Providence Teachers Union Leadership Fight Escalates Over Audits, Seniority

GoLocalProv News Team and Kate Nagle

Providence Teachers Union Leadership Fight Escalates Over Audits, Seniority

A showdown is looming for the future of the Providence Teachers Union.
The Providence Teachers Union (PTU) is holding its upcoming leadership elections on May 11, and the back-and-forth between the existing leadership structure — and opposition slate —is heating up, with one side accusing the other of defamation. 

Melissa Cimini, a special education teacher with nineteen years in the Providence Public School Department (PPSD), is challenging curent PTU President Maribeth Calabro on a platform of having the union become a “proactive and unified” organization. 

“We need a PTU leader that will not remain silent on important issues such as the following,” Cimini wrote in a Facebook post on April 12. “Inclusion positions are being cut and students have minimal or no support in their classes. IEPs are approved without sufficient service times. Newcomer students are being placed in classes with no support. I will advocate for proper supports for our teachers and students. We wouldn't allow this to happen to our own children and we can't allow the district to do this to our students any longer.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Both current Treasurer Alex Lucinin and Calabro fired back at the opposition on social media. 

“Amazing that our opponent is making accusations about finances but has never once reached to me (the treasurer) with questions regarding union finances. Our organization is audited yearly and receives the highest possible rating. Maribeth Reynolds-Calabro and our slate work tirelessly to stand up for teachers. I wish our opponents vigor and energy continued when real challenges occur and not during campaign season,” said Lucini. 

“How can you say you want change when your campaign promises are things that I already do? We have been having independent audits for over 12 years! Hmm, so you want me to stop having an independent audit every year? You want me to stop getting the highest rating offered by an auditor? That's your idea of change? Doing what I already do? Good luck with that,” wrote Calabro. 

Candidates Weigh In

PTU President Maribeth Calabro
Cimini said Tuesday that she’s running so that “teachers have a voice.”

“First and for most, I feel that we don’t have a voice,” said Cimini. “When our last contract was ratified, around 340 members voted. That’s around 16% our our roughly 2000 members.  I feel there’s been a lack of honesty about what the language means for teachers and job security, and that they just wanted a quick deal.  There’s issues of nepotism and teachers are maxed out and stressed and feel that the union doesn’t always have their back, we’re told that we should fear retaliation, but that’s not why we pay dues — we pay dues to not fear retaliation.” 

Cimini said she took issue with where new jobs were going, versus where she thinks they're needed.

“The district just came out with three jobs for central administration for close to $160,000 but we don’t have enought help for kids in the classroom. The union needs to be vocal about these things.  It’s not about job security it’s about what’s best for our students,” said Cimini.  “But when the current leadership does away with seniority when it comes to layoffs, you need a strong leader who says we need fair and equitable conditions.”

Calabro, who countered a number of Cimini’s claims, said that she in fact “solidified seniority” in the most recent contract.  

“It’s a false claim that I gave away seniority,” said Calabro. “It’s actually dictated by state law.  Seniority is always a factor in layoffs as it pertains to a decrease in student population, but not in terms of financial issues, when the district can’t afford a certain numbers of teachers.  I actually solidified seniority."

Audit Availability at Center of Dispute

Challenger Melissa Cimini
Cimini that she and her slate wanted more information about the union’s finances — and say in how they’re spent. 

“I’ve heard they’ve accused me of slander. I’m just putting out the facts. Last time there was a union vote, they chose one school for 2000 teachers, and I waited in line for an hour and half.  We don’t know where it’s going to be next month. We pay nearly $2 million in dues, and they’ve refused to consider absentee ballots - and that’s a common complaint on both sides. People can’t always wait an hour to vote. This should be for voting on contracts as well,” said Cimini, who said she has a “five-zone plan” for voting. “If we’ve got to spend another $5,000, I believe people would support it.”

“The bottom line is anyone can have an annual audit, but we don’t get to see expenditures,” said Cimini. “They said, you can come to the union office and do it there. No, it’s public knowledge. I’ve proposed more parent community involvement. Why don’t we have a part-time person working for us? The [Providence School Department] has one. A lot of parents need our help. They trust the district, which doesn’t always work out for them.  We could help them advocate for their position — I believe we could find that money for a position easily.”

Calabro, who has been president since 2014 after being elected following the retirement of Steve Smith and had previously served as Vice President at large since 2003, said that the opposition slate was putting out “false information” that is “defamatory.”

“One of the last things someone showed me was that [Cimini] said she’ll have a forensic audit every year. We’ve had one every year for the past twelve years.  All have been given the highest rating we can get,” said Calabro. “Look, she’s run before, both times her platform has been 'change.' If you’re asking for change, I already do the audit, are you changing that practice?"

“I think [the attacks] have risen to the level of defamation. If it were based in fact or truth, that would be fine, everyone’s entitled to make comment. But when you make it appear that thing are not happening, that’s defamation,” said Calabro. “I have all of the [audit] records.}

Calabro said that the union’s financials were "not public" when asked by GoLocal, but “any member could ask to seem them.”


Top High Schools in Rhode Island 2015

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.