Sailing Capital

 

This is as it should be: The National Sailing Hall of Fame will move from Annapolis, Md., to Newport, where the institution will be housed in the Thames Street Armory Building, most of which will be owned by the Hall of Fame. The city will retain ownership of the Newport Maritime Center in the basement but the retail operations in the old building will have to go.

 


As major international sailing and yachting center, the former long-time base of the America’s Cup races, one of the two homes of the New York Yacht Club and a storied port dating back to the 17th Century, Newport should have always been the home of the Sailing Hall of Fame. And, after all, the City by the Sea is on the, well, breezy sea, and not, like Annapolis, on the inner reaches of fetid Chesapeake Bay, much of which is virtually inland.

 

The city will retain ownership of the Newport Maritime Center in the basement.

 

So now Newport will have two major Halls of Fame, with the National Sailing Hall of Fame joining the International Tennis Hall of Fame - institutions honoring two sports traditionally associated with wealth in a city with a long romance with great private riches.

 

Tyranny Likes Oil

 

“We have no eternal allies, and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual, and those interests it is our duty to follow.’’

 

-- British statesman Lord Palmerston, in 1848

 

The  apparent torture and murder of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi at the order of a Trump favorite, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, and that brutal regime’s implied threat to cut off oil supplies to governments that try to punish it  for this outrage,  is another reminder that we need to get off oil, especially from corrupt Mideast dictatorships,  but I repeat myself! oil props up these gangsters, even as fossil-fuel use threatens to ruin the world within the next few decades.


Readers might also note that the Saudis, using a lot of U.S. weaponry, have been massacring thousands of civilians and causing the death of thousands more by starvation in the murderous monarchy’s intervention in the civil war in Yemen. I repeat, despite U.S. antipathy toward the theocratic regime in Iran, the Saudi monarchy is far, far worse for those who care about human rights. And a reminder: Saudis led the 9/11 attacks.

 

China’s Cheap Mail to America

 

Trump plans to withdraw the U.S. from a 192-nation treaty that lets Chinese companies use discounted shipping rates for small packages ordered online to be sent to American consumers.  Under the pact, poor and developing countries have been assessed lower rates than wealthier ones to try to boost their economies and international trade. But China now has the world’s second-biggest economy and a rapacious approach to trade competition.

 

Good for Trump, especially, considering that, among other things, fentanyl and other dangerous drugs have been illegally shipped to America from China, including in business envelopes.

 

The law has let Chinese companies ship goods here at lower rates than what U.S. firms pay domestically; indeed it has let some Chinese online retailers offer free shipping to the U.S., even as U.S.-based businesses pay hefty rates to ship to China.

 

 

Some of Trump’s trade “policies” (if you think they’re coherent enough to be called “policies”) are sloppy and self-defeating. But this mail move, while it’s unlikely to have a very big macro-economic effect, is long overdue.

 

And, as Jay Timmons, the president of the National Association of Manufacturers, said: “This outdated arrangement contributes significantly to the flood of counterfeit goods and dangerous drugs that enter the country from China.” He’s right.

 

Globalization and its discontents

 

John B. Judis has written a very thoughtful New York Times piece headlined “What the Left Misses About Nationalism: The perception of a common national identity is essential to democracies and to the modern welfare state’’ Among his remarks (which I strongly agree with) about how globalization has been oversold and how right-wing populists have profited by opposition to it:

 

“The free movement of companies has led to a global race to the bottom for wages, taxes, and regulation and to growing inequality within nations….’’
 

“Here is the simple truth: As long as corporations are free to roam the globe in search of lower wages and taxes, and as long as the United States opens its borders to millions of unskilled immigrants, liberals will not be able to create bountiful, equitable societies, where people are free from basic anxieties about obtaining health care, education and housing. …. To achieve their historic objectives, liberals and social democrats will have to respond constructively to, rather than dismiss, the nationalist reaction to globalization.’’

 

“Today’s nationalist revival is in reaction to the failure of global, not nation-based, initiatives that sailed over the heads of ordinary citizens. The reaction has been most potent on the political right, but there is certainly a basis for a liberal or social-democratic nationalism. If anything, the decline of liberal and social-democratic parties is a result at least in part of their inability to distinguish what is legitimate and justifiable in nationalism from what is small-minded, bigoted and contrary to the national interest it claims to uphold.’’

 

Mayor Jorge Elorza
Wrong venue, Mr. Mayor

 

On Oct. 13, Providence Mayor Jorge Elorza addressed one of those now all-too-trendy and self-consciously hip TEDx conferences, this one held in the Veterans Memorial Auditorium.  (The event started with a tedious modern-dance performance that went on and on, accompanied by irritating techno noise, magnified by the hall’s alarmingly good acoustics.) Hizzoner should have just warmly and briefly welcomed the several hundred people attending and gotten off the stage fast.

 

Instead, he used his time to make a campaign speech rife with assorted “progressive’’ positions on the rights of the transgendered, the glories of leading a “sanctuary city’’ for illegal aliens, etc., etc.  (He was generally preaching to the converted.)

 

There’s a place for such speeches, but not, you’d think, at a TEDx confab, where the focus is supposed to be on invention, innovation and entrepreneurialism, in scientific,  cultural and other areas – of which there’s quite a bit going on in the big college town known as Providence.

 

TED comes from “technology, entertainment and design,’’ the focus back when TED Talks were invented in 1984 by Richard Saul Wurman, an architect and graphic designer, who, by the way, owned a Newport mansion with his wife, the author Gloria Nagy, from 1993 to 2016.


In 2010, he told The New York Times: "I love living in this  {Newport} house, and I'm not blasé about it at all, but this town is an intellectual wasteland without any sense of humor. I've been living here for 17 years, and if you asked me to tell you when I last had lunch with anybody but my wife or someone that came to see me from India or New York or Boston or Germany, I couldn't come up with a name."

 

Maybe no one invited him to dinner at The Reading Room. Or maybe somebody did…. Perhaps he should have spent a lot of time at the  Naval War College if he needed intellectual stimulation. I met with Mr. Wurman a couple of years ago in New York. He has a splendid sardonic sense of humor and doesn’t like what has happened to TED since he left his creation, in 2002.

 

The two favorite words at TED Talks are “incredible’’ and incredibly,’’ applied to many banal things. Could we at least bring back the word “very’’ to replace “incredibly”? For that matter, “very’’ is usually not needed either.

 

Brexit Bathos

 

Perhaps the most memorable takeaway from London-based writer and long-time NPR and BBC contributor Michael Goldfarb ’s brilliant Oct. 17 talk on Brexit at the Providence Committee on Foreign Relations. The Brexiteers had/have little idea on how to actually do Brexit. They have operated with bombast, ignorance and wishful thinking. Fear and chaos still reign as the deadline fast approaches.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.