Whitcomb: RI's Education Debate; Congestion Pricing; Obama and Goldman Money; Fewer Cold Waves?

GoLocalProv

Whitcomb: RI's Education Debate; Congestion Pricing; Obama and Goldman Money; Fewer Cold Waves?

Robert Whitcomb, columnist
“It’s then I hear a voice,

a crystal shining icicle clear voice,

cold water but made of sound,

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

tells me, keep my connection to the spirits strong.’’

 

-- From “Winter Along the Rio Grande,’’ by Jimmy Santiago Baca

 

Tolls and Congestion Pricing

Connecticut will likely reimpose highway tolls (on trucks or trucks and cars) in the next couple of years. (The state had tolls on the “Connecticut Turnpike,’’ aka Route 95, until 1985.) Meanwhile, Massachusetts is mulling jacking up tolls for people driving in rush hours in Greater Boston – the sort of “congestion pricing’’ now used in some cities in Europe and in Singapore. Both programs would probably speed traffic by taking a lot of people off the roads and onto expanded mass transit, which the new tolls should help pay for, along with road repairs. And user fees seem to me the fairest form of taxation.

 

Foxconned

Yet another giveaway to big business is going at least partly sour: Foxconn, the huge Taiwanese electronics company to which Wisconsin’s now ousted  GOP Tea Party governor, Scott Walker, promised around $3 billion in taxpayer-funded incentives in return for building a  huge factory, now says its core promise – that it would hire thousands of people to make flat-panel display screens in the Badger State – won’t be fulfilled. As it turns out, big-time manufacturing in America doesn’t make sense for the company. So the company may do little or no manufacturing here.

 

Meanwhile, Reuters reported that in 2018, the first year of the Wisconsin {Foxconn} experiment, Foxconn hired  178 people instead of the promised 260.

 

Most economists agree that creating and maintaining high-quality public education and physical infrastructure – transportation and water and other utilities – and  fair and efficient tax and regulatory regimes attractive to business, in general, is the way to go – not bribing a big company to come – and sticking much of the bill on companies and individuals already in the jurisdiction. And the big sexy company might leave faster than it came.

 

 

Questions for R.I. Education Debaters

As the heated conversations continue about how to improve public education in Rhode Island, a few questions, among others, should be asked:

 

What can be done to make special education, which of course is very expensive, more cost-effective?

 

To what extent, if any, do charter schools drain money from regular public schools?

 

What can be done to discipline the many Rhode Island public-school teachers with outrageous levels of absenteeism?

 

Loud Music, Soft-Spoken Staff                                            

Increasingly, loud pop music fills commercial spaces, be they stores or hotel lobbies. I hate it and seek out places without music, unless it’s classical, jazz or what used to be called “standards’’ - old popular tunes). On second thought, make it just silence.

 

There’s the seeming paradox of the soft-spokenness of the young employees of these establishments co-existing with the ambient cacophony, such as in the very hip Row Hotel, in Manhattan, where I  recently spent a night (by 3 a.m. it seemed a week)  and where most of the employees seem to have been under 30. As I do in CVS drugstores, with their racket, I asked an employee if she minded the noise. “After a while, we don’t hear it,’’ she answered.

 

 

Anti-Intelligence

Trump’s rejection of the findings presented by all the leading U.S. intelligence officials about the biggest immediate threats to our national security is simply another indication of how dangerous he is to national security. Who knows what mixture of ignorance, egomania, and corruption explains his bizarre reaction? The creature in the Oval Office is a far bigger threat to national security than what’s happening on our southern border.

 

 

Socialism, Fascism and Social Democrats

I wish that people would stop calling Venezuelan dictator Nicolas Maduro a “socialist.’’ He’s governing like a typical fascist thug and kleptocrat. Indeed, his ouster would set an unsettling precedent for such other fascist dictators as Vladimir Putin and Turkey’s Tayyip Erdogan, who thus loudly support their fellow dictator. And I wish that so many in the media wouldn’t confuse social democrats, such as the young Juan Guaido, the president of Venezuela’s National Assembly, with Maduro-like “socialists,” which the right likes to associate in the public mind with Communists. (By the way, the anti-Communist George Orwell was a socialist.) Social democracy has been very good for the prosperity, vibrant democracy and quality of life of some nations, most notably in northern Europe. Of course, having a relatively homogenous society makes social democracy a lot easier. It probably wouldn’t work in the much more complicated U.S.

 

Anyway, let’s hope that Maduro is tossed out, even if that requires our outbribing some of the generals that Maduro has bribed to keep himself in power.  That would be good Trump corruption.

 

 

Fewer Cold Snaps

A Jan. 31 article in Bloomberg News, “Dangerous Cold Snaps Feel Even Worse Because They’re Now So Rare,’’ puts last week’s arctic attack in perspective. The authors write: “Temperature data since 1970 suggest that sudden freezes used to be much more normal, and the U.S. hasn’t had a good, old-fashioned cold streak in more than two decades.’’ Well, that assertion is debatable, but they usefully cite the work of Ken Kunkel, a researcher at North Carolina State University and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Atmosphere who for two decades has maintained a “cold wave index’’ record. Bloomberg explains that the index tracks “how often multi-day wintry blasts descend on the U.S.’’ Mr. Kunkel’s chart clearly shows a decline in the frequency of cold waves.

 

Rapid warming of the Arctic, linked to fossil-fuel burning, has screwed up the jet stream, which in turn sometimes lets big pockets of extremely cold air from Siberia and Canada move into the Mideast and Northeast, even as western North America gets much warmer than “normal’’.  Ah, the “polar vortex’’. I love the hysteria that phrase creates!

 

Then the jet stream waviness changes and Mideast and Northeast turn much milder than normal, which is predicted for this week. To read the Bloomberg piece and chart, please hit this link:

 

 

 

Pence Bad for Christianity

The assertion of Vice President Mike Pence and sidekicks that American Christianity is threatened by attacks in the “Mainstream Media’’ and other parts of secular culture is absurd, although these allegations may help them raise money and otherwise boost their influence in Republican circles. American Christians, like adherents of other religions, can practice their faith any way they want as long as they don’t violate the legal rights of others.

 

The biggest threat to Mr. Pence’s version of Christianity is the growing disenchantment, especially among the young, with organized religion. That in part stem from the corruption of evangelical “Christians’’ using TV and other media to make piles of money for themselves and to expand their personal power through promotion of GOP programs.

 

 

President Barack Obama
Obama and Payments from Goldman Sachs

Barack Obama’s speeches, for hundreds of thousands of dollars each, to the likes of Goldman Sachs can only reinforce the idea that high-level politics is a way to make a fortune – undermining respect for public service. It’s hard to believe that Harry Truman would take no fees for speaking engagements after his presidency because he thought it would undermine the dignity of the office.

 

And enough of these havens/palaces of tax-free hagiography called “presidential libraries’’ to which influence-seeking companies and individuals give piles of money.

 

 

The Weight of War

The novel Warlight, by Michael Ondaatje (who also wrote The English Patient, among other books), is an often riveting psychological and spy thriller. Mostly set in London and the English countryside, Ondaatje tells the story of a family roiled by “special services’’ work during World War II and the effects of that work, some of it traumatic, over decades, mostly from the view of a man who, with his sister, lived, as teens, under a bizarre guardianship in wartime London after the mysterious disappearance of their parents.

 

Of course, I wasn’t in London then, but based on what people who were there have told me, and from what I’ve read, the portrayal of London in the war and post-war seems spot on. Reading the book reminded me of the grim black-and-white photos of the still-bombed-out parts of London I used to see as a kid reading the Illustrated London News in the late ‘50s.

 

Tom Brokaw
Brokaw and the Melting Pot

Tom Brokaw, of NBC News and a writer (The Greatest Generation, etc.), has gotten himself into hot water with some Hispanic Americans over his suggestion that “Hispanics should work harder at assimilation.’’ He was accused of xenophobia.

 

Brokaw subsequently apologized for the comment. “I feel terrible a part of my comments on Hispanics offended some members of that proud culture,” Brokaw tweeted. “I never intended to disparage any segment of our rich, diverse society which defines who we are.”

 

In fact, the usually very diplomatic Mr. Brokaw was right. In part because of the vast number of immigrants from Mexico and Central America in the past few decades, many have been slower to assimilate than earlier waves of immigrants, which were of course mostly from Europe. In particular, the sheer size of the growing Hispanic community has reduced the pressure to learn English – knowledge of which is essential for full integration into American society. In some parts of the United States, it’s possible to only have to speak Spanish.

 

A National Academy of Sciences study found:

 

….”Spanish-speakers and their descendants appear to be integrating more slowly in terms of both gaining English language and losing the ability to speak the immigrant language than other immigrant groups (Alba, 2005; Borjas, 2013).

 

“A major reason is the larger size and frequent replenishment of the Spanish-speaking population in the United States (Linton and Jimenez, 2009). ‘’

 

To read the study, please hit this link:

 

At the same time, the decline in American schools’ civics and history instruction has eroded the knowledge in the general population of the nation’s institutions, laws and culture – a general knowledge that has helped hold together the country with the world’s widest range of background ethnicities and national cultures. Indeed, surveys have shown that even students at so-called elite colleges are alarmingly ignorant about the unique characteristics (and origin thereof) of the nation’s institutions and traditions. If you don’t know where you’ve been, you don’t know where you’re going….

 

The rise of “multiculturalism’’ in recent decades has helped lead to widening political divisions. It’s fine to respect and retain some cultural traditions from abroad, such as having a second or even third language (after mastering the great unifying mongrel language English), various cuisines and sports and celebrating events associated with admirable aspects of the cultures from which citizens, or their ancestors, came. However, to encourage the idea that being American is no more important, or perhaps less important, than that of one’s ethnic background is a road to national suicide. To last, we need considerable cultural cohesion, not a nation riven by identity politics – the reaction to which helped put into the Oval Office the con man/demagogue Donald J. Trump

 

The National Association of Hispanic Journalists denounced Mr. Brokaw, saying: “It only further demonstrates Brokaw’s lack of understanding of what forced assimilation does to communities.’’ And the organization’s president, Hugo Balta, said that ‘’assimilation is denying one culture for another.’’

But as National Review’s Rich Lowry noted: “It is astonishing that in the formulation ‘the other’ is American culture. We are perhaps the only nation in world history that has sought to ‘otherize’ its own culture.’’

 

The rise of identity politics in which one’s ethnic background is seen as more important than as identity as an American does not bode well for the country’s political stability and prosperity. We need to fire up the old melting pot.

 

The Law and Biodiversity

John Charles Kunich, a professor at the Roger Williams School of Law, has written a very useful, if highly technical, book called Ark of the Broken Covenant: Protecting the World’s Biodiversity Hotspots. Professor Kunich proposes a new statutory program to help stem the wave of extinctions, deforestation and other human-caused ecological devastation.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.