Defeated DeSimone to Run Write-In Campaign — Historically Never a Successful Path

Kate Nagle, GoLocalProv News Editor

Defeated DeSimone to Run Write-In Campaign — Historically Never a Successful Path

Defeated John DeSimone
Democratic House Majority Leader John DeSimone made national news in September, but not positive news. He was beaten by upstart Marcia Ranglin-Vassell in the Democratic primary.

Now, DeSimone is threatening to run a write-in campaign in a desperate attempt to regain his House seat.

Ranglin-Vassell responded to the news of DeSimone’s campaign by issuing the following statement on Facebook on Tuesday night.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

"The House Majority Leader that I beat twice in the Primary election is mounting a write-in challenge," wrote Ranglin-Vassell, referring to the primary election -- and recount. "He does not seem to understand that District 5 voters have spoken and that they need ethical and compassionate people (me )to fight for all of us not just the well connected."

According to the most available campaign finance reports, at "7 Days Before Primary," DeSimone had $72,439.22 cash on hand and Ranglin-Vassell reported $823.61.  

DeSimone is not the only one running a write-in this fall. GoLocal was first to report that incumbent Jan Malik, who was defeated by Jason Knight in District 67, is looking for the write-in nod. 

Marcia Ranglin-Vassell
Malik, who was first elected to the district that represents parts of Barrington and Warren in 1996, lost to Knight with 637 votes to Knight's 867. 

Libertarian Daryl Gould is currently on the ballot against Knight in November.

Malik's Statement

Malik made the announcement on Facebook on Monday.

"Columbus Day seems to be an appropriate one to announce that I, Jan Malik, am back in the much talked about race. Just as Columbus set sail and had to navigate through many unseen obstacles, I too am up for the challenge that lies ahead in the upcoming weeks. Due to an outpouring of support from Barrington and Warren voters after the primary results, I did a lot of soul searching," wrote Malik.

His opponent Gould, however, questioned the move. 

"Whether it's me or anyone else, I think democracy works better with choice. I wonder about Malik's true motivation though," said Gould. "I know that Jan is upset about the way the campaign was run, and might want to go out guns blazing against Knight, before he rides off into the sunset."

"What I don't understand is why you wouldn't announce the day after the primary," added Gould. "Why would you use Columbus Day as a symbol? I mean, here's a guy who essentially lost his way, and Forrest Gumped his way to a new land."

Historical Races

Speaker John Harwood
In 2002, Speaker Harwood Almost Beaten 

In 2002, Bruce Bayuk ran a spirited write in campaign against then-Speaker John Harwood.

“Speaker Harwood barely squeaks by write-in challenger Bruce Bayuk amid evidence of voting irregularities and charges of voting fraud. After investigations and recounts by the Board of Elections, Harwood remains the victor,” wrote historian Phil West in his book “Secrets and Scandals.”

Harwood defeated Bayuk by 291 votes, according to revised figures from the Pawtucket Board of Canvassers.

West wrote, "University of Rhode Island political science professor Marc A. Genest thought the close result undid Harwood as speaker: “He may be the only candidate elected who actually loses. He’s a dead man walking.” 

Woonsocket Rep. Thought He Could Prevail 

As GoLocal MINDSETTER™ Donna Perry wrote on October 25, 2012, “Taxpayers in Woonsocket will get the chance to right a wrong - or write a wrong - in less than two weeks when they go to the polls. Ousted House Representative Jon Brien, who was overtaken in September’s Democratic Primary battle against firefighter candidate Stephen Casey, is back on the ballot on November 6. Brien is waging an energetic write-in campaign to retake his District 50 seat.”

Brien lost badly only garnering 31% of the vote to Casey’s 69%.

Councilman Kevin Jackson
East Side Battle in 2014

Embattled Providence City Councilman Kevin Jackson, who is now facing charges by the RI Attorney General, fought off a very credible write in campaign in 2014 to hold his seat in the Third Ward. Jackson won by the slimmest of margins 50.7% (1955) to 49.3% (1900) for write-in opponent Marcus Mitchell.

In 2010, Three Democrats Tried

In late September of 2010, three Democrats defeated by unions in the primary announced that they weren't about to call it quits. The three incumbents—Doug Gablinske, Mary Ann Shallcross Smith, and Al Gemma—announced they would run write-in campaigns for the general election.

GoLocalProv reported:

At a Statehouse press conference, the three vowed to continue their fight for pension reform and be an independent voice for voters.

Former Rep. Gablinski failed in a write-in
“We do this collectively to make the point that each of us was targeted for defeat by special interests, which are first and foremost more interested in protecting their pensions, than they are about the viability of the State of Rhode Island or anything else,” said Gablinske, of Bristol.

“The news coverage of how these outside-of-district special interest forces have collaborated and inserted themselves into our General Assembly races has certainly gotten the attention of people in our respective districts,” Gablinske added. He said people had been calling the three state reps, urging them to continue on and offering to volunteer and donate. “Our guess is that they are mad as hell and won’t put up with it anymore.”

Gablinske and Shallcross Smith, of Lincoln, said they continue to identify as Democrats. Gemma described himself as both a traditional Democrat and an independent.

Gemma noted that 14 percent of registered voters in his district turned out in the primary. He said he was running in the general election to give the other 86 percent a “second chance.”

Gablinske denied that the three write-in campaigns could toss the race to the Republican candidates in their districts.  

None of the three regained their seats.
 


Rhode Island's Best Communities 2016

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.